Jo Eadie catches up with Clare Hemmings

clare_hemmingsI first met Clare Hemmings at the ‘Activating Theory’ conference in York in 1992.

The conference had been widely promoted at the National Bisexual Conference in Norwich, and as a result had a strong bi contingent.  There were a batch of us giving work on bisexuality – including David Bell, Merl Storr, and Ann Kaloski. Merl, Ann, Clare and I would go on to co-ordinate a series of seminars called ‘Bi Academic Intervention’, which would eventually lead to us publishing a book of the same name (which received a rather complimentary review back in BCN 22 and which has, I’m proud to say, the best cover of any book on bisexuality ever published).  David’s book ‘Mapping Desire’ is pretty much the key text on sexuality and geography. I say all this not out of vanity – well, alright, I say it out of quite a lot of vanity, but also because it’s a welcome reminder that bisexuality can still be a career-choice!  Although many workplaces still enforce closets of various sorts, we have all been lucky enough to keep our sexuality at the heart of our work.  Perhaps that’s made us take being bi for granted, leading to the harsh assessments of bisexual politics that we all seem to have taken in our writing.

Anyway, ten years on Clare’s new book is out. ‘Bisexual Spaces: A Geography of Sexuality and Gender‘ takes us on a tour of a number of key places where bisexuals mingle, asking what each one tells us about how as bisexuals we think about our sexuality, and how other groups use bisexuality to define, police and make sense of their own spaces.  I caught up with her over email, packing before leaving for Duke University to spend the summer as a visiting lecturer in the USA.

Jo: Bisexuality is a big topic, but any book on it has to start somewhere. So of all the facets of bisexual culture to address, what made you choose ‘space’ and what does it tell us about bisexuality?

Clare:  I became interested in thinking about space when it struck me that there are very few specifically bisexual spaces, despite the number of people who either identify as bisexual, or who have sex with more than one sex. I realised that this must mean that lesbian and gay, as well as straight spaces, or mixed spaces, are ones bisexuals negotiate on an everyday level. I’d originally thought that this was a question of exclusion – you know,  bisexuals not being able to express themselves or be themselves – but I came  to think about it more positively in terms of the complex ways that  bisexuals learn to survive and make their desires known. Since this sense of being in a space that doesn’t recognise you in name is central to what it means to be bisexual, I wanted to pay as much attention to that process as  to spaces that do name bisexuality directly. For most of us, that’s an everyday reality of what it means to be bisexual.

Jo: When we first met, we were trying to put bisexuality on the agenda. Following on from that, a lot of what you seem to do here is stress the  unrecognised relevance of bisexuality for existing academic and political debates – is it an ‘activist’ book in that sense? Is it making a case for bisexuality?

Clare: I hadn’t thought about it quite like that. A lot of responses to how bisexuality has been talked about within academia have stressed its exclusion – what I consistently see is its centrality, though. Bisexuality might not be named, and it might not be engaged with directly, but assumptions about bisexuality often form the basis of contemporary sexuality studies.  And in political contexts, bisexuality frequently marks the boundaries of queer political credibility.  I don’t think the book makes the case for bisexuality as such in any clear way, and certainly not in terms of insisting on bisexuality as better, or essential, or more enjoyable or what have you. But I think it makes the case for taking bisexuality seriously – both academically and politically. It asks: what difference would taking bisexuality seriously make to current political and theoretical perspectives in lesbian and gay studies?

Jo: And outside lesbian and gay studies too? I’m wondering about the role that academic writing plays in wider debates about the bisexual community.  After all, ‘Bisexual Spaces’ is a mix of quite different materials – some very theoretical,  some  more journalistic.  Where would you suggest a non-specialist reader started?

Clare:  It’s true – the Introduction and first chapter to the book put the work in the theoretical context of feminist, bisexual and queer theory and so might only appeal to people who are interested in those perspectives. I think I’d probably start with Chapter Two, “No Place Like Home”, if I didn’t have a  particular interest in bi theory.  That chapter is an ethnography of the place of bisexuality in the history and  politics of Northampton, Massachusetts, known as ‘Lesbianville, USA’ to its  locals.

The late 1980s and early 1990s saw highly charged debates over whether or not to include the term bisexuality in the title of the annual Lesbian and Gay Pride March.  In the end the battle went in favour of bisexual inclusion, but while in one way this was a success, in another it falsely separately bisexuality from lesbian community – one possible reason for the lack of sustained bisexual politics in Northampton after that point.  Bisexual activists might also be drawn to the final chapter on the first US national bisexual conference in San Francisco in 1990 – they might even recognise themselves in its pages!

Jo: But even where we come together in shared spaces, I sense you’re keen to dispel the notion that as bisexuals we all have a shared identity. But at the same time you do seem to want to say that bisexuality generates a particular and distinctive perspective on the world for us.  Can you have it both ways!?

Clare:  Hmm, hard one to answer! Tempting to simply say, of course I can!  I definitely don’t think that bisexuals shared a particular identity, but I do think that we have significant shared histories and experiences that are important to trace. In this I’ve been really influenced by Eve Sedgwick’s perspective on shared cultural knowledge, rather than on shared identities. She doesn’t extend her argument to think about bisexuality, though, and partly this is what I wanted to do in the book – think about what bisexual cultural knowledge might look like, and what value it might have, without saying that bisexuals are the same, are uniquely oppressed, or need to emerge as a separate movement.

It goes back to your question about space – what is particular about how bisexuals have to negotiate space on a daily level?  And so a specific feature of bisexual cultural knowledge concerns  negotiating spaces that don’t recognise them – and this is true of both subcultural and dominant spaces. That’s a distinct perspective, even though I don’t think it produces a singular identity.

Jo: A large part of what seems, in your reading, to make bisexuality  distinctive is that it recognises it can only be understood through its connections with other kinds of identity, whereas other sexualities may want  to  think of themselves as more separate than they really are.  Am I right?

Clare: Yes, I think that’s right. Though it’s not as though other sexualities don’t often have a sense of self that is at odds with the spaces they negotiate. It’s more that this can’t not be the case for bisexuals  currently.

In terms of connections with other identities, I think that’s an ideal  outcome, but not a necessary outcome. The lack of recognition of bisexuality might indeed result in a very clear assertion of difference for example, or  simply in lack of a strong sense of self.  But a ‘healthy bisexuality’ (to rip off Fritz Klein, here) would be one where the central partiality of bisexual experience results in adaptive connectivity. I hadn’t thought of it quite like that before.

Jo: So we connect and mix with others – in our personal and political lives – never being purely bisexual.  Has thinking through the questions that the book raises suggested any  key  points to bear in mind as we create new bisexual spaces, and as we move  ‘bisexually’ into the spaces of others?

BCN cover image
This appeared in BCN issue 62, August 2003

Clare: I suppose a key ‘warning’ that I would always want to raise about creating new bisexual spaces is that we don’t insist bisexuality is different and then wonder where we lost the connection to a range of communities. Or that we don’t erase our complex bisexual histories in the process of wanting something new. This isn’t to say that bisexuality won’t ever translate into separate spaces in the way that lesbian and gay communities do currently,  but that even if that happens it’s important not to think of this as the only goal of bisexual community.

This brings me onto another point – part of the importance of bisexual history for me is that we find ways of doing this without simply reclaiming key figures as ours and not theirs (whoever the ‘they’ is). If, as I suggest  in the book, bisexual history is marked by its relationship to other histories and communities it becomes less important to establish a  particular person as belonging only and securely to one history or community. It just doesn’t resonate with bisexual experience.  Most of us do move among, within and between communities and gain a sense of self from that movement; yet we still expect the past to be less rather than more complicated!  Partly I think that’s to do with the ways bisexuals are accused of passing, and therefore want to show both that we don’t, and that we have  a history of not doing so – that’s important, but it’s also important not to  simply be reactive. In moving bisexually within the spaces of others, which, let’s not forget, are also our spaces, we continue a long tradition of resisting heterosexism  in a specifically bisexual way.