As the UK announces a review of blood donation policy, France and the Netherlands have both decided that their lifetime bans on men who have sex with men donating blood should be ended.
A similar move was made in Britain four years ago, though Northern Ireland retains a lifetime ban as policy on the matter is devolved to the Stormont Assembly. The USA followed suit in 2014.
Like the UK and the USA, the shift by the Netherlands government is not a complete repeal of the ban. Donations will only be taken from men who have not had sex with another man in the past 12 months – meaning the change will probably open up the chance of donation more to bi men than to gay men.
Also like the UK, though it is often reported as a ban on “gay blood donors”, the ban continues to limit donations by the female partners of bi (or behaviourally bi) men.
These “lifetime ban” rules were rushed in when HIV / AIDS first became known in the 1980s and we were still unsure how widespread and easily spread HIV would be.
France meanwhile is also moving on the ban, though with more nuance than the Netherlands.
Reform of the blood ban was part of President Hollande’s election platform. Social Affairs and Health Minister Marisol Touraine announced that as “giving blood is an act of generosity, of civic responsibility, the donor’s sexual orientation cannot be a condition. While respecting patient safety, today we are lifting a taboo.”
The change will not be a complete and immediate repeal of the ban. Initially donations will only be taken from men who have not had sex with another man in the past 12 months – meaning the change will probably open up the chance of donation more to bi men than gay men. The French plan involves this then rolling forward to reduce the 12 month limit, with a likely end point of donations being accepted from men who have only had sex with one other man in the previous four months.
Here in the UK, Jane Ellison MP, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Public Health, announced in November that blood donation policies would be reviewed, in response to a parliamentary question.
She told the House, “Donor deferral for men who have sex with men was changed from lifetime to 12 months in 2011, but four years later it is time to look again at the question. Public Health England has just undertaken an anonymous survey of donors and I am pleased that the Advisory Committee on the Safety of Blood, Tissues and Organs will review the issue in 2016.”
Around the world rates of blood donation have fallen in recent years, with the UK reporting a 40% drop in donor numbers in the past decade.
