A new UN report lays bare the Westminster government’s failings on human rights.
The United Nations Independent Expert on protection against violence and discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity’s report is based on a week of visiting and observing the current situation, meeting with representatives of over . Their report is here.
After the 1967 Sexual Offences Act partially decriminalised sex between the UK complied with various court rulings to advance LGBT rights, most notably extending that decriminalisation to Scotland and Northern Ireland. A few steps were taken voluntarily under Labour from 1997 to 2010 while more were similarly ruled by courts – gender recognition, an equal age of consent, or allowing LGBT people to serve in the armed forces for example were fought against by the government and eventually legislated. England and Wales then introduced same-sex marriage and rolled back the blood donation ban under the Conservative – Liberal Democrat coalition from 2010 to 2015, with separate similar measures following in Scotland and Northern Ireland.
Since then however things have been different: progress stalling under the Conservative majority government from 2015-2017 and the Conservative – DUP arrangement from 2017 to 2019, and then actively moving backwards since 2019 including Westminster overruling the Scottish Parliament over powers that had been devolved to it.
As such the report reflects on how we got to where we are:
National, imperial, and colonial histories of the United Kingdom include leading roles in criminalization, pathologization and actual or attempted erasure of gender diversity. At the national level, as recently as 1979, the use of homophobic and biphobic attitudes, and their instrumentalization through the media, led to the enactment of a series of guidelines within the school curricula that aimed at prohibiting comprehensive sexuality education; they also led to the enactment of Section 28, an infamous piece of public policy that created lasting damage on LGBT persons and institutions.
They look at the damaging public ‘debate’ over human dignity:
(In) meetings with authorities in Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland, national authorities and civil society representatives expressed concerns regarding where the UK government stood on the protection of human rights of LGBT persons in line with international standards
While the focus of public hate speech is around trans people’s freedom to live in mainstream society, and this is reflected in the report, there are plenty of other current issues. For example they note:
[…] significant data gaps in relation to the number of LGBT persons experiencing homelessness in the UK, which was one of the main challenges in adopting effective policies in this area. For instance, only 3% of people accessing services for homeless persons were recorded as self–reporting to be lesbian, gay or bisexual, whereas 22.6% reportedly preferred not to say their sexual orientations in survey data. Authorities noted that the lack of clarity in the data could also represent service providers being unwilling to ask service recipients about their sexual orientations and recording the data inaccurately as a result.
It makes detailed, if saddening, reading. It concludes on as positive a note as it can:
It is telling that, during the visit, the current environment was uniformly described as toxic by stakeholders across the board, without exception, all of those who he met declared themselves unable to suggest a winning formula for making inroads in a situation that has been driven to a state of such acrimony. Yet, it is the very British people who have for decades inspired the world to know what to do in such situations of confusion: keep calm. Examine the evidence. The evidence shows that there is nothing to fear in the existence of LGBT persons, and much to celebrate in the diversity that they bring to our common humanity. Keep calm. Examine the evidence. Respect Diversity.
Yep. Keep calm. Examine the evidence. Respect Diversity. Don’t respect fascism.
