Economics, apparently…
Stephanie Theobold came up with the term ‘bi-try’ to describe the phenomenon of women having sex with women but refusing to admit to being lesbian or bisexual. In The Guardian
(March 30) she looks again, after Joy Brook (WDC Kerry Holmes in The Bill) announced that, contrary to an interview in the Guardian last year when she stated she was a bisexual, she is in fact 100% a
heterosexual, and never found her female ex-lover attractive physically, despite living with her for two years.
I’d love to hear what the ex-lover had to say when she heard that. Much as we all want people to fall for our personalities, not just our looks, to hear that someone you shagged for two years claims never, whatsoever, to find anyone of your entire gender attractive, must be a blow to the ego.
Theobold asks a good question: what will Brook do if ‘an image of a comely nude female’ pops into her mind in ten years time? Will she ‘stroke her wedding dress for reassurance?’ But if she’s entering monogamous marriage, I’d have thought the gender of a tempting body wouldn’t make much difference. Brook is marrying a “committed Christian” – it’s implied her sudden vehement heterosexuality is related.
The rest of the article, however, is not to do with this story. Instead of examining why Brook (like so many public figures) would deny the validity of a past affair, she takes Brook’s statement “I fell in love with … her personality, not what she was physically” as a “fatuous implication that women – still – don’t have a sex drive of their own”. She also finds the fact that “we apparently all become reactionary and frightened after the age of 21” a “shocking assumption”. Shocking? Has she never seen final year undergraduates, one by one, dyeing their hair back to a more natural colour, removing piercings, the men cutting off the ponytails they’ve spent three years cultivating? It’s a truism that people become more conservative as they age – some as young as 21. Admittedly it’s an overgeneralization – for every college bisexual who decides to stick with the easy option of other-sex relationships afterwards, there’s another who ‘only realises’ their sexuality later in life. I’ll let Theobold off for ignoring that, though, as it’s only younger women who’ve been publicised in the ‘bitry’ coverage.
There’s pressure to be straight, sure. But Theobold is convinced “women are less allowed to experiment with their sexuality than men”, because “Men feel threatened by women who…are solely interested in women”. They ‘punish’ these women by “extracting the women on woman concept, water it down, eroticise it…. turn it into a lot of old nonsense”. But, she claims, men don’t get punished by ‘such sexuality appropriation’. No? No. “They get queerbashed instead.” So that’s all right then.
Her other arguments are equally dodgy. Her problem with the whole ‘bi-try’ is that it’s used by magazines which are “only interested in propping up the old regime of heterosexuality.” Really? The magazines which have discussed women experimenting with bisexuality are Elle and Cosmopolitan, plus women’s weeklies. I can see Cosmo having a problem with its “Give a great blow job” articles if half its readers weren’t wanting sex with men, but Elle is a fashion magazine. Surely Theobold herself doesn’t think that women who currently read Elle will stop wanting stylish clothes and the latest image just because they’re trying to attract a woman rather than a man? That would be falling for exactly the stereotypes she attacks in the following sentences: “Nobody at a deep level really fell for any of
that fashion/’lesbian chic’ stuff; the propaganda campaign that worked best of all was the dungarees/fat/cat one.”
If we found the ‘basic threat’ that men feel about non-exclusively-hetero women, “we could bottle it and sell it. Except the only people who would want to buy it are feminists and they don’t have any money.”
Another perpetuated stereotype: women are broke. Which doesn’t help her other argument that men have a “vested interest in creating fake lesbians because they can make money from them.” Or are many more men purchasing glossy women’s magazines nowadays? If men want titillating pictures of women, I doubt they’re suddenly picking up Elle rather than the mags that have been dedicated to the purpose since long before ‘bi-try’ was heard of.
She points out that it is worrying when someone’s sense of what it is to be a woman seems to be ‘feeble’, dictated by a ‘manmade’ image. True, although in fact she is describing a ‘sense of what it is to be attracted to another woman’ – a very different thing. And she blames men (‘planet earth’ is ‘run by men’) exclusively, despite the almost totally female staff of the magazines responsible for publicising ‘bi-try’. Yes, men fantasise about bi women. But she’s hardly begun to examine all the different pressures on women’s sexuality.
Family. The fact that 90% of men fancy women while only 10% or so of women do. Urge to produce children. Wanting to appear normal. Being afraid to admit to enjoying any sex at all. The stigma of acting bisexual in lesbian communities. Being just as scared of queer-bashing as a man, whatever the statistics say. Wanting to go back to what you are used to.
It’s not just male bosses.
HT
