The Celluloid Closet

(Rob Epstein, Jeffery Freidman 1995)

This film (also shown on Channel 4 recently) takes a look at homophobia in Hollywood. It shows how homosexuality and bisexuality was included in the US films of the late twenties and early thirties only to be suppressed by censorship until the late sixties/early seventies.

It is a compilation of clips interspersed with talking heads of assorted lesbigay celebrities and liberal actors/actresses like Susan Sarandon, Whoopi Goldberg and Tom Hanks.

The clips were interesting, there was one from 1897 made by Edison Experimental Films, of a male couple dancing while a violinist played. There was one clip from ‘Wings’, a 1927 film where the two male leads were shown kissing and cuddling. There were also clips from films with a high bi content like ‘Morocco’ and ‘Sunday, Bloody Sunday’.

There were some interesting interpretations of the subtexts to supposedly straight films like ‘Ben Hur’ (Ben Hur and Marsalis were previously lovers, according to Gore Vidal, which is why there was a conflict between them – incidentally, Charlton Heston is supposed to be suing Gore Vidal for that comment). Susan Sarandon remarked that at the end of ‘Butch Cassidy’ they had to go out in a hail of bullets – ‘They couldn’t show affection, so they had to get their dicks (i.e. their guns) out’.

Susie Bright was the token bi who then blew all her bisexual credibility by saying that ‘Morocco’ was a lesbian film. (This is the film where Marlene Dietrich seduces a man and a woman during her cabaret act.)

Where the ‘Closet’ started to really drag was when the talking heads started pontificating. Susan Sarandon girlishly waxed lyrical about Hollywood ‘being the keeper of the dream’. Harvey Fierstein (‘Torch Song Trilogy’) said ‘…publicity at any cost… what I can’t stand is being ignored’. I have serious quarrels with both statements. I don’t think Hollywood films are about dreams at all, they are about making money.

People who complain about not being included in Hollywood films should really take a long look at psychopathic offerings from Tinseltown. The occasional film which is both adult and has any sort of spiritual awareness does not excuse the usual shit-for-brains fare which emerges, where every minority is played off against each other.

Seeing a Hollywood film like ‘Independence Day’ and then the ‘Closet’ is like being interrogated by a nice/nasty police routine. The nasty one beats the crap out of you and the nice one starts a support group to help you. In the end, though, you know that you are going to be well and truly stitched up.

Queers will only be allowed into films as long as they don’t rock the consumerist boat. There are different ways of fighting Hollywood. One is the way that we are doing now, local action, small groups reclaiming our dreams and taking back the power to run our lives the way we want.

I could advocate violence of course (I do have a fantasy which involves Joe Esterhaus, Sharon Stone, Michael Douglas and an ice pick – hey, don’t push at the back of the queue, I’m first in line) but I would be in danger of having Oliver Stone write a script about my life. (Mad bisexual driven to murder ‘innocent’ films stars by a cruel and uncaring biphobic society etc. etc.) I prefer the course we’re on now.

Kevin Saunders

Independence Day: Aliens ate my analyst’s mother

‘Independence Day’. Gross aliens invade, blow up cities; humanity fights back, under American leadership of course. Great special effects; the sort of plot you could fly a Stealth Bomber through.

Perhaps I’m hyper-sensitive, but what riles me about this film is its limited definition of inclusion. The final bunker scene seems designed to include all America; there is even a black single mother from a working-class background.

So why is it that the identifiable gay character has to die? Harvey Fierstein plays a middle-aged queer who, when invasion threatens, phones his mother and his analyst. Why can’t a middle-aged queer have a boyfriend to worry about?

‘Independence Day’ will be forgotten in a few months. Its politics were, of course, cartoonish, and I didn’t go expecting to be challenged. But I came out fuming that still, in 1996, Hollywood can’t even throw us some crumbs.

Steve C