warp and weft of a fine brocade
At bicon this summer, there was a workshop for the frowners and nodders who are willing to get up and out by ten on a Sunday morning, on bisexuality, theory and research. I clattered into my seat a little late and listened to the still somewhat sleepy discussion unfold. As consciousness began to raise itself from the lingering night before, some debate was had over the different value and contribution of activism and research to the bisexual cause, with talk of opposition, mutuality, jargon, and elitism.
Then ding, ding, round two, everyone was away for their next nibble of bicon’s hard and soft centred workshop selection box. But just as all good workshops should, the hour’s discussion provoked many thoughts and feelings, the most immediate of which was an intense desire for tea and nicotine. Cravings quenched, I decided to put my more considered provocations on paper, in the hope that the conversation of that Sunday morning might continue.
If I reflect on what activism means to me, I get images of hearty solidarity among good people who do real things to make a difference. Activism as political, empowering, meaningful and vital. Yet I also hear the oppressor hiss that it is misinformed, crass, deviant and dangerous.
As for research, I’ll declare my interest here. I’m doing a research project on bisexuality and therapy, so when I reflect on what that means for me, again it is real, political, empowering, meaningful and vital. However as a working class mature student, in a new university ranked by the Sunday Times as 103 of 123, I know very well the perception of research as a dried -up, remote activity for posh folks that serves no purpose other than being the library spiders’ patio. I had to overcome that in myself to even apply for the course – and then find an institution that would let someone of my background in! Of course research talk is jargonised, but try as it might to be exclusive, its nothing more than any other technical workplace shorthand, and activism has its own codes and talk too.
No one would call me an activist though. (Too isolated here with a pack of kids in a remote hideout in the West Midlands, with nothing of the bi community within seventy miles.) Not unless you count writing for BCN once or twice, giving a bit of support to a GLBT heaith project at work, and getting GLBT issues included in an equal opportunities document at my kids school, in spite of Section 28. And not unless you count my research project as being an action in itself.
Research and activism have had a fractious relationship in queer communities, as was evident in the bicon workshop, and I can’t help but feel this results from mistakenly internalising yet another false dichotomy, thrown our way by the oppressor like a bone to keep us gnawing, heads down, growling at ourselves.
Both research and activism are essential to the whole movement toward rights and recognition. They are interwoven like the warp and weft of a fabric, just as the workshop on bi theory and research was a piece of activism, gathering people together to converse and grow. Research and activism are like the simultaneous quantum wave and particle, done for the well-being and visibility of self and community, for political and personal change, processes of both discovery and direct action.
Research is an act in itself, recording and providing evidence for activism or practice. it is also about contact, empowerment, and engagement of participants, with publication and dissemination to new audiences. As an example of the inseparability of research and activism, take this quote from Lesbian and Gay Psychology Review March 2001:
“When the BPS (British Psychological Society) Lesbian and Gay Psychology Section was established in 1998, some criticism was voiced about its failure to include transgender and bisexual psychology in its title. The reason for this was that in order to meet the criteria for a Section we first had to identify a substantial British psychology literature on the proposed Section’s focal topics. While we could do this for lesbian and gay psychology, we were unable to do the same for transgender and bisexual psychology. We therefore decided to proceed with the attempt to establish a Lesbian and Gay Psychology Section and resolved that, once this was achieved, we would work to foster the development of transgender and bisexual psychology in Britain, with the ultimate aim of ensuring that they qualify for inclusion in the section title.
“with the aim of extending the Section’s inclusivity and broadening the scope of Lesbian and Gay Psychology Review, we would also like to invite Section members who know of noteworthy activists and service providers to conduct interviews with these individuals and write these up..for submission.”
This shows that even within the restrictions of a professional hierarchy, activism and research must weave the banner together, as if they waste time in opposition to each other, they will remain out of view forever. (And to this end, Lesbian and Gay Psychology Review extends a genuine offer publish articles from a bisexual perspective – if you are interested, contact me at bobbiesthere@blueyonder.co.uk for details).
My experience of doing research, and that of my co-researchers (participants), has been one of affirmation and increased visibility. Besides which, all! can do on my own is to read and write, surf and mail, so my project is very personal, and actively political, an opportunity born of my very circumstances. The co-researchers regard it as a live and active process too. One reckoned they’d never before seen the word bisexual printed in the journal that carried the project advert. As a research goes, it’s far from posh, conducted from my kitchen table entirely without funding. Telephone interviews to keep costs down, recorded on my son’s personal stereo with a borrowed computer mic. Cinderella style, perhaps, but it would have been impossible without the fairy godmother of telecommunications, still a privilege on much of the planet.
Perhaps especially for bi activism and research, for the sake of the missing middle, the relationship should be symbiotic. One can’t do without other, and it is not helpful, holistic, integrative, or inclusive to put a false and dualistic separation or conflict between them. Both processes reflect levels of bisexual and human experience. Research, felt as yin energy, is listening, reflective and
contemplative, the weft, holding the fabric together, giving texture, colour and tone to the brocade. Activism, felt as yang energy, of bi politics, rights and lives. Talking, doing, action and change, the warp, giving strength, direction, and definition to the cloth.
Woven throughout time, this bi brocade is gloriously full of lurex, velvet, pyc, spandex, and sequins, with a few snags and splits, but all in all, is warm, flexible, and flamboyant, a little fluffy and a little scratchy.
I was going to say I’d lay down a gauntlet for debate, but as this is about bi culture, it had better be a sparkly evening glove. Anyway, what have I missed out? What else does the bi community need to know about this? Is it cobblers or credible? Cotton or silk? This space is available for you to have your say – send it in to BCN.
Bobbie
