Charlotte Raven’s ‘Swap Shop’, (Observer Life, 15 October 1995), managed to offend nearly everyone. Jo and Clare make sure nobody gets left out.
When Charlotte Raven wrote in The Observer that bisexuality was “the love that should never speak its name”, it was obviously the job of the editor of BCN to condemn and ridicule her . I guess. Or is it my job to listen to what all bisexuals have to say? And Raven’s announcement that bi desire is the only “viable response in a world which contains both Liam Gallagher and Kate Moss” makes her, surely, one of us. In community work, the announcement by a member of a community that they find its rules, its slogans, its clothes , and its very name hateful, might be a cause for reflection. In our community, it’s been taken as a call to write to the Press Complaints Commission to shut her up, and to describe her criticisms as self-hatred and internalised oppression.
And yet reading the article, what stands out is (and who could miss it ?) not excessive self-hatred, but excessive self-love. “No pejorative term evolved for the bisexual” observes Raven; “Potential taunters obviously agreed that the existing one was bad enough”. And who would want to argue ? Could anyone with any self-respect be happy claiming a label that makes them sound like they belong in a specimen jar, or a zoo ?
What Raven detests is the way that bisexual politics, with its calls for all-round niceness, opts for “terrible gloopy wholesomeness” (a phrase that more than one ex-Bicon attender has come close to muttering). Here is the voice of someone who looks at “the bisexual option” and doesn’t like what she sees. And the fall-out rate from local bi groups might make us think that this is a line of thought worth pursuing. What does happen to everyone who isn’t happy with patchwork clothes and cheerily fashionable fetish gear ? Who hates the fact that you can’t move at Bicon without someone offering you a hug ? Who dislikes counselling-speak’s vacuous neutrality ? Or new-age paganism’s endless syrupy cliches ?
And Goths ? Don’t get me started on Goths.
Of course, in our community the word we use to address this problem is “diversity” – subtitle for IBIS 96, celebratory opening of an article in last month’s newsletter. When ever anyone criticises, we tell them that we are very diverse. What if diversity becomes shorthand for: don’t complain about us. Are we diverse ? It’s not what I hear from the people who come back from Bisexual Conferences saying: “Oh God, they were all the same – and none of them were like me”.
Does anyone remember the name badges we gave out at the Nottingham Bi Conference ? They all bore the elegend (and I shudder to recall it) “NICE”. Perhaps that should have read “SMUG”. And this month I saw one of the folders from the BASH PEP training weekend. On the front was printed: “smiling is mandatory”, followed by that very thing which Raven singles out as indicative of the bi community’s forced happiness: a big, fat, jolly exclamation mark.
I didn’t need to be told it was a bisexual event.
Jo Eadie
My problem with Raven’s article, while I disagree in principle with slagging off bisexuality, and hate the fact that there aren’t many positive images of bisexuals out there, is that, in the end, I’m inclined to agree with her analysis of contemporary bisexual identity. Raven has picked up on the ways most bisexuals talk about their identity. She’s not the only one fed up with celebrations of bisexuality as the ‘best of both worlds’, ‘twice the fun!’, and a possibility for anyone if only they’d lighten up, open up, and accept the bisexual open invitation to ‘party!’
The current tendencies with the bisexual movement to celebrate bisexuality as ‘beyond gender’, or ‘beyond binary oppositions’ (which were much in evidence when Kilroy was recorded) sound pretty much like what Raven says about us, only from a different angle. Bisexuality clearly does not go beyond gender entirely, since it is dependent upon attraction to both sexes from its definition. The ‘beyond’, really means ‘both’, or ‘either’, and in the Freudian structure (which it relies on – Freud’s notion that we are all born with a bisexual potential) is really ‘before’. Bisexuality as potential, bisexuality as gleeful over-stimulation, undirected desire. More insidious perhaps, bisexuality as the innate propensity that accounts for heterosexuality and homosexuality (because it comes first in childhood), and therefore allows for conversion back to heterosexuality. To say bisexuality is beyond gender (overused bi movement slogan) is not so far from Raven’s statement that ‘bisexuality represents libidinal self-expression to a heterosexual audience’. It interests people because it looks like something you’re bound to grow out of. Bisexuality as the freedom not to have to choose one or the other (how many times have I heard that one) really does locate bisexuality as pre-oedipal, as part of the structure of heterosexuality. ‘There is a kind of affectlessness in failing to come down on either side’, a kind of juvenile stubborness to extricate oneself from the responsibility-free polymorphous years. This might explain Raven’s accusation of banality ( everyone’s bisexual really, so who gives a fuck? Nobody really needs to change, because we’re all bisexual already ! well hooray ) and also the embarrassment factor – nerdy pre-pubescent children are kind of cute in their own way, but as an identity?
It is probably worth pointing out that I don’t actually think that bisexual desire is pre-social, pre-oedipal, or pre-anything. Bisexuals do make sexual choices all the time – ever wanted to shag someone you don’t fancy? I don’t think so – due to specific variables (intellect, money, class, height, ethnicity, music-taste, gender). When we call bisexuality ‘beyond’, or “nothing to do with gender” , or “breaking down binaries”, etc, we are actually saying the same things as Raven (that bisexuality is a vague, undifferentiated, sticky happiness) but in a celebratory, rather than derogatory way. So why cling to the ‘beyond’ rhetoric? Can’t we resist the Freudian structure, just for a second. He’s been dead an awfully long time (though he did have a beard, I suppose).
If we can just bring ourselves to admit that bisexuals do choose, and yes on the basis of gender and sex, as well as other things, we might be able to trash Raven for being part of the Freudian old-school, rather than having to ignore the ways in which she says things that are similar to what the bisexual movement says in order to discredit her (and others like her.)
Clare Hemmings
