America’s only openly bi Senator is under pressure in her constituency – from LGBT activists.
Kyrsten Sinema gained the Republican-leaning swing state of Arizona as a Democrat, and has carved a mirror path to her Republican predecessor John McCain. Where McCain was elected as a Republican but did not toe the party line as much as his colleagues, Sinema has not felt constrained by loyalty to her Democrat party label.
In another term of office this would not be so important but the US Senate is perfectly balanced, with 50 seats each for the Democrats and the Republicans.
Vice President Harris thus has a casting vote when votes tie – giving a wafer-thin 51 to 50 vote majority for Democrat measures on paper.
But on a string of issues Sinema is not playing ball – such as reforms to improve the economic situation of the poorest Americans, to ensure the functioning of democracy where voter suppression measures are being pushed forward by the Republicans, or basic human rights protections in day-to-day life and employment for bi, gay and trans people.
Further, her refusal to support reform of the ‘filibuster’ procedure in the Senate means even where a majority for a measure can be found, the Republicans are able to use blocking tactics to prevent bills progressing into law.
Of course issues like poverty have particular overlap for bi people – time and again, research shows we earn less than our gay and straight colleagues.
As the first openly bi Senator Kyrsten was expected by many to stand up on issues that especially affect bi and other queer Americans, and so her refusal to do so has started to boil over. An open letter reproduced below has been signed from a host of LGBT+ and Ally organisations such as Trans Spectrum of Arizona and the state’s Young Democrats organisation alongside many individual activists. It challenges her over her inaction, with a warning that if she continues to act as she has done, there will be greater efforts to run a viable challenger to her for the Democratic Party nomination next time around:
On behalf of the below LGBTQ21A+ community leaders and organizations, we urge you to end the filibuster to pass the Equality Act and secure the civil rights of queer and transgender people across the nation. As the first openly Bisexual member of the Senate, we look to you to lead in the fight for queer and transgender civil rights, to protect our people from violence and discrimination.
Arizona can be a leader in this fight. With a higher percentage of queer and transgender residents than NYC, Silicon Valley or Chicago in Phoenix alone, we have the power to lead the nation on queer and transgender rights. You have the power to cast the deciding vote to make those rights law. Our right to exist, and the rights of black and brown transgen are not up for debate or compromise. Unless we end the filibuster, the Equality Act has no chance of passing the Senate in this polarized climate.
The filibuster blocks bills that would otherwise pass by the democratic process of majority rule. This is an undemocratic relic of Jim Crow era racism and minority repression. The longstanding tradition of the filibuster has been to block the civil rights of black Americans, and that tradition continues today as it is now being used to block the civil rights of queer and transgender Americans. The overwhelming majority of Senate Democrats support filibuster reform, and we urge you to join in the movement to end the filibuster.
By casting the decisive vote to end the filibuster, you would open the flood gates of possibility to pass popular reforms supported by the majority of Americans. Among these transformative reforms, the Equality Act, which you cosponsored, will prohibit discrimination on the basis of sex, sexual orientation, and gender identity in employment, housing, public accommodations, education, federally funded programs, credit, and jury service.
We have a rare opportunity in this moment in history. With the support of the President and the majority of Americans for the Equality Act, it is now up to Senate Democrats to end the Jim Crow filibuster and pass this bill securing equality for all LGBTQ21A+ Americans. As the first openly Bisexual Senator, you should be a champion of queer and transgender rights, and the fact that you oppose filibuster reform in favor of the status quo is deeply concerning.
We, the below queer community leaders and organizations, thank you for co-sponsoring the Equality Act, and we urge you to take the necessary next step of ending the filibuster so queer and transgender civil rights can pass the Senate and be signed into law by President Biden. If you refuse to do this, we will have no choice but to seriously consider whether our support for you, including financial donations, may better serve our community if directed to another Democrat who will use their power as a US Senator to stand up for our rights.
