Just a note in response to Judy’s in issue 2 of Bi Community News, I am delighted that she found the weekend useful, moving and well-planned. I was there for just one day of it, and would agree completely with her feelings; I learned a lot, met some wonderful people and only wish that I could have managed both days. Well done Kath – it was an immense achievement.

However, I don’t want to talk about the weekend in general as Judy has already covered that. I was there as one of the bisexuals living with Aids that she mentioned in her article, and I want to use this opportunity firstly to thank her for her comments, and secondly to thank everyone for all the love, help and support that I got from you all that day. As many of you who were there may have noticed, it wasn’t one of my best days, but you were all very patient and I appreciate it so much. I am not good at speaking in public and this was the first spiel I had ever made on the subject, so I was terrified and, I suspect, fairly incoherent ! But meeting everyone made the whole thing worthwhile and whilst I have not had much feedback what I have had has been good (although I suppose it could be said that people might feel a bit awkward about giving bad feedback!). I hope it provided light entertainment for you all, and thank you all again for being so friendly and non-judgemental.

Annie

- -- --- -- -
Dear BCN

As regards the Kilroy show, which still remains unshown, can we offer a slightly different perspective? They contacted us on the Friday before the Monday on which the recording took place, to ask if we’d still like to be on a show about what they call ‘threesomes’, we call ‘ extended marriages’ and everyone else calls ‘polyamory’. We did, and arrangements were made. By about 4pm on Saturday they had realised that they could not find an existing extended marriage (by which they mean a living-together polyamorous group) in which all the partners would be willing to come on the show: this, they felt, would not present a balanced view. At that point they decided that most poly people would be bisexual, they had a few bisexuals who could be pulled in at short notice (some of them had to be flown down from Edinburgh), so the show would be about bisexuality, with a segment on poly. That’s how it turned out.

As regards whether the show should have been about ‘what the public wants to know about’, that is a problem. When Kilroy zoomed in on us to talk about extended marriages, he wanted to know where the additional partner(s) would sleep. A fair question, but he wouldn’t take “that would be up to him” for an answer. There was so much we wanted to say about our own perceptions/experiences of extended marriage that wan’t about sex, but apparently the public don’t want to know. We suspect in a show actually about polyamory, there would be more chance to hijack it and talk about wider issues.

Moving on to the issue of responses to Charotte Raven. Surely the issue is not whether what she said was relevant/true, but where she said it? I (Joy) can sympathise enough with what Jo and Clare said to know that these are issues that need discussing, but within the bi community, not washing our dirty linen in publications that love to slag us off, singly and collectively.

On the question of being ‘diverse’, I think this grew up as a response to the tendency of the monosexual world to take anything any of us said as ‘what bisexuality is really about’. I felt a bit alienated on Kilroy by everyone asserting that they desire men and women equally, when in fact I am at least 95% heterosexual. But if I had come out and said so, I know it would have been interpreted as meaning ‘bisexuals are really straight’. Hence the tendency to refuse to say anything definite. The fact remains that the bisexual community includes, or potentially includes, everyone who is 1% to 99% heterosexual, plus anyone else who is in a relationship or friendship with a bisexual person, or just feels constrained by the sexist assumptions of a monosexual society. That being the case, it is difficult to make any definite statements about what we are.

(By the way, the ‘anonymous clubgoer’ on Issue 2 page 2 is Marcus Morgan, who isn’t ‘anonymous’ by any reasonable definition!).

Best wishes,

Anthony and Joy Hilbert

(formerly Anthony Gilbert and Joy Hibbert).

The caption under Marcus’ picture was supposed to be ironic …{Krayg}

- -- --- -- -
Dear Newsletter,

I read that subscribers had sent in their suggestions for newsletter names and voted on BCN. As one of your subscribers, I’d like to know what those other suggestions were, otherwise it just isn’t a fair vote. I’m know I’m not alone in thinking this – there are other frustrated Mancunian subscribers! Bi Community News sounds like a mixture of worthy and twee. It also makes me feel like I live in a therapeutic village. Please can you print what the other ideas were and have another vote? ‘100 percent Bi’ – the title from one of Rachel House’ cartoons would be a good one.

I’m sorry to be complaining about what is a small detail in an otherwise excellent newsletter.

Weeza.

I can symapthise with the mancunian dissenters. It wasn’t an easy decision finding the right name – perhaps something that pleases most people is bound to lack spark a little. But people scrawled objections all over their subscription forms about other attempts like Basic Instincts orAmphibious. I do think it’s vital, though, that we make the issue of community so central – particularly since it is a source of such contention amongst bisexuals. One hundred per cent bi ? See the above letter for some of the problems with that as a name.

I’ll see if I can dig out what other names people proposed for the next issue {Jo}

- -- --- -- -
Dear BCN

I like BCN a lot, as it does give me a feeling of ‘belonging’ somewhere. But I do find that many of the discussions are about topics which affect parts of the community rather than things which affect us all. Not that I am against this – I would just like to see more things which affect us all in addition to the other (academia, spirituality, SM bis) stuff. Ideas for more general topics would be a booklist, with brief reviews of each (and where to buy them); a film list of bi related films (including porn, if that is allowed – anybody seen a good bi porn film?); a discussion on coming out and people’s experiences; accepting our bisexuality; discussions on polygamous relationships; being bi and married; attraction. I’m sure I could think of many others too – maybe each issue could have a 2 or 4 page major theme, touted in advance, and with letters in following months.

Regards

Alan Ford

Lots of useful ideas Alan. Keep your eyes open for more “general interest” material in future months. {Jo} We will also be producing an ‘Intro Pack’ [with a better name than that] which will hopefully cover some general topics in an introductory way. {Krayg}

- -- --- -- -
Dear BCN,

Re:Jo Eadie’s “Ravin’ about Raven”. The editor of Bifrost at one time had an e-mail sign off that went something like: “It’s better to start a flame trail than it is to curse the darkness” (apologies if I’ve got the intent wrong, as well as the wording). As long as Jo’s article is seen as meant to stir up controvery and get issues raised, then it makes sense. If his article is taken seriously, then it not only contradicts itself, but it also contradicts an article he wrote in Issue Zero, entitled “BiCon Revisited”.

In “Bicon Revisited”, Jo was promoting unexpected alliances, renaming cliques as networks/friendships, and celebrating our ability to make things happen. Now he seems to be saying that here is someone (Raven) who looks at the bisexual option and doesn’t like what she sees, as she finds our rules, slogans, clothes and name hurtful. Jo says that this should cause reflection on our part, and that the fall-out rate from local bi groups should add to our desire to do so. Jo lists some things that he, or others, don’t like in the community, or at BiCon, and says that we shouldn’t ignore these dislikes in the name of diversity. He also says we shouldn’t use claims of diversity as a cover for saying “don’t complain about us”. He asks: are we diverse, or are we all so similar that we exclude newcomers? Well Jo, you can’t have your cake and eat it too: wasn’t it you who said that we should rename cliques as networks ?

What Raven has regurgitated and then judged us with are all the tired cliches and bigotry of biphobia. Raven could never have seen anything that she would accept about us. because what she dislikes are her assumptions about us. She wasn’t looking for any challenge to them, only confirmation.She is so in love with cliches that if you can spot any she didn’t use, I’m sure she’d be grateful if you sent them to her.

Jo’s opinions concern me more than Raven’s. Yes, we should reflect on the views of newcomers who don’t stay, especially when we can get their opinions, but how hard are we going to beat ourselves ? Just because someone says we are all the same, does that make it true ? Many people come to bisexuality with misconceptions and fears – it will be a great day when we can meet them at the door, greet them with somebody who is “just like them”, mind-read their particular misconceptions/fears and gently reassure them with believable information which they absorb. Some people also come looking for instant sex, or a panacea for all ills, but despite Jo’s wishes we can’t make everyone a happy bunny.

In “Ravin’ about Raven”, Jo says the label “bisexual” sounds like a specimen-jar label – but homosexual and heterosexual sound equally so, and we have no equivalent of lesbian, gay or straight. As some people still moan about the abuse of the English language, and the “misuse” of the word gay, “Nice” was suggested as one way of offending the same people, and giving us a non-sexually linked name as well. This was meant as a joke. People are still arguing about “gay” and “queer”, and there is never any hope of getting all bisexuals to agree on something as important as a name.

Jo says we may as well call ourselves “SMUG” – well Jo, it was only after our last conference that you were celebrating our ability to make things happen. In the light of our conferences, our presence at Pride, our phonelines, our national groups, and not least our brilliant newsletter, I’d be more than happy for our group name to be SMUG.

Judy

Well Judy, I never thought I’d hear another bisexual telling me that I couldn’t have my cake and eat it too, but there you go. Thanks also for pointing out that I have more than one opinion – it’s nice to see that diversity of attitudes is a Good Thing in the community, but a Bad Thing in any individual. {Jo}