An open letter to Diva responding to their brush with bisexuality at the end of 2001.
Behind butch bravado and erratic linguistics there is a woman in serious existential crisis. Fiona Johnstone, having climbed strenuously out of the closet and into “a fully-fledged steel toe-capped lesbian lifestyle”, now finds that she’s bi, and tells her story in a piece called “Life sucks. when you can’t get back in the closet” in Diva (November 01).
Stranded outside the only closet she knows – the lesbian closet – Fiona is trapped in the bipolar mindset that has driven weaker bi’s into depression, self-harm, and beyond. Fiona is to be congratulated for leveraging her angst into a fee from the Gay Times Group for her “coming in” story.
She got it wrong in every way. Her choice of mother was a bad early move. (Mum is of the fundamentalist “Why did God curse me with a bent child?” brigade). Picking Paul to “conquer [her] unconquered territory” was an unfortunate later choice. He was too “drunk and incapable” that first night, and the following morning Fiona’s mother stormed into her bedroom, “yanked the duvet cover off the bed and bellowed, “Don’t you know she’s a lesbian?!”
Whereat, poor Paul loses his Ian Fleming cool (all boys think they’re Bond in bed, no?). He doesn’t remind mother that it’s polite to wait one’s turn, and remark that here indeed is pussy galore. Instead he rushes off in unseemly haste, and, thereby says Fiona, “put the kaibosh on any fantasies I had about being found to be a fantastic lay.”
Her friends are little better. Fiona confided in her “best lezzer mate”, Kerri. First there was disbelief, then there was anger and then came tears, reports Fiona. Lesbians tell her that all she needs is “a good dildo-shagging to ‘sort me out'”.
Fiona paints herself as a difficult character. “I was so butch the even lesbians were intimidated by me.. I told the world and anyone else who would listen that I was a man-hating feminist lesbian bitch.”
Nonetheless, your heart goes out to Fiona. She has discovered, she says, that she is “one of those indecisive, attention-seeking people that I, and seemingly the whole gay community, loathe so much. I tried so hard to be gay, dismissing bisexuals as wannabes and greedy arses.”
The piece suffers from stilted syntax and a fretful tone, but even more from uncompromising self-loathing. No warmth or empathy is shown towards bisexuality. It has no redeeming qualities. Fiona writes as if she were afflicted with a disease. “I really wouldn’t have chosen to go through all the mockery and the embarrassment of being called a shite lay that I’ve endured during my ‘coming in’ experience if I hadn’t thought I had to, believe me,” she writes.
Fiona, as we bi’s know, there is a range of sexualities and a series of closets to endure, or to leave. Emerging from the bi closet can be hardest, if a narrow gay culture rejects you and the mainstream straight world denies you. But it doesn’t have to be like that.
Another thing. Here’s a rare event: Diva has let bisexuality in between its covers. But in such a hostile piece. Diva – you owe your readers (and your writers) a reminder that bisexuals are not sick homosexuals, nor heterosexuals on holiday, but human beings who can be quite ordinary, but also often nice, rather clever, and who can, if they choose to, support each other – for example by subscribing to Bi Community News.
Poppy
