This week’s papers have got another bi science story. And like many before it, it looks rather threadbare.
“This is the fascinating reason women have evolved to become bisexual” says the Sun. “Female sexuality is ‘more fluid'” gasps the Daily Mail. Yup, there’s some bad sex research out.
The proponent, a Dr Satoshi Kanazawa who works at the London School of Economics, explains: “(My) theory suggests that women may not have sexual orientations in the same sense as men do. Rather than being straight or gay, to whom women are sexually attracted may depend largely on the particular partner, their reproductive status, and other circumstances.”
Well that’s my silly girly head told. I thought I had a sexual orientation, but I have a foolish womanly “neither gay nor straight” sexuality. He’s right on the “other circumstances” bit though. Who I’m attracted to depends largely on the “other circumstances” of whether I fancy them.
Satoshi opines that the “most objective and accurate measures of sexual orientation” are the “let’s wire up a sensor to your genitals” model – the one which was used in the 2005 report that claimed there was no such thing as a bisexual man, despite several research subjects meeting its peculiar criteria for being a man and bisexual. That was, as I recall it, a report whose poor research and analysis methods later led to an awkward retraction.
The theory being presented starts from previous USA research that suggests women are more likely to be – well, not bisexual, as using that term properly involves far too much of a grasp of human sexuality for this report which is keen to avoid the notion – to be more “sexually fluid” than men.
Why is that? Evolution! Women who lived as part of a polygamous family structure with one man and several women naturally became more open to finding pleasure other than from sex with their husband, to pass the time and improve bonding within the family. Somehow that made them more fertile, so over time women evolved to be more able to find sexual pleasure regardless of the gender of their partner. Natural selection of the orgasm-iest.
Now, I know what you’re thinking. “Bollocks.” Well, maybe you had a politer word. This upturn in fertility is supposed to happen despite a complete lack of biological or plain logical cause-and-effect, and the periods of human existence where such families have been dominant within local cultures are unlikely to be of evolutionary timeframe relevance. And having sex with your partner’s partner is – sadly for some – not a tried-and-tested way to make life easier all round. I’m told that in the modern world sometimes it can even cause a bit of a kerfuffle.
Are there not more likely factors in play, such as a huge cultural bias around sex and sexuality pressing people toward certain labels and understandings of themselves?
The supporting cast of evidence doesn’t help the case for the published hypothesis. It cites as proof of the impact of being around other women the phenomenon of synchronising menstrual cycles. It’s a popular idea in culture after an academic suggested it might be a real thing some 45 years ago; unfortunately ever since people have failed to find evidence for it. So we’re down to “this thing happens, just like that thing that doesn’t happen happens”.
All told it seems what we are dealing with is less a piece of research, more the kind of drunken ramble someone goes on in a bar after reading a newspaper article. Research shows more women than men have changed their chosen sexuality label over the last decade, in a society with widespread biphobia especially for men. There must, Kanazawa decides, be a reason for this. Here is an idea: perhaps it’s down to polygamy in the past. After all, other things have happened in the past that affect life today. There must be an explanation, this is an explanation, therefore this is the explanation. Or as South Park once put it: 1) Steal pants, 2) umm, 3) profit.
As Kanazawa says in that opening comment, it’s “my theory”. It’s not really got any kind of an evidence base. But it’s been published in a journal, it’s about sex and it gives tabloids an excuse to print a titillating photo of two girls kissing, so it is being reported uncritically and gives us yet another bi-erasing myth about human sexuality to have to unravel. Thanks ever so much for that, Biological Reviews.
