Interviewed by Rachael House
Charlotte Cooper, fat rights activist, writer, zinester, performer and queer-girl-about-town has written a book: ‘Fat and Proud: the politics of size’. In her dizzy social whirl she found time to tell BCN readers about her work.
Charlotte:The book’s about fat politics from a British perspective. It’s in a new direction because most of the work that’s been published here is in the context of eating disorders and this book criticises that quite a lot. Also, the British work that was influential to me I think is very tame and very safe and I wanted to write something that was informed much more by fat rights work in the US, which is much more radical, angry and exciting than what’s happening in Britain, which seems to be more about finding nice clothes to fit.
The book covers women’s experiences of fat hatred. Unfortunately I haven’t been allowed to write about men, which I think is a shame because it’s something that needs to be addressed. I use interview material from lots of fat women with different perspectives. There’s a lot of material in the book that criticises fat being defined in terms of health because I’m very interested in fat rights as a social movement, about civil rights. In the same way that disabled people are critical of medicalisation when things can also be read in a social context, fat people can do that. We shouldn’t just see fat in terms of fitness and health; those arguments have been very detrimental. In the book I talk about this new civil rights movement of fat people; I think this follows black, women’s and gay civil rights movements – they share many patterns.
A lot of fat rights ideas have gained common currency now and I’m quite critical of some of them, for example the notion that it was OK to be fat in the past. I think the debates are important because they show that fat hatred isn’t always going to be around, but the way those arguments are used glosses over important details, for example the position of women in the past. So in the book I’ve tried to introduce people to basic arguments about fat rights, but I’ve tried to develop these arguments.
Rachael: I hadn’t heard of set point weight theory before and felt uncomfortable with it. It seemed to be saying that people have an ideal weight – so maybe mine would be a stone lighter than I am so I’d be ‘overweight’.
C: SPW is very popular among fat rights advocates because it takes away the notion that you’re absolutely responsible for the size of your body, but at the same time, being fat is much more complex to me than just my biological functioning – to rest everything on one theory, genes or SPW, is very dangerous. What happens if that theory is disproved? Fat people come from every walk of life; to say that people are fat because of this one thing is not true. Mostly I think ‘who cares why we’re fat?’ We just are.
There are lots of things in the manuscript not included in the final book that I wish had been included. They weren’t included because the Women’s Press were ideologically opposed to them. I call it censorship; they call it something else, editing I think.
The things they wouldn’t allow me to say included ‘queer’, which is how I define myself. I call myself ‘bisexual’ as well, but I feel more at home with queer because I think of it as being anti-authoritarian, bisexual doesn’t have those connotations to me. They also cut out references to transgendered people. There’s a whole strand of argument that thinks fat is inherently womanly and I said transgendered people have shown you can alter your body and notions like feminine and masculine are very fluid.
They wanted no references to SM which pissed me off because that’s part of my sexuality and I’ve found it very liberating to play and have fun with my body.
They didn’t want me to mention a zine called Fat Girl, which is very close to my heart, because they believe it promotes pornography. I wanted to thank Fat Girl in my acknowledgments page and they wouldn’t allow me to even thank them. They also asked me whether other sources I’d used promoted porn or SM; I said no they did not – including your zine Rachael! (laughter)
The fact that I couldn’t use the word queer upset me most. They allowed me to call myself ‘bisexual’ but changed queer to lesbian. There’s a passage where I say that people involved with early fat rights were queer and that makes me very proud; now it reads that the people involved were lesbian and that makes me very proud. I don’t think they noticed the difference and what that meant.
R: Do you see your sexuality as having informed your fat politics?
C: I do. When I was younger all the things I read were about sex in some way, and were critical of mainstream values and culture. I think having that view and calling myself queer has enabled me to not get sucked into the idea that you have to look a certain way or you’re invalid. It also helps being sexy and being fancied, going out and being cruisy and all that kind of stuff, it makes me feel that I’m pretty hot!
Men and women fancy me pretty much the same. I don’t find that dykes or bi women are any more or less fat-phobic than men. I think there’s a myth that dykes are cooler but I don’t think that’s true.
R: How fat-positive is the bi community?
C: I don’t know if I’m qualified to talk about the bi community, I don’t really feel like a member of it. I don’t subscribe to BCN, I don’t go to meetings, I spent half an hour at the last Bicon and that was to have a cup of tea with my friend. But it’s one of the few places were I haven’t been totally laughed out of the door for mentioning fat stuff – that’s valuable. If you’re part of a community that’s experienced exclusion and ridicule that might give you a greater propensity to understand other things, but that’s quite utopian and idealistic.
When we did that fat workshop at Bicon a couple of years ago the response was really good. I think the Bi Community is idealistic and it’s a good place to be discussing new ideas.
R: You’ve likened the bi community when we’ve talked before as similar to the fat community in this country, as being quite new and full of freaks (laughter).
C: Yeah, true, I like that freakiness, it’s not so full of cynicism.
R: How famous are you now Charlotte?
C: I’ve only been recognised a couple of times, I’m not famous enough for the dole office to cut off my benefit. I’m famous enough to go to the Women’s Press 20th Anniversary party and people came up to me and said ‘Oh you’re Charlotte Cooper.’ I’m famous enough that all my friends are going out to buy my book and they’re very excited about me. I’m famous enough that my friends are treating me differently now that I’ve been in the papers a few times, that’s quite funny. I’ve got to wait a while before I make any money from this, before the royalties start coming in. I’m not in the Madonna league, not very famous Rachael.
R: So should I ask my next question? What’s the best thing about being famous?
C: The best thing about being a bit famous is that people come up and say ‘I really like your work.’ It’s very gratifying going into a bookshop and seeing your book there, even though it’s published by you know who and they cut so much out. Oh, and maybe I’ll get more shags too.
R: Tell us about your next projects.
C: I’ve got lots of things lined up, a film script with Jewels about village life and how nasty it is, a little thing about censorship, a novel about bad girls having fun with lots of sex and violence.
R: Are the Women’s Press going to publish it?
C: They might, you never know! I’m still doing zines, I’ve got a new Kink coming out this week, lots of story zines, I’m still packing porn and still doing my cleaning job. My life’s a mixture of drudgery and glamour at the moment.
Fat and Proud by Charlotte Cooper, Women’s Press, £8.99
Kink and other zines are available from (historic contact details deleted)
