Bi Community News Feedback Meeting At BiCon ’96
When we formed Bi Community News at BiCon a year ago, we said that we would hold a meeting at each year’s conference to report back to and get feedback from the community. This article contains the reports and feedback from the first meeting, held at BiCon ’96.
BCN Financial Position 1996/97
Income for the year between setting up the newsletter at BiCon ’95 and BiCon ’96 was £2,880, mostly from the 290 subscriptions. Thanks to all of you and please don’t forget to renew your subscription.
We spent £2,048, mostly on printing and posting the newsletter and the BM box. This means that each issue cost around £205. We have £831 left, which means that if no-one renewed their subs we could put out around four issues before we ran out of money.
At BiCon ’96’s closing plenary we were voted £600 from the surplus from BiCon ’95 (see BCN Issue 10) to spend on publicity and outreach.
Jean Bassington, Treasurer
Other Reports
We explained that, at the workshop where BCN was formed a year ago, it was agreed that the newsletter should be: monthly, national, news-based, accountable to the community and not be a forum for poetry and creative writing.
Each of us involved with BCN then explained our roles. These included: editing, layout, writing news, writing opinion pieces, interviewing people, scanning pictures, book-keeping, maintaining local group listings, maintaining the Web site, dealing with mail, publicity, organising personal ads, printing the newsletter and sending it out.
The workshop then discussed what was good and bad about BCN, what we wanted from it and what people could do for it.
What’s good: ‘it succeeded in matching its aims’, ‘I’d be lost without it’, its tone, ‘BiWatch’, its simple layout, Rachael’s cartoons, listings.
What’s bad: the logos, the layout and logo changing, issue dates and numbers falling off the front page, confusion between the names ‘Bi Community News’ and ‘Ribbit’, listings policy, not enough people writing for it.
What we want: more line drawings, more international stories (particularly for ‘BiWatch’), indication when letters are cut, more academic stories (but not in academic language), more stuff on non-community bisexuals, an ISBN/ISSN number.
What you can do: design new logos, send us drawings/photos, write (letters, articles, anything!), join the collective, get in touch with us about publicity/your networks.
As well as being a great way to receive feedback, the meeting was a big success in terms of recruiting contributors and new collective members. Getting more people involved in contributing to BCN is incredibly important, as is getting your feedback, so if you missed the meeting but would like to send us your opinions, articles, drawings or photos please get in touch at the usual address.
Caramel Quin
That Closing Plenary
In case you weren’t there, or have tried to put the whole episode out of your mind, here are the decisions of the final plenary: of the money left over from BiCon ’95: £700 went to the BiCon Advisory Group to help with set up costs; £600 to BCN to help publicise the newsletter and £50 to a new Sheffield Bi Group (see listings). The remainder went into the deposit account of the London Bi Group to be held until BiCon ’97 where we’ll all decide what to do with the money.
Commentary
We had half an hour to make some complex decisions about what to do with a fair amount of money. Congratulations are in order that decisions were made. It would have been easy to have argued among ourselves so much that a decision would have been impossible.
The plenary was intense and acrimonious, people lost their tempers, were shouted down, spoke out of turn, made personal remarks and walked out in disgust. Against that was the fact that most people were well behaved, the chair was able to keep the meeting in order and the decisions made met with the approval of the majority.
I’ve attended large meetings where difficult decisions need to be made before. These have usually been union meetings where there have been political groups with a firm agenda out to get their decision through. The most acrimonious ones were to do with strikes. In those meetings, people made some really vicious personal attacks and were ready to use some underhand tactics to get their way. None of these were in evidence.
That said, there were one or two things which made me uneasy about the way the decisions were arrived at. It was decided with little discussion that we should use majority rule to make decisions. This is quick and generates workable decisions. But there can be a sizeable minority who are so pissed off with the decision that they do everything they can to undermine it. Using majority rule can also generate a circus-like atmosphere as groups form to bash each other and it encourages scapegoating people who see difficulties that the majority doesn’t acknowledge. For a community that tries to be inclusive, these are serious points to think about.
There were no ground rules against people making personal attacks. A few people (one or two on the platform as well) interrupted other speakers with catcalls.
If a couple of people had been appointed as ‘vibe’ monitors they could have alerted the chair to stop the remarks becoming too intense. If there had been some people delegated to help the chair, vibe monitors, time keepers, then the chair would have been freer to focus on keeping the meeting in order.
There could have also been some attempt to make sure that men and women had equal access to ‘air time’, my impression was that there were more men than women allowed to speak.
A more serious flaw was that no tellers were appointed. Some voted yes and no to some decisions. No count was made of the votes and there was no call for abstentions.
We will be making difficult decisions in the bi movement in the coming years as our struggle progresses. We need to start thinking about how to make those decisions in a better way.
Kevin Saunders
