Plural desires: writing bisexual women’s realities

Plural desires: writing bisexual women’s realities / edited by the Bisexual Anthology Collective. Toronto: Sister Vision Press, 1995. ISBN 0920813194 £10.99

This is a welcome addition to the current crop of bi anthologies: a collection of writings, both fiction and non-fiction, from a Canadian and predominantly black/women of colour perspective. Although many of the pieces cover familiar territory – coming out, self-acceptance, relations with the lesbian community – there is an added depth to this collection which suggests a step forward from the `Bisexuality 101′ phase of earlier collections such as Bi Any Other Name.

Although the title might suggest an introspective, personal stance – and that is certainly true of some of the contributions – there is also a good deal of serious political thought and discussion. The `round table’ technique of throwing together a group of bisexual women, a tape recorder, and a topic, is skilfully employed, having the effect of drawing the reader into an intimate conversation and simultaneously illuminating topics which might have seemed dry and theoretical had they been presented in a more formal manner. Particularly interesting in this respect are `Purifying the (Identi)Ghee: South Asian Feminists Gup-shup’ which takes on the issue of heterosexual privilege outside of a white Western context, and `Toward a Feminist Bisexual Politic,’ a thoughtful analysis of the intersection of the bisexual movement with other liberation movements and the question of integrity on a personal and political level.

I did feel that some of the articles didn’t quite work (Janice Williamson’s `Strained Mixed Fruit’ for example, a `autobifictograph’ running to some 40 pages), but on the whole I was heartened by this book, by the intelligence and maturity of the contributors’ voices and by the fact that it was published at all. In the current climate of media-created `bisexual chic,’ this is the perfect antidote to claims that bisexual women are apolitical trendy invaders of lesbian space. It deserves to be read both within and outside the bisexual community.

Claire Parry

 

 


Lies, Damn Lies and Statistics

The gay gene debate rumbles on with a new book by Chandler Burr, `A Separate Creation’ (see short review also BCN issue 8). However in a substantial aside the book attempts to rewrite sexual orientation. Male bisexuality all but disappears while we are told that many women are bisexual and/or are fluid in their sexuality over time.

Much of `A Separate Creation’ deals with the work of geneticist Dean Hamer; and this is where the stuff on orientation comes in. Hamer did the research at the initial stage of his search for a male `gay gene.’ It’s worth noting that for his later research to work he needed an either/or proposition on male sexuality – either straight or gay. The existence of male bisexuality would have destroyed his research position.

So do Hamer’s results stand up to scrutiny? Too little detail is given by Burr to tell. We are not told how many people are interviewed, or how they were selected – very basic points. And the information which is present suggests a number of flaws large enough to discredit the study.

Hamer states that the men he interviewed tended to give yes or no answers whilst the women gave qualified ones. He interprets this as a sign that men’s sexuality will also be at one end of the spectrum or the other. A more reasonable conclusion would be that men gave more simplistic answers. Which would also account for a reduction in those revealing their bisexuality. Hamer also interviewed the men, while a colleague interviewed the women. Which is a basic research error that throws up spurious differences between sexes.

Hamer then compounds mistakes with offensive opinion. According to Hamer, the few men in the study that identified as bisexual were in fact gay and coming to terms with their sexuality. Where have we heard that before? He also dismisses the idea that some that identified as gay could possibly be conforming under pressure (or for social, or political, reasons).

It’s possible to drive a coach and horses through the holes in Hamer’s research. His research is flawed, with a clear motive for such a bias, and other research tells us a very different story to Hamer’s. Respected studies including Kinsey and Project SIGMA for instance. SIGMA interviewed 930 men who have sex with men, of whom only identified as exclusively homosexual.

And what of the gay gene theories? While the theory may be interesting, until others can reproduce the work, and there is something of statistical significance (and actual significance) to be put forward it remains a lot of hype with nothing to back it – a lot like this book.

`A Separate Creation’ by Chandler Burr is out now from Bantam Press, price £16.99.

Steve Pointer