The Pink and Purple Pound revisited

To pay or not to pay?

The bisexual community is reliant upon its ‘community workers’ who perform the vital functions of keeping the community alive – I’m thinking of the BCN collective, the people who organise Bicon and other bi events, the people who run the phoneline, local groups, people who produce books and other magazines, and the people who maintain the bi.org website. In this respect it is the same as other communities such as the environmental movement, or even a geographical community such as a large housing estate or a village.

Many such communities start off small, or with a low level of activity. When evidence of the success spreads the community begins to grow or the level of activity rises, and then the community workers can begin to feel the pressure, as demand for their work grows. A common question then looms: ‘Should we pay our workers?’.

As well as relating to size or activity, this question often arises alongside a feeling of recognition for your community. In a recent article Alison wrote ‘I think the community needs to grow into normal society so that we don’t need a community any more’. I don’t wish to assign a wrong meaning to her words, but the quote is similar to words I’ve heard in other communities as people begin to feel justified in their own actions and value them equally or more highly than the activities which are perceived as ‘the real world’ or ‘normal society’: where people ‘earn their living’.

£ £ £ £ £ £ £

Not to pay

Many people decide that the nature of their community would change if they were to introduce hard economic values into it, and somehow a decision is made or a feeling emerges that things should stay voluntary. In this case, the key factor is the number of activists: in BCN25 Steve P. commented, ‘whilst people come into the (bi) community, they are balanced by those leaving… the community is essentially stagnant’.

If new energy doesn’t keep joining, people burn out, or leave because of the pressure. Or the people involved may be willing and able to take on more, but should they then cease to be able to donate their time (maybe having to get a paid job to earn their living), whole projects fall apart because the skills were not shared widely enough, or there is just too much to do and no one to do it.

£ £ £ £ £ £ £

To pay

Creating paid work within the community can be seen as ‘valuing’ that work as highly as ‘conventional jobs’, or it can simply be seen as a necessity – ‘no-one’s gonna volunteer to do all this, we’ll have to pay someone’. It can solve the problem of your key people having to leave to earn some money, but the community or organisation within it has to recognise that it is a big step to take, and it does inherently change the way the organisation works.

Even more than with volunteers, it is essential to make sure the paid workers do skill and knowledge share – they may well move on (or get run over by a not-so-proverbial bus) and many a group has found itself with no-one else who knows how a key system works.

There are other practical problems, like supervision, but I want to concentrate on the nature of the beast, and the bi community.

£ £ £ £ £ £ £

Inequality

Within a volunteer-run community there is a cosy feeling of equality – we’re all in this together and chipping in. Sure, some people are seen not to contribute and just ‘take’ without ‘giving’, but as soon as the question of payment arises, things become far more polarised.

Take Bicon as an example: we attend, it’s a wonderful experience, but there are always a few problems. However, we know that a few hardy souls have given a lot of their spare time to organising it and can’t be expected to get everything right. Now imagine that Bicon enters the professional league, and the people who organise it are making a wage from it. I think you’ll find that many people who attend would now feel that ‘this is their job, if they can’t do it well they ought to be sacked’ and treat it much more like a product to be bought. And would all the workshop leaders and people who contribute small but vital amounts of help be happy donating their time to ‘help someone else line their pockets’?

£ £ £ £ £ £ £

Economic Necessities

In my previous article I argued that the power of the pink or purple pound can be harnessed to further the cause of the bisexual community by spending your pounds within the community and avoiding paying people who actively discriminate. I was referring to, for example, buying from businesses run by bisexuals or sympathisers. So here I ask, why should their businesses not provide the facilities that are vital to our community? If there’s a market for bi-orientated camps, retreats, conferences, pornography/erotica then how do we decide who should provide it? I see three options: a) a ‘community volunteer’ basis; b) not-for-profit organisations that pay wages to their workers; c) businesses where the profits are for the owners.

£ £ £ £ £ £ £

Finding the Bisexual Balance

I hasten to make the point that I’m not of the belief that ‘to do something properly you have to pay someone’. I think Bicon and BCN amongst others show that people can indeed do things in a professional way when they are volunteers. But I am in favour of people earning a living doing useful things (only then can we get away from the notion that unwanted activities are necessary because ‘we need the jobs’).

I therefore suggest that anyone who comes up with an idea for a bisexual event or product should not shy away from marketing it and trying to earn reward for their time organising or producing it. And I’d love to see the day when Bicon and BCN are set up as not-for-profit co-operatives with one or two part-time staff earning a basic wage for their efforts. We might even get the all-singing all-dancing Bicon linked in with film festivals, gigs etc. that Tom Robinson referred to.

As long as we always know who’s benefiting in what way, we can make our choice as to what to support with our help or our pounds. Openness, honesty, diversity and a balance will benefit us just as much in the economic spheres as in the sexual.

Krayg