The European Parliament tomorrow debates a motion to declare the whole of the EU an “LGBTIQ Freedom Zone”.

It is tabled by a coalition of MEPs from several of the parliament’s groups: PPE (which the Conservatives used to be part of before David Cameron pulled his group out to please the Brexit wing of his party), S&D (parties broadly aligned to Labour and the SDLP), Renew (which before Brexit included the Liberal Democrats and the Alliance Party), Green EFA (Green Party, SNP and Plaid) and Left Group (which lacks a significant UK equivalent).

The move is a clear and direct rebuke first to the “LGBT Free Zone” areas declared by local government in parts of Poland and cheerled by the country’s president, who was re-elected by a wafer-thin margin last year. Further against the ongoing persecution of bi, gay and trans people in Hungary.

MEPs have started tweeting photos holding LGBTIQ FREEDOM ZONE signs, rainbow flags and other such props.

MEP for Dublin, Barry Andrews, posed for a photo ahead of the vote:

 

Czech MEP Radka Maxová tweeted a street photo:

Terry Reintke MEP is German but helpfully tweeted in English:

And the European Commissioner for Cohesion and Reforms, Elisa Ferreira tweeted her support:

 

The full motion is below (apologies for what the conversion from PDF has done to the layout!) or here as a neater pdf.


The European Parliament,
– having regard to the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (hereinafter
‘the Charter’),
– having regard to Article 2 of the Treaty on European Union (TEU),
– having regard to the European Convention on Human Rights and the related case-law of
the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR),
– having regard to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights,
– having regard to Council Directive 2000/78/EC of 27 November 2000 establishing a
general framework for equal treatment in employment and occupation,
– having regard to Directive 2004/38/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council
of 29 April 2004 on the right of citizens of the Union and their family members to move
and reside freely within the territory of the Member States amending Regulation (EEC)
No 1612/68 and repealing Directives 64/221/EEC, 68/360/EEC, 72/194/EEC,
73/194/EEC, 75/34/EEC, 75/35/EEC, 90/364/EEC and 93/96/EEC2,
– having regard to Directive 2004/113/EC of 13 December 2004 implementing the
principle of equal treatment between men and women in the access to and supply of
goods and services3,
– having regard to Directive 2006/54/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council
of 5 July 2006 on the implementation of the principle of equal opportunities and equal
treatment of men and women in matters of employment and occupation,
– having regard to the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU),
– having regard to the Commission communication of 12 November 2020 entitled ‘Union
of Equality: LGBTIQ Equality Strategy 2020-2025’ (COM(2020)0698),
– having regard to its resolution of 14 February 2019 on the future of the LGBTI List of
Actions (2019-2024),
– having regard to its resolution of 18 December 2019 on public discrimination and hate
speech against LGBTI people, including LGBTI-free zones,
– having regard to the EU Guidelines to promote and protect the enjoyment of all human
rights by lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex (LGBTI) persons, adopted by
the Council in 2013,
– having regard to the results of the EU LGBT Survey launched by the European Union
Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA) in 2019,
– having regard to its resolution of 17 September 2020 on the proposal for a Council
decision on the determination of a clear risk of a serious breach by the Republic of
Poland of the rule of law,
– having regard to its resolution of 12 September 2018 on a proposal calling on the
Council to determine, pursuant to Article 7(1) of the TEU, the existence of a clear risk
of a serious breach by Hungary of the values on which the Union is founded,
– having regard to the Council of Europe’s Recommendation of 31 March 2010 of the
Committee of Ministers to member states on measures to combat discrimination on
grounds of sexual orientation or gender identity (CM/Rec(2010)5) and to the standards
adopted by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe,
– having regard to the Memorandum of 3 December 2020 of the Commissioner for
Human Rights of the Council of Europe on the stigmatisation of LGBTI people in
Poland,
– having regard to the debate in the Council of Europe’s Congress of Local Regional
Authorities Current Affairs Committee, and to its subsequent reports entitled ‘Factfinding
report on the role of local authorities with regard to the situation and rights of
LGBTIQ people in Poland’ of 27 January 2021 and ‘Protecting LGBTIQ people in the
context of rising anti-LGBTIQ hate speech and discrimination: The role of local and
regional authorities’ of 10 February 2021,
– having regard to Rule 132(2) of its Rules of Procedure,
A. whereas LGBTIQ rights are human rights;
B. whereas the right to equal treatment and non-discrimination is a fundamental right
enshrined in the EU Treaties and in the Charter, and should be fully respected; whereas
all Member States have assumed obligations and duties under international law and the
EU Treaties to respect, guarantee, protect and fulfil fundamental rights; whereas
combating inequality in the EU is a shared responsibility, requiring joint efforts and
action at every level of government;
C. whereas since March 2019, over 100 regions, counties and municipalities across Poland
have adopted resolutions declaring themselves free from so-called LGBTI ideology or
have adopted ‘Regional Charters of Family Rights’; whereas in November 2020, the
Hungarian town of Nagykáta adopted a resolution banning the ‘dissemination and
promotion of LGBTQ propaganda’; whereas these resolutions discriminate directly and
indirectly against LGBTIQ people; whereas LGBT-free zone resolutions declare
opposition to the ‘ideology of the LGBT movement’ and call on local governments to
refrain from any action that would encourage tolerance towards LGBTIQ people,
including withdrawing financial assistance from organisations that aim to promote
nondiscrimination and equality; whereas the ‘Regional Charters of Family Rights’ use a
very narrow definition of the family, while calling on municipalities to protect family
rights in all their policies, initiatives and funding; whereas by focusing only on these
types of family, the Regional Charters are indirectly calling for discrimination against
all other forms of families, in particular single-parent, same-sex couples’ and rainbow
families, and to refrain from providing financial support to projects and initiatives
which protect and promote fundamental rights, organise anti-discrimination education
or in any other way support equality and LGBTIQ people;
D. whereas the Polish Ombudsman for Human Rights has initiated nine complaints against
some of the regions, counties and municipalities which have adopted resolutions on
being free from ‘LGBT ideology’, which has resulted to date in four resolutions being
declared unconstitutional by administrative courts; whereas in January 2021, the Polish
town of Nowa Dęba withdrew its resolution declaring itself free from so-called LGBT
ideology following the loss of a twinning agreement with the Irish town of Fermoy;
whereas the Polish county of Sztum and the Polish town of Tomaszów Mazowiecki
withdrew their resolutions adopting Regional Charters of Family Rights in September
and October 2020 respectively;
E. whereas Norway withdrew from granting funds to the Polish regions, counties and
municipalities which had adopted resolutions declaring themselves free from so-called
LGBTI ideology or had adopted ‘Regional Charters of Family Rights’; whereas the
Commission has rejected applications for EU funding under its town twinning
programme from Polish towns that had adopted LGBTI-free zones or family rights
resolutions; whereas all EU funds managed under the Common Provisions Regulations
2021-2027 must respect the principle of non-discrimination and respect fundamental
rights as set out in the Treaty, including on the basis of sexual orientation, and whereas
municipalities acting as employers must respect Council Directive 2000/78/EC, which
prohibits discrimination and harassment on the ground of sexual orientation in
employment, in accordance with the judgment in Case C-507/18 Associazione
Avvocatura per i diritti LGBT;
F. whereas a legal complaint was submitted to the Commission by three NGOs
highlighting that ‘Regional Charters of Family Rights’ and resolutions declaring
regions, counties and municipalities to be free from so-called LGBTI ideology
introduce discrimination against LGBTIQ people and thus breach Council Directive
2000/78/EC establishing a general framework for equal treatment in employment and
occupation, as well as Articles 15 and 21 of the Charter on the freedom to choose an
occupation and the right to engage in work and on non-discrimination respectively;
whereas to date the Commission has neither provided a response to this legal complaint
nor formally recognised a violation of EU law;
G. whereas the adoption of resolutions on being free from so-called LGBT ideology or
‘Regional Charters of Family Rights’ are part of a broader context of increased
discrimination and attacks against the LGBTIQ community in Poland, which include
characterising diversity of sexuality, identity and expression as a dangerous ideology, of
growing hate speech by public authorities, elected officials – including by the current
President – and the pro-Government media, as well as of arrests of LGBTIQ rights
activists, of attacks against and bans on Pride marches and awareness-raising
programmes and actions, including in schools, and of discriminatory anti-LGBT
demonstrations; whereas hate speech by public authorities legitimises and further fuels
the climate of intolerance and discrimination against LGBTIQ people; whereas
exercising freedom of expression carries duties and responsibilities, particularly for
public authorities, politicians and opinion leaders, and whereas they should not engage
in hate speech or any discourse stigmatising LGBTIQ people, and should firmly
denounce and counter such narratives and stigmatisation, including when they are
expressed by private parties;
H. whereas the Polish activists who are acting against and informing the public about the
resolutions on being free from so-called LGBTI ideology and the ‘Regional Charters of
Family Rights’ are facing strategic lawsuits against public participation (SLAPP) owing
to their work; whereas the Polish activists who are working to denounce anti-LGBTIQ
declarations and family charters, including the authors of the ‘Atlas of Hate’ website
and the creator of the ‘LGBT-free zone’ photo project, have been subjected to
unfounded lawsuits filed by local governments or fundamentalist organisations claiming
substantial financial compensation, and to a smear campaign labelling them as liars for
using creative advocacy tools; whereas these actions are clearly intended to intimidate
and silence civil society; whereas the Polish authorities have a duty to fully protect all
persons belonging to minorities, including LGBTIQ people, from hostility and
aggression, and to enable them to carry out their activities freely; whereas the
Commission has not introduced anti-SLAPP legislation, despite repeated calls from
Parliament;
I. whereas two petitions (No 0448/2020 and No 0354/2020) on the issue of ‘LGBTI-free
zones in Poland’ have been submitted to the Committee on Petitions; whereas these
petitions were discussed in the Committee on Petitions on 26 January 2021 and, owing
to the unsatisfactory answer from the Commission, remain open for the Commission to
further clarify the situation;
J. whereas the LGBTI Survey II published by the FRA in May 2020 highlights an increase
in intolerance and violence towards LGBTIQ persons or persons who are perceived to
be LGBTIQ in Poland, and shows Polish LGBTIQ respondents’ complete absence of
faith in the government’s efforts to combat discrimination and violence, recording the
lowest percentage of anywhere in the Union (only 4 %), and the highest percentage of
respondents avoiding going to certain places for fear of being assaulted, harassed or
threatened (79 %); whereas this shows a clear correlation between LGBTIQ-phobic

governance and increased discrimination and violence against LGBTIQ people;
K. whereas Parliament has already encouraged the Member States to criminalise ‘so-called
conversion therapy’ practices; whereas the May 2020 report of the UN Independent
Expert on protection against violence and discrimination based on sexual orientation
and gender identity has called on Member States to adopt bans on practices of
‘conversion therapy’; whereas the practice is still carried out in at least 69 countries
worldwide, including in the European Union, where the use of medication,
psychotherapy and ritual cleansing in conversion therapy have been reported to have
taken place in EU Member States10; whereas the practice has only been banned in two
Member States of the European Union, namely Malta and Germany;
L. whereas the backlash against LGBTIQ people is often coupled with a broader
deterioration in the situation of democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights;
whereas the European Parliament has expressed its deep concern in several resolutions
on the deterioration in the rule of law in Poland, in particular with regard to the
independence of the judiciary and the protection of fundamental rights; whereas no
proper response has yet been given to Parliament’s initiative on the establishment of an
EU mechanism on democracy, the rule of law and fundamental rights to be governed by
an interinstitutional agreement between Parliament, the Commission and the Council;
M. whereas Parliament has expressed its position in several of its resolutions on the
situation of the rule of law, fundamental rights and democracy in Poland, concluding
that a systemic threat to the values of Article 2 of the TEU exists and that it constitutes a
clear risk of a serious breach thereof; whereas the hearings with the Polish authorities
organised by the Council under Article 7(1) of the TEU in response to threats to
common European values in Poland have not produced any results; whereas the
situation of the rule of law and fundamental rights in Poland has not only not been
addressed but has also seriously deteriorated since the triggering of the procedure,
alongside the situation of fundamental rights, specifically those of LGBTIQ persons and
women; whereas the Council should ensure that hearings under Article 7(1) of the TEU
also address new developments and assess risks of breaches of fundamental rights;
N. whereas the President of the Commission Ursula von der Leyen declared in her 2020
State of the Union address to the European Parliament Plenary that ‘LGBTQI-free
zones are humanity free zones. And they have no place in our Union’; whereas the
Commission President also declared that LGBTQI is a person’s identity not an
ideology11; whereas the Commission and the Council should refrain from narrowly
interpreting the principle of the rule of law; whereas the Commission should not hesitate
to use all tools, including infringement procedures, the Rule of Law Framework, Article
7 of the TEU, as well as the recently adopted Regulation on the protection of the
Union’s budget in case of generalised deficiencies as regards the rule of law in the
Member States, in order to address violations of the fundamental rights of LGBTIQ
people everywhere in the Union; whereas the new Citizens, Equality, Rights and Values

programme can contribute to building a non-discriminatory and more equal society
through making funds available to civil society organisations promoting LGBTIQ
equality;
O. whereas while LGBTIQ persons in Poland face systematic discrimination, this is also an
issue across the EU, with little to no progress being made in alleviating the persistent
discrimination against and harassment of LGBTIQ people; whereas public
discrimination, hate speech and hate crimes against LGBTIQ people are still prevalent
across the EU; whereas these attacks violate the fundamental rights of LGBTIQ people
and responses from public authorities too often remain inadequate; whereas LGBTIQ
persons in every Member State still face a higher rate of discrimination in all areas of
life, including at work and at school, and a high prevalence of physical, emotional and
sexual attacks, both online and offline, which leads to a worrying suicide rate among
young LGBTIQ people12, and especially among young transgender people;
P. whereas transgender persons continue to face some of the worst forms of
discrimination, violence and persecution; whereas in 2018 the Commission published a
study entitled ‘Trans and intersex equality rights in Europe – a comparative analysis’;
whereas only 13 out of the 31 countries surveyed in the study have national legislation,
at least to some extent, providing protection on the basis of gender identity and/or sex
characteristics;
Q. whereas many Member States lack specific non-discrimination laws which at least
adhere to minimum EU standards that protect people from discrimination, hate speech
and violence based on sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression and sex
characteristics, and whereas they have failed to take action to remedy this legal lacuna;
whereas the horizontal directive on non-discrimination, which could partially fill this
this gap in protection beyond employment, has remained blocked in the Council for
over 10 years; whereas the implementation of legal measures against discrimination,
where present, is still insufficient in many Member States; whereas the Commission
intends to extend the list of ‘EU crimes’ under Article 83(1) of the TFEU to cover hate
crime and hate speech, including when targeted at LGBTIQ people;
R. whereas only Malta, Portugal and some regions of Spain have prohibited medical
intervention on intersex persons without their consent; whereas many Member States
continue to follow an approach that is highly medicalised and pathologising;
S. whereas legal developments in Hungary have severely hindered the fundamental rights
of LGBTIQ people; whereas the adoption of Article 33 of the Omnibus Bill T/9934 de
facto bans legal gender recognition for trans and intersex persons in Hungary, exposing
them to discrimination and infringing their right to privacy; whereas in December 2020,
the Hungarian Parliament adopted constitutional amendments which further restrict the
rights of LGBTIQ people, neglect the existence of transgender and non-binary persons
and restrict their right to family life, and a law that will strip non-married couples of the
right to adoption;
T. whereas in January 2021, the Latvian Parliament began examining the constitutional
amendment seeking to restrict the extension of the concept of family, as indicated in the
ruling by the Constitutional Court, whereby the latter recognised the application of the
Labour Law to different family models and obliged the legislator to ensure support and
protection of same-sex couples;
U. whereas a bill to prohibit activities aimed at addressing gender identity theory in
educational contexts was adopted by the Romanian Senate in June 2020; whereas the
Romanian President refused to promulgate the law, asking instead for a constitutionality
review; whereas the Romanian Constitutional Court declared in December 2020 that the
law was incompatible with the Constitution; whereas this shows that effective checks
and balances in Member States as regards the rule of law and democracy are crucial for
the protection of LGBTIQ rights;
V. whereas being a parent in one Member State means that you are a parent in all Member
States; whereas there are cases of children with two same-sex parents who are facing
difficulties owing to the lack of legal provisions for the mutual recognition of a birth
certificate with two same-sex parents; whereas a forthcoming ruling of the CJEU will
decide on the case of a child with two lesbian mothers who faces statelessness due to
this legal lacuna; whereas the LGBTIQ Equality Strategy envisages a legislative
initiative to close this legal gap and a revision of the 2009 guidelines on free movement,
both scheduled for 2022; whereas same-sex couples continue to face difficulties when
exercising freedom of movement within the EU, but the Commission has nevertheless
not proposed initiating legislation on the mutual recognition of relationships;
W. whereas combating inequality in the EU is a shared responsibility, requiring joint efforts
and action at every level of government, and whereas local and regional authorities have
a key role to play in this; whereas these authorities are often responsible for
implementing EU laws and embracing equality and diversity; whereas the Congress of
Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe has adopted a resolution
recalling the responsibilities of local authorities in protecting the rights of LGBTIQ
persons and has invited them to appoint a ‘Local Expert on Equality and Diversity’13;
X. whereas the European Committee of the Regions, as a representative of local and
regional EU authorities, has been invited to consider taking action, within the remit of
its competences, in response to the development of zones free from so-called LGBT
ideology;
Y. whereas LGBTIQ persons everywhere in the European Union should enjoy the freedom
to live and publicly show their sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression
and sex characteristics without fear of intolerance, discrimination or persecution on
those grounds; whereas the right of asylum is guaranteed by the Charter; whereas
appropriate protection of vulnerable applicants, including LGBTIQ applicants, needs to
be ensured in the context of the common European asylum system and its reform;
whereas, rather than discriminating against LGBTIQ persons, the authorities at all levels
of governance across the entire European Union should protect and promote equality
and the fundamental rights of all, including LGBTIQ persons, and ensure their rights in
full;
1. Hereby declares the European Union an ‘LGBTIQ Freedom Zone’;
2. Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the governments and parliaments of
the Member States, the Council, the Commission, the European Committee of the
Regions and the European Economic and Social Committee.