With recent months’ headlines dominated by the Pride name-change, it seemed time to consider the question of why we should be channelling our energies in that direction.

Why extend an event set up to celebrate the lesbian and gay community, to include bisexuals?

For most lesbians and gay men, the thinking seems to be that because we all share same-sex desires, we should all be free to celebrate them together. And don’t a lot of bisexuals put time, money and good looks into those communities? And shouldn’t we have that acknowledged? Sounds good.

Except that most bisexuals don’t just want ‘half’ their sexuality celebrated, because our sexuality can’t be split in two – although it’s true that most bisexuals attending Pride with same-sex lovers feel a lot more at home than those with different-sex lovers (I know that my sense of belonging fluctuates from year to year on that score). So maybe even if we don’t split our desires in two, we have to put up with the splitting that others do to us. Knowing when we feel really welcome at Pride, and when merely tolerated. Which isn’t a basis on which to be put in the title.

So do we say that we are linked by our same-sex desires, but are celebrating all our other desires too , whatever they are, and that Pride should adopt that position? Also sounds good.

But it’s not at all clear that many bisexuals do see themselves as having connections with the lesbian and gay world. In which case, why link up with Lesbian and Gay Pride? Are we saying ‘bisexuals who don’t feel at home don’t have to come’ – thereby undermining what would be, supposedly, a celebration of bisexuality by linking it to an event which many bisexuals see as irrelevant to their lives? Which bisexuals is this event meant to be for?

Or do we say ‘all bisexuals should feel involved’, and set about making the day welcoming to swingers, heterosexual men-who-have-sex-with-men and anyone with bi leanings, whether or not they have invested any time or energy in making an identity around them? If we take that line, there’s not a lot left of the lesbian-and-gay component, and we’re moving beyond a celebration of same-sex desire and on to a celebration of general sexual diversity – including heterosexual polyamorists and fetishists. Which would be great – except that lesbians and gay men would, no doubt, go back to wanting a celebration of their own, taking us back to square one.

This isn’t to say that just because any option seems to lead to slippery slopes and dead-ends, we shouldn’t try to change anything. But I think we should be asking: why do we want to see this change?

I suspect that it’s because many of us feel a deep affinity to the lesbian and gay community – and have spent large amounts of time and energy there. We want that investment validated, and we want a welcome from a place we have called home at times.

But for many – or even most – bisexuals, it never has been a home. Many don’t see any connection to the gay or lesbian communities, and don’t understand why bisexuality should be tacked onto this event, rather than anywhere else.

Labels like ‘gay-identified bi’ have been pushed out these days as not being bi-positive enough – but they were a useful way of recognising that some bisexuals felt involved with the lesbian and gay world, and others not at all. With that recognition lessened, we need to ask how we can signal what the complicated links between the two are – and I’m not convinced that a shared march is an accurate or honest way of doing that. Not for lesbians and gay men – because they only want us there if we leave our opposite-sex lovers at home – and not for many bisexuals, who frankly don’t see the point.

A different perspective might be to ask why we want to forge these alliances with the lesbian and gay community at all. It sometimes seems that it’s a community which can only exist by marketing itself as a unique and distinct desire – a notion which suits heterosexuals very well, because then they can go on distancing themselves from their own queer longings. As long as ‘the homosexual’ is a separate species, everyone is happy. And now, when bisexuals are trying to remind everyone that erotic attraction can appear at the most unexpected places, we’re leaping at the chance to have our own species, ‘the bisexual’, which will go on placating the straight world by not trying to blow apart its categories. And which will go on a big march once a year where we point at tourists on buses and say ‘we’re completely different from you’.

Maybe instead of limiting bisexual pride to one day, one place, one time of the year, we ought to be looking at how to make more places proud of their unrecognised bisexuals. Except… wasn’t that why we wanted the name change in the first place?

Jo Eadie