The Jackal

(dir. Michael Caton-Jones)

You may have read my preview of The Jackal in BCN last summer – except that at the time of the test screenings it was called The Final Contract. So what happened between the test screening and general release?

Well, they trimmed out some less interesting bits and replaced them with distractions from the central story, and in the process diluted some of the tension. They also trimmed out some of the exciting bits, giving it a slight feeling of sex with the orgasm taken out when you were expecting one.

The kiss in the gay nightclub that Bruce Willis gave his victim was toned down from a full ‘with tongues’ to merely a smacker, and this time evoked an amused response from the audience instead of a disgusted one. My feeling is that the more mature audience we were with this time would have taken it in their stride anyway, even in Wimbledon where we watched it. And apparently Richard Gere ordered the scene where the gay decoy gets shot, to be re-shot to make it clear he isn’t being shot because he’s gay. Well, I don’t know what he was so het up about, because from my memory, in the test screening Bruce Willis’s character shot him (the gay decoy) because he was going through his (Willis’s) bags, not because his hair was a bit too bouffant.

All in all, you would have enjoyed the test screening a lot more, blue matte and all.

Mike H

In and Out

(dir. Frank Oz)

Dreadful young actor outs his old English teacher at the Oscars. The conservative small town of Greenleaf, Indiana is horrified. Is Howard Brackett (Kevin Kline) really gay and will his marriage go ahead?

There’s a case for this film I suppose. It is a 12 certificate, playing in multiplexes across the land, which shows a full on male-to-male snog; which argues that coming out is good and which ridicules homophobia; which says to male students ‘hey, having a gay teacher is a bit weird but you can get used to it’. It even points out that life is unfair and gay people can get sacked from their job.

in+out So why am I so unenthusiastic? (Papers like the Mail and Sun loved it; I am with the liberal press which sneered.) I suppose because it is a light and fluffy comedy but it is not always that funny. It could have been sharper and wittier – I laughed a bit and cringed more. In and Out shows what you can get away with in mainstreamland – it manages to land a few medium blows on the Oscars, a target beyond satire – but it also shows what you cannot get away with. There are three places where I thought ‘Dear God, they are going to do something surprising’ but the film carefully took the safest option. Without giving away the plot, these are when a high school student stands up and says he’s gay, the wedding at the end, and the meeting of actor and #mentor (the dirty-minded will ask how come the younger man is so sure Brackett is gay…?) In each case, any frisson is carefully milked and then shut off. It is a film which ridicules the idea that gay teachers might ‘infect’ straight pupils, but which can’t cope with the complexity of having an under-age kid come out. I know gay (etc) teachers, and yes, like straight teachers, they are not unaware of the attractive students. They cope with it. That is what being a responsible grown-up is about.

In the end this film has more sociological interest than ‘must see’ value. It may be a nominal milestone in the growing acceptance of non-straight sexuality. (In and Out, first male kiss rated #suitable for young adults.) And I suppose when you look at the tortured Dirk Bogarde in Victim, we have come some way forward. I just find peddling watered-down stereotypes less than amusing.

Steve C

Dancing on the edge

Richard Holloway

(Fount, £8.99)

The Christian crazy gang are drawing the line at poofs. Press reports suggest that around a quarter of the United Reformed Church are ready to split because of a decision to allow (for the time being) ordination of gay and lesbian priests. In the Anglican Church, conservative parishes are breaking canon law by refusing to acknowledge bishops who they think are unsound on the sodomy issue. Sex seems to be the hot issue that may allow the conservatives to take over, or to split, several historic denominations. (Women priests was never quite such an issue because some very conservative Protestants still support women’s ordination.)

Richard Holloway is the Anglican Bishop of Edinburgh, and this book is not solely about sex. However he is no doubt already down on lists as ready to be purged by the self-proclaimed forces of light. Holloway slags off religion based on fear and welcomes doubt and experiment – he argues for a sexual ethic which is broad enough to encompass most things BCN readers get up to. (He wants gays to be able to marry in church but he doesn’t prescribe marriage for straights or gays.) His constant refrain is that the Church is for real people as they are, and he comes up with the extraordinary idea that it should not lecture people about their sex lives or indeed any aspect of their behaviour. Some of us think that is what it has historically seen as its mission. Above all, he argues that the fanatics don’t have a monopoly on truth, or the Church. (I won’t try your patience with the arguments from within Christianity against fundamentalism, only to say that they are numerous and sound.) He says the Church will just have to live with different views on pervery, just as it fails to agree on abortion, divorce, war and economics. Unfortunately, his opponents have absolutely no intention of cohabiting with good humoured thoughtful liberals. The struggle ahead is going to get very nasty, but it will be fun if Holloway’s side wins.

Steve C