A case has arrived in the Court of Justice of the European Union about same-sex couples being recognised as parents across borders.
Bulgaria has refused to recognise the birth certificate of a child born in Spain at the end of 2019. This is because Spain recognises same-sex couples as parents for birth certificates, and Bulgaria does not as part of its continued failiure to recognise same-sex marriages – and the child’s parents are a female couple: one from Bulgaria, one from Gibraltar.
Bulgaria won’t admit the existence of same-sex parents, while the UK won’t register the child either as one of its mums being British is not deemed enough of a connection to confer citizenship.
Right now the birth certificate will seem a lot less exciting to the baby than almost everything else in the world, but in later life not having one could affect the child’s access to things like health services, pensions and other state benefits, or even whether she is allowed to go to school.
The case brought today argues that this breaches EU law which requires mutual recognition of partnerships – in this case of the two mothers but clearly with wider implications, not least because there are already other similar cases around the Union.
“The preliminary ruling is a long-awaited opportunity for the CJEU to continue strengthening LGBTQ+ rights within the EU”, Carsten Wendler, the law partner presenting the case told CompanyNews.
“LGBTQ+ couples and their children still face unequal treatment in the Member States. The EU court has the chance to clarify that once parentage is established in one Member State, all other Member States must recognise these vested rights regardless of their stance on same sex marriage,”
The legal firm are bringing the case pro bono to advance human rights recognition across Europe.
