A Very Bisexual Intervention
One of the goals of BCN is to let different sections of the community know what each other are doing. So when I was in York at Christmas, I went to visit Ann Kaloski and Clare Hemmings, who set up the Bi Academic Intervention network.
Why is it called Bi Academic Intervention?
To distinguish it from other bi organisations. The name academic is in it, so it’s clear that that is the main focus – and so it’s clear that one of the aims is to intervene in academia as well as generally.
It started at the Nottingham BiCon where some of us met and decided to stay in touch. We started by running a mailing list with people contacting each other.
Now we also run day schools twice a year. We’ve had four so far. There’s a newsletter that we send out, keeping people in touch with conferences, publications and calls for papers. And there’s a publishing collective too.
We’re building a base from which we have a sense of ourselves as a group doing bi theory. We all felt isolated, and didn’t have a sense of what ‘bisexual theory’ might be, but now we have a space to develop those ideas.
So what is bisexual theory?
We talk about ‘theorising bisexually’ rather than ‘theorising about bisexuality.’
‘Theorising about bisexuality’ is discussing how bisexuality itself has appeared in various cultures, texts, films, etc. Discussions about bisexuality – how has it manifested itself, how has it been talked about, how accepted was it, what stereotypes were used against it. The problem is that this approach assumes that bisexuality exists as a thing in itself, rather than being a relatively recent concept for fixing how people desire one another.
‘Theorising bisexually’ means looking at things from a bisexual perspective – drawing on all the bi ideas of fluidity, diversity and change to think about sexuality in ways that are influenced by bisexuality, but don’t just involve pointing it out.
A concrete example would be: someone theorising about bisexuality might talk about how lesbians who have sex with men are repressed bisexuals; whereas theorising bisexually means holding on to the fact that people’s identities, behaviours and desires might never quite come together – theorising bisexually is about keeping all your balls in the air (so to speak), the way that most bisexuals have had to.
The interest is not in some kind of ‘truth’ about bisexuality, but in how bisexuality varies and appears in different contexts, communities and periods. In particular, how it’s related to other sexualities. It’s not about cutting bisexuality off from society.
Bisexuality expresses itself among other desires and identities that it’s not separated from. Increasingly, it expresses itself through them, or even as them. And because we’ve been going for a while, it’s safer to say that.
When I desire women, it isn’t always a bisexual desire – sometimes I experience it completely as a lesbian desire. Which isn’t denying bisexuality. We don’t have to celebrate bisexuality always because of its lack of visibility. You can be bisexual and experience lesbian, gay and het desire – just as lesbians can experience bisexual or heterosexual desire.
We’ve debated a lot on whether bisexuality is identity or desire. For a time I felt you could only talk about bisexuality if that’s what people identified as. I’m increasingly aware that it goes further than that. The danger is then unearthing bisexuality in places where it isn’t ‘bisexuality.’ By calling something bisexuality you’re producing it in a particular way – you’re placing it in the realms of psychology, and the twentieth century, and Anglo-American identity.
How did your view on bisexual theory develop?
Ann: Looking back at my adolescent diaries from the 60s, there were a couple of months of wondering if I was a lesbian, and then I was bisexual. I never really got beyond that. Back then, I couldn’t say anything about what it meant.
Clare: I identified as bisexual for a long time, but never had any desire to read or write about it – it was just a way of describing who I desired. It was only the absence of things to read that made me upset! And the few bi books there were weren’t the whole story.
In fact, none of the existing community stuff felt right to us. We thought there must be a lot of people like us who don’t want to be part of a grass-roots, identity-based movement. That’s only one way of being bisexual. The more ways there are of thinking about bisexuality, the more ways there are for people to feel comfortable about their sexualities, whatever they might be. That’s what we’re about.
A lot of people that come to our day schools aren’t interested in BiCon. Without us they’d just disappear. What we’re doing is important – no less important than marching on the streets. And in the 90s not many people are marching anyway!
If, instead, people start thinking about what bisexuality means, or about its relationship to other sexualities, you’re creating a whole new form of coalition politics.
What does the future hold for you?
There’s a book coming out at the end of the year – ‘The Bisexual Imaginary: Bisexuality and Representation.’ It’s probably the first book that uses different forms of bisexual theory throughout.
It’s edited by the Bi Academic Intervention collective, with essays by different people in the network. The book is about ways of representing bisexuality in film, literature, history, psychology and photography – including photographs exploring new images of bisexuality. It’s to give bisexuality status as a subject to be incorporated into academic discussion of culture, sexual politics, feminism etc. and to make us think about the consequences of different ways of imagining bisexuality.
We’re also editing a special edition of the Journal of Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Identities – coming out at the same time.
It looks like December 1996 will be one for your diary.
Jo Eadie
