The Court of Appeal in Singapore has rebuffed an attempt to decriminalise sex between men.

While the country’s laws still make it a crime, the law is in suspension for all practical purposes. Nonetheless while it remains in place this suspension could be revoked at any time, as well as being a clear barrier to other law reforms for LGBT people.

The law states that, “377A. Any male person who, in public or private, commits, or abets the commission of, or procures or attempts to procure the commission by any male person of, any act of gross indecency with another male person, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to 2 years.”

The case brought to the court argued that it was a breach of the country’s constitution.

In their ruling the Court admitted that ‘although s 377A is a law that, on its face, purports to do no more than prohibit particular sexual acts, its penalty and purpose carry more profound consequences, touching upon “the most private human conduct” and often in the context of the most private relationships”‘.

However it balanced this by reflecting, “What rights the appellants claim to be fundamental, others view as controversial; what is to the appellants deeply personal and even definitive of their identity, others regard as offensive.”

So we can’t give you your human rights because some other people might not like it.

In the meanwhile though, the appellants ought to pursue their goals through parliamentary means rather than the courts: “One may well ask whether litigation is, in fact, the optimal way to resolve such differences. Politics seems the more obvious choice than litigation for debating and resolving highly contentious societal issues. At the heart of politics lies the project of democratic engagement, as politicians aim to persuade voters by appealing to hearts and minds.”

Peculiarly it then goes on to blame the Roe v Wade case in the USA for the existence of the so-called “Right To Life” movement.