Dear BCN,
Re: Issue 32 – I am rather alarmed at the seemingly prevalent view of the LBWG’s decision about the attendance of trans people at their meetings.

The LBWG is a women’s group and like all groups – whether they be about train-spotting or tantric sex – have a right to expect their members to satisfy certain basic criteria. In the case of trainspotting, one would not expect to let Mr Beeching in. While mixed groups are welcome to invite all-comers to their meetings this group has a particular target membership. It is for ‘women’ and not ‘women-and-preop-transsexuals-and-maybe-those-who-get-off-on-being-in-a-women-only-space’. A ‘youth’ group would not allow in a 40-year old, no matter how much they said they were ‘young at heart’ nor would a black men’s caucus allow a white woman into membership.

Women-only space, whether lesbian, bi or straight, is a very precious resource. Exclusivity is not a negative force. It is an empowering one. Newcomers do not want to walk into a space they believe to be women-only only to meet what are – by their appearance or behaviour – men! At a meeting some months back the discussion topic moved on to abuse by men and one member couldn’t bring herself to discuss in the meeting the feelings she had about a past event as one of these people was in her sub-group. It should not be necessary to have to worry about the history of other people present in what should be a safe space.

Turning to people who say they are ‘challenging stereotypes’ or are a ‘third sex’. I am sure that they, like many other TGs, are all very well-meaning and I have no problem with most of these people as individuals but they are – by their own admission – not women, and therefore have no right to attend a women-only meeting (or men-only for that matter). Saying you are neither does not make you both! Similarly, much of the bi community appear to believe that the behaviour practised by some of the ‘self-defined-women’ – using men’s loos and retaining male privilege at work but running women-only workshops at bi-con or wherever – may not be questioned. ‘PC’, however well intentioned, should not become a blanket acceptance of deception.

Post-op TSs have generally shown that they are genuine in their beliefs (hey, surgery is serious!) and are acceptable but some of the other people one sees around on the Bi scene are questionable at the very least. What about someone who calls themselves a woman but has an obvious beard? At first one may say that they are in the early stages of transition, but over two years later, still with stubble and wearing male-style clothing? Worse, they still behave in a male manner; taking over meetings and saying that they have a right to determine policy for women’s groups!

There is a threat posed by the existence of TSs in all stages of transition in women-only space. The human race are not mind readers; we do not know why they are there, what they are feeling, whether they are getting their sexual kicks from the experience. We do know that some of them look a sight in short skirts with stocking tops showing, with short back and sides haircuts or with deep voices and designer stubble. Of course we can all point to natural-born women who cross some of these boundaries, but shouldn’t TSs always be aware of their effect on others and try to correct the imbalances they may present? Their desire for acceptance should require that they accept their history and compensate for it. Should a women-only group accept without question everyone who decides to put a frock on for the evening? For that matter, how many ‘real’ women nowadays get dressed up especially to go to a group anyway? In nearly every women-only space one goes to just about every skirt is being worn by a trannie of some description!

Events in the past six months have included one night where over 20% of the attendees were TS, some clearly pre-op; another where an individual, believed to be pre-op, became very disruptive and caused the group to have to create a behavioural policy – something that was never needed in the past when only women attended – and another individual who acknowledged they were ‘dressing up’ to attend while remaining generally in the male role otherwise.

So far as I understand (having been to the LBWG on and off for a few years) it has never needed a trans policy in the past. It was never a problem. The policy earlier this year was set by the group’s venue, The Wheel, and not directly by the group, so please get the target right when attacking that policy. The LBWG did not want to lose the meeting room (Camden Council put paid to that hope some weeks later) and accepted the limitations set.

This forced relocation gave an opportunity to review the policy and all these events meant that it was looking dangerously close to becoming a ‘mixed’ group in some ways. London Bi-group, having served the whole community well for over 16 years would not want a competitor on its doorstep! The LBWG had a confidential postal vote of everyone who had attended in the last nine months. The results were certainly clear-cut, even if they did not follow what had been said in public (that ‘PC’ thing again). They accepted that only natural-born women and post-op TSs who live full-time as women could be members.

The LBWG are an independent bunch of women, have every right to self-determination and a responsibility only to themselves. Should they let in every TV, TG and no-op-yet TS that wants to attend? Let in a man wearing a pinstripe suit, bowler hat and a beard who says in a deep voice ‘I am a woman’? That is what a self-definition policy would mean even if it is unlikely to happen. The primary membership would dwindle until the group had to change to the London Bisexual TV-TG-TS group for want of a woman member.

An ‘open-door’ policy could end up as a ‘revolving door’ policy with real women walking out as the TGs walk in. If you don’t like the policy then feel free to try and start your own group, but please let’s not destroy what is serving its target audience well.

Alison M. Wheeler

 

Dear BCN,
Re: Letters, Issue 32, and developments occurring at LBWG since – Thank you to Poppy for kind comments about my dedication. I do care a lot about the group and so at the last planning meeting I suggested we had an anonymous postal vote on our admissions policy regarding transsexuals. We had previously attempted to resolve the issue by discussion but opinion was very strong on both sides, discussions were heated and a number of people told me they planned to leave. I couldn’t bear to see the group tear itself apart over a single – if very emotive – issue.

Poppy is mistaken in her belief that the need for a policy arose because of a few disruptive individuals. There was a person whose behaviour some people felt was disruptive and we formulated a behaviour policy, applying to all women at the group. The issue was much broader, this is a women-only group – but what is a woman? The answer is not clear-cut. Some people move socially from being one gender to being another and some people define themselves as being between the genders. There are arguably not two sexes but a continuum. At what point along that line do you decide a person is female? This did not receive a unique answer, even from the transsexuals attending the group themselves.

Among the TSs attending, the following opinions were expressed to me:
* We should have a completely open door policy, anybody who self defined as a woman was welcome. (Current Bicon Policy for women-only space.)
* TSs living full time as women should be allowed. (Current Nottingham Women’s Centre policy, hailed as a victory by Press for Change when introduced.)
* There should be some kind of dress policy to prevent people turning up in e.g. mini skirts with stocking tops showing.
* We should have a pre/post policy. (Previous Bicon policy. Used at many lesbian groups and the gay games.)

The women had also expressed this cross section of opinion. I presented these as options in the vote and attempted to summarise the arguments for and against each. Because of the complexity of the issue and the broad range of opinions there was rather a lot of information, and it was not possible to do a simple ‘either/or’ vote. I am sorry if anybody finds this confusing, especially those who have not attended our group or had not been attending the group at the time when the increasing number of transsexuals caused the initial arguments to break out. I endeavoured to simplify the arguments and the voting process as much as possible while at the same time giving all options a voice.

The result was that only ‘natural born’ women and those transsexuals who were post-operative and also living full-time as women could be admitted. The return was approximately 27% [36 of 135 votes] (the mail out was to everybody who had been in the last nine months including many people who had only been once or had not been for many months, a comparable return to Local Council elections). 39% [14] voted for a completely open door against 61% [22] voting for some form of limitation. Of those voting for some form of limitation 73% [16] voted for a pre/post policy 73% [16] voted for ‘living full time’ (exactly the same figure) and 45% [10] voted for ‘look behave and dress’. As each option required 50% plus one to carry the ‘look behave and dress’ policy fell while the other two carried.

This took me completely by surprise. Very few people had openly expressed a desire for a pre/post policy. I realise this is the most controversial aspect of the policy. I am sorry that, inevitably, some individuals have been hurt. However, I stand by the group’s decision as it has been democratic and we have a right to determine our own policy. We are not being oppressive or discriminatory – we have simply drawn our line in a different place to some other organisations. No policy is perfect; nothing we did or did not do would have kept everybody happy and there are arguments for and against every solution. In the end, the only way our group could move on was by presenting all the possibilities to the membership and going with the result. To answer some of the criticisms raised in Rachael’s letter:
* This aspect of the policy would work on trust as we would not be asking anyone to pull down their knickers as they walked through the door!
* We never had to formulate a policy on pre-op female to male transsexuals as nobody fitting this description has ever attempted to attend. It is unlikely that anybody wishing to be a male would want to be in a women-only space. We feel no need to formulate a policy for a problem that does not exist.

The process the group has been through over the last few months has been a wide examination and review of the issue ‘what is gender?’ There is no black and white answer, no simple factual response, just a whole load of different opinions. It is also a question that interests many people in the bisexual community. Although our group has reached its decision I am sure the debate will go on and I welcome this chance to contribute to it through these pages.

Mary Tinsley

 

Dear Editor,
I wish to add my unreserved support for Mary Tinsley’s letter (above). An issue crying out for a policy decision arose. A vote was democratically taken and a policy reached – however flawed some people might think that decision was.

Can we please now assume that there was goodwill from all LBWG members – from both supporters of self-definition and supporters of a strictly women-only only space. We are a diverse community doing our best to fulfill diverse needs and we won’t fulfill everybody all the time. Between the various social/support groups I hope that we can support and fulfill all sectors of the community. But please, let’s not argue and divide over LBWG’s very best intentioned efforts to do so.
Regards,

Gabrielle Samuels (LBWG member)

 

Dear Sir/Madam,
As a member of The London Bi-Women’s Group for nearly three years, an environment which I have always found to be friendly, safe and trusting, I would like to express my point of view on the recent vote on the group’s ‘open door’ policy. Members voted that the group should remain a women-only group. I feel that this decision should be final, as far as I am aware no-one was out to offend or upset anyone. I feel sad that the group has suffered because of this with much criticism about the final outcome of the vote. Furthermore, I originally joined this group, precisely because it was a women’s group, in my opinion pre-op transsexuals do not fall into the category of women. Certain subjects can be a little delicate, they concern women and should be of interest to women only. Women consider these meetings to be ‘safe’ and if men are permitted to attend there is a potential for abuse. In a worst-case scenario a woman could become friendly with someone, not knowing the real gender of her new-found friend and this could have serious consequences.
Yours sincerely,

Sandra Robinson