LBWG ignite a more general discussion of tensions between non-TG women, and their Others. Although the LBWG attract a disproportionate number of TG woman from which we might expect greater understanding, we are reminded instead, of the complex nature of being. Particularly how we might perceive ourselves as (i) woman and (ii) bisexual. Unlike the TG women, these identities may be more distinguishable in our minds and hence responsible for the divisions between us.
So, some of us preserve ‘woman’ as natural and authentic, regardless of sexuality. Yet who hasn’t had ‘incorrect’ feelings of, ‘we are being patronised by men ‘choosing’ to be women,’ or, ‘he’s living in the ideological clouds?’ Or, ‘well if he’s going to try and be a woman, why the fuck doesn’t she do something about that make-up and why, for Gods sake, those ridiculous clothes!’ (Forgive me Ru Paul). A TS, in contrast to a TV, has to jump ’nuff hoops to get to the ‘post-op’ stage, so tolerance can be extended only because she has ‘suffered’. Misrepresented altruism might have us conclude exasperatingly, ‘a woman looks nothing like that and frankly, I feel damn insulted.’
Yet if ‘woman’ is something natural and authentic how do we situate societies’ social creations of her? The resentment existing towards TG women by most of us surely lies in our knowing that men are responsible for our makeovers, but then he tries to mimic us too. I think it’s felt, ‘those bastards want it both ways, ‘our’ role as well as theirs.’
Now my bisexuality is one that allows me to get sexually intimate with women who enjoy strapping ‘one’ on, as well as with sexually less assertive women. When she straps one on, she seemingly for that moment has everything. When I do, I experience something sexually transcending; incredibly powerful. I can touch in me a male associated arrogance I didn’t know existed but thank God nobody knows.
When I think of the male equivalent to she with the strap-on, I easily conjure up the very sexual image of me with a transvestite. I’m talking lesbian-trannies and no, she doesn’t desire to cut it off. A man made in heaven for some of us and yet what does it say about both our gender/sexuality situations? If she touches my lesbian inclinations it’s her womanness that I enjoy but shouldn’t I judge us completely by the presence of a penis? She is physically and quite naturally more feminine than I.
Still, if we grew up as female we are products of something unique to that experience. Within a gender transition does ‘maleness’ disappear? ‘Cos if TG women once had privileges over women, outside gender role-plays, who really needs to teach who what? Who are weaker or less informed? Lingering doubts may translate into the cynical, ‘how can they understand what a woman feels if they have never been one?’
Plus, non-TG women will challenge what she’s ‘expected’ to be. TG women must ‘polish’ passive behaviour to ‘pass’, an opposing aim. Fail, and they will never ‘feel woman’ enough because so much depends upon social acceptance – our acceptance. Butch women feel excluded from us, punished for failing to conform ‘properly’. Men rarely accept her as a man though I Wish they would, rather than be undermined for the feminine she cannot be. Or ought she remain in a woman’s group?
Our anxieties about being women can get in the way of our feelings towards our TG Others so we need a different conceptual standpoint. TG women will always be more vulnerable in this society, ‘cos she will always be TG and/or a woman with a past to hide. I agree that our different beginnings make our union complicated but we have much to learn from each other. We need not suffer for working side by side as women, even when we are not.
Marlene Ellis
