New Netflix ‘reality dating show’ Love Is Blind highlighted how biphobia hits men in navigating and negotiating relationships.

The programme’s promotional blurb promised “singles who want to be loved for who they are, rather than what they look like, have signed up for a less conventional approach to modern dating where they hope to meet the person they want to spend the rest of their lives with… without ever having seen them”.

What that really means is a group of men and a group of women – all basically young, slim, pretty, conventionally smartly dressed and apparently not-yet-disabled – meeting in mixed-sex pairings, on opposite sides of a dividing wall that prevents them seeing one another.  They chatter a few times on voice-dates and try to find “the one”. Reality dating, for very particular definitions of real.

But for one of our guy contestants, he has an extra problem to wrestle: he’s had relationships with men in the past.  He explains to the camera how he is clear he wants to a long-term relationship with a woman, but when he has talked about his bisexuality with women in the past it has been the death-knell for relationships.  He feels he has to be honest about who he is and the life he has lived with someone in order to marry them – but speaking up risks losing everything yet again.

It’s interesting how he talks about his relationships with men though. They don’t seem to have had some of the softness and loving connection he’s looking for. I don’t think that’s impossible: maybe it’s just the kind of men he was meeting or felt able to connect with.

Carlton talks about this to the camera away from the ‘blind dates’ but by the time he meets the woman he proposes to face to face, he still hasn’t found a way to slip being bi into conversation.

It’s a common problem, the notion that bi men in particular are untrustworthy, that it’s a “stopping off point on the way to gay”, and that bi guys are way more likely to have an STI.

It is a ‘danger’ motif in contrast to the hypersexualisation of bi women, not least as ‘unicorns’ for couples wanting to have a third person in their relationship.

Indeed one female contestant makes a throwaway remark elsewhere that could be taken as a confession of bisexuality – but it just doesn’t appear as an issue or make the person she’s on a date with raise an eyebrow.

In episode three Carlton’s voiceover explains, as he is chatting with his prospective bride face-to-face at last:

“I have a big secret to tell Diamond about my sexuality and I’m so nervous. Every moment that I spend with her it’s in the back of my head.  If I don’t roll it out the right way with her it could just turn into a catastrophe where she just can’t deal with it.”

But – perhaps due to so much of his mind being taken up with his secret – he isn’t making as good an impression face-to-face as he was making from behind a screen when they were both still choosing who they might want to marry.

She figures out something’s wrong and he tearily explains:
“I feel like, I’ve always been in situations where people have abandoned me and have rejected me”
“You don’t have nothing to worry about.”
“Yeah I do… You have no idea, you could leave me at any moment cos I have not fully opened up.”
“What is it that you need to open up to me about?”
“I don’t feel like you’re going to want me after this information.”
“What information?”
“In the past… I have dated both genders.”
Her eyes widen and there is a pause of a few heartbeats.
“What do you mean, like male and female?”
“Male and female, yeah.” Let’s not get into the politics of that binary phrasing right now… we are busy having some more awkward pause.
“It’s a lot to accept. Like, I get it it’s okay. I have my fears, I have gone through the thought of, fuck you met the love of your life and now…”
“My question is: how do you know I’m the love of your life. Do you ever feel like you need to go date another man?”
“No. No that is the biggest misconception in the world. Men like me who are honest, I love people for who they are at the core. This,” (waves hands at his face) “has nothing to do with it. This,” (points at his crotch) “has nothing to do with it. Like that has never been the motivating force in my life. It’s a lot to accept.”
“Yeah.”
She looks down like this is all over.
“I’m looking at you now and-“”I’m listening”
“But I feel like, your eyes are so blank.”
“It’s a lot to take in” she protests.
“I know” he says, yelps “fuck!” and they each turn round and cry.
Diamond gets a voiceover now: “I love Carlton, but I was not prepared for that.”
I’m watching and wondering at it all. I know, I live in a very queer bubble: it’s easy to forget how bisexuality is a million miles from some people’s ideas of what they might find in a partner.
“I may leave this earth alone, but I will leave this earth saying I was fucking honest,” Carlton says choking back some tears. “I didn’t fucking deceive nobody, and I did one of the harded things that was ever done. I’m not a hider: what am I hiding for, why can I not be myself?”
“You can be yourself,” sighs Diamond. “I just need time to think about this as something – you just threw a curveball.”  And she walks away.
The next day she monologues to camera about how she is torn: this is someone she feels she wants to be with, but this has blindsided her and she loves him and hopes this can work out when she has got things off her chest.

They hug hello.
“I feel that you left out who you really are.”
“I get that you feel betrayed,”
“I feel like you played an experiment. I feel you weren’t honest with me from the get-go.”
“I was honest, I wanted you to get to know me for me. But in the beginning, you would pre-judged me. Would you have really – if I would have told you on the first day, would you have given me a chance?  You wouldn’t have.”
“I would rather you would have told me up front.  I would feel like: okay, you told me, but you are sure that you want to be with a female?  This is how I feel when I slept on it.”
Carlton gets his monologue to camera. “Last night she was rubbing my back, she was all, give me a hug, let me talk to you, I’m here for you. And today it’s all of a sudden you have an issue with it?  Nah.”
He asks her, “Do you really think that I would be here if I didn’t have real feelings? Like what, just for a trip? Show your true colours, I’ve shown mine.”
“But you didn’t! You waited til nearly four weeks away from our wedding.”
Carlton has a strong point here, albeit not one Diamond or perhaps most viewers are going to recognise, and the TV show production team are doing nothing to advocate for it. The shape of the show is such that if Diamond had felt off-balance about the bisexuality at the start, the two of them would not have had the additional blind dates that let to the marriage proposal.
If people assume heterosexuality without asking, when are we to tell them different?
“That’s fine? For you to do that?” she chastises him.
“It’s whatever you want at this point.”
He then claims he’s never had a reaction like this from a woman before.  Which for the viewers sits at odds with his previous claim to the camera that coming out had derailed budding relationships with women time and again.
“You’re so defensive with this,” Diamond says. “I’m telling you how I feel, I’m sitting here and talking to you about it. If I didn’t want to I wouldn’t be here, so don’t go playing the victim here.”
“It’s insulting to me at this point.”
“Oh so this is not insulting to me?  I’m on some real stuff – you don’t care, no feelings about how you took me through this.”
She hands back the engagement ring and tells him that he has “serious issues to disrespect me, to mislead me that you really were into me. If you were you would have told me from day one that – ‘Diamond I am bisexual’.”
“I don’t have to disclose information that I’m not ready for somebody – before I have disclosed that information too soon and been called all types of names.”
“You don’t think that’s misleading for other people!?” she yelps.

Well as a viewer I don’t, Diamond, because we are this far into a two-day fight about him having come out as bisexual and for everyone out here paying attention to your double-standards, you still haven’t told anyone whether you are straight.
They yell and she throws her drink over him, he throws the engagement ring in the swimming pool, and it seems pretty clear this is one couple that won’t make it down the aisle.
He monologues: “this is clearly not the woman for me, she’s proven herself to be ignorant, to be stereotypical, I feel betrayed just as much as she feels betrayed. So, fuck her.”
Diamond is putting on a show of crying for the camera.  “I was literally about to walk down the aisle with someone that clearly I didn’t know,” she explains, airbrushing over the way that she still hasn’t told him – or us – if she is straight. “I feel like it shouldn’t have got that way, I was really just there to talk to him and tell him how I felt. I was hoping he could be a man and talk to me but no real man would act like that. So it’s a done deal with us.”

Ah yes, “real” men.

She cries for the camera some more and we get a montage of the rise and fall of their relationship as they take separate cabs to the airport home.
The programme hits against other relationship preconceptions too as one potential couple fall apart when one of them decides their age gap is too big for love to be possible. One partner after a wedding proposal from behind a screen meets their new fiance and wonders whether it can work out when they are not from the same racial background. And every match started with the guy asking the girl to marry him.
To borrow a line from Carter USM: it’s like punk never happened.

I thought the story would end up on a sour but sadly honest note there with someone being rejected for failing to perform their bisexuality in an unattainably perfect way.
But the gossip media picked up on the rocky road Carlton has faced since his time on the show ended: therapy, online death threats, and according to tmz.com emergency services being called to his house following social media posts about feeling isolated, unsupported by his community and fellow celebs – tweeting “Black lives matter until it’s an LGBT Black life. Also, so called “celebrity” friends on social media have every opportunity to defend my CHARACTER yet they don’t!”

The programme makers are now recruiting for a second season. As so often with TV opportunities, approach with caution…


This article originally appeared in the April 2020 edition of Bi Community News (issue 160).

You can read more from that edition of the magazine here.

To get the latest BCN content subscribe to have it delivered direct to your door all through the year.