Sex Changes: The Politics of Transgenderism
Pat Califia (Cleis Press, 1997)
An in-depth history and analysis of transsexuality, gender dysphoria and transgenderism in the 20th Century, clearly written by someone who has examined the subject carefully.
Califia takes care to avoid claiming to be an objective authority although her background as a writer and critic of the queer world as well as being a qualified therapist will give her an air of authority to many.
The book starts with the first transsexuals to publish autobiographies and moves onto ‘Father Figures: The Gender Scientists’ and the feminist backlash, with particular scrutiny of transphobia in the lesbian community.
After a critique of the gay community trying to claim differently gendered people in traditional societies as their own, the book moves on to contemporary transsexual autobiography and the current politics around transgender. These chapters cannot be as complete as the more historical sections since the debate is ongoing. They give a good overview of the present and discussion of futures.
There is plenty of detailed information and discussion. The book is certainly not a light read although it doesn’t go off into academic discourse. The work is well referenced with pointers to resources for those who wish to explore further.
Sex Changes is a good way of finding all about the background to current discussions around transgenderism with a strong historical view and well-thought-out analysis.
Grant Denkinson
Body Alchemy – Transsexual Portraits
Photographs by Loren Cameron (Cleis Press, 1996)
This book isn’t about all transsexuals or a transsexual movement, it is an intensely personal look at several transsexual men. It doesn’t contain overviews or analysis: these are portraits of individuals.
The book starts with an introduction by the author and artistically posed self-portraits accompanied by passages of text illustrating aspects of his body and thoughts. Next are pictures framed by hurtful sound bites, grouped by sex and sexuality. These are followed by a selection of portraits of other ‘new men’ together with a page of their own words.
The next section contains close-up views of genitals, to satisfy the curiosity. After that are more men who one might walk past on the street, with a little about their jobs and hobbies, not their dicks.
Some fascinating before-and-after shots precede the chapter ‘Duo’, where words and pictures by Loren with Kayt, his partner, end the book on a warm note. Body Alchemy is valuable, allowing one to see transsexual men not as medical problems or gender revolutionaries but as people.
Grant Denkinson
Dick for a day
Ed. Fiona Giles (Indigo, £6.99)
The neon cover screams out, ‘What women would do if they had a dick for a day!’ A marketing dream, instantly grabbing the prurient reader, assorted queers and the youth market alike. It even has the potential to get old-school feminists’ backs up before they so much as open the cover.
The contributions range from Diane DiMassa’s single-page response (she’d show it to all her lesbian friends so they could laugh at it, and then lose interest) to long detailed sexual fantasies. The most invigorating is Pat Califia’s essay, which muses for ten pages before getting sordid, though more for the things she has to say about gender than the sexual antics she envisages.
By and large these are not (as far as I am aware) writers who are transgender. The contributors are a mixture of bi, straight and gay women and so have an interesting assortment of sexual imaginings and takes on the implications of acquiring a penis. Of course to be interested enough to write a short piece on the subject, I suppose they must be more interested in gender than a random member of the public.
So is it worth reading? Yes; as with any collection of short prose it has dull moments, but there are some gems in there and the possibilities for frightening people by reading it on a train are delightful.
Finally it reminds me of how differently our society values ‘male’ and ‘female’ genitalia. At a youth gathering in November, I read extracts from this book in the dorm one night to an audience of the bemused and the enthralled. Would they have taken Muff for a Morning as seriously?
Jen Yockney
My Gender Workbook
Kate Bornstein (Routledge, £13.99)
‘The way that you live without gender is you look for where gender is, and then you go someplace else.’ This is a delightful textbook, even if sometimes you need to suspend the disbelief that comes from living in as strongly gendered a culture as most of us have to deal with walking to the supermarket.
It’s aimed at people who have little grasp of radical transgender thought, guiding you by the hand and using a big dollop of humour to sweeten the pill. There’s even a little gender aptitude test at the start to tell you how difficult you’re going to find the rest of the book.
Rather than lecturing you with ‘how wrong you were’, Kate offers a series of questions and exercises designed to make you think about all the parts of gender you took for granted or were never allowed to challenge while you were growing up. This works beautifully, just like a good school exercise book (right down to spaces for you to write answers in pencil) – and if you already know plenty about transgender you can dip in and out of the chapters for pleasure without missing anything.
It’s camp, it’s comic and it has cartoons by Dianne DiMassa who wrote Hothead Paisan. What more could you want?
Jen Yockney
