Looking Queer: Body Image and Identity in Lesbian, Bisexual, Gay and Transgender Communities

Ed. Dawn Atkins (Harrington Park Press, 1998)

A collection of over 60 articles by LGBT people on the relationship between body image and sexual identity, the various forms of body fascism that exist in our cultures (e.g. men not being allowed into gay clubs because they were ‘too fat’ or ‘too old’), issues around disability, racism and gender conformity.

Articles range from the highly academic ‘Beauty Mandates and the Appearance Obsession: are Lesbians any Better Off?’ to very personal accounts of discrimination and self-hatred. Whilst Atkins herself identifies as bisexual, and there is a strong acknowledgement of bisexuality throughout the book, no distinctive bi perspective on body image is given. Instead the view that ‘women’s body image improves as they get less involved with men and more involved with women’ is offered, even though some of the contributors admit that lesbian communities can be just as narrow as heterosexual society in defining what is an attractive or acceptable appearance. ‘Famous bisexuals’ Naomi Tucker and Jill Nagle contribute interesting articles, along with an unusually revealing account from John Stoltenberg.

An important and fascinating part of the book are the contributions from intersexed people – contesting the practice of surgical ‘correction’ in infancy of people born with hermaphrodite or other unusual genitalia, despite the physical and psychological problems that such surgery can cause.

The book is also very good at exposing the ‘no pecs, no sex’ oppressiveness of much of US gay male culture, and its obsessive worship of ‘hung, buff boys’. Andrew Feraios in ‘If Only I Were Cute’ describes the dilemma of working hard to achieve this idealised gay image, only to find that men related to him just as a physical object to fuck and possess. It’s hardly surprising that lesbians were found to have a better self image after they accepted their sexuality, whilst gay men had a worse self image after they came out!

The main emphasis of the book is on fat acceptance, with the majority of the articles dealing with this. Only a few articles cover disability, and a significant omission is any contribution from people with a facial disfigurement, as this can have a severe impact on how we are perceived and on our social life.

An American bias is also very evident throughout – with two exceptions all authors are from the USA, and this leads to a rather parochial outlook, with little consideration of alternative attitudes to body image in other cultures. Whilst many issues and discriminations are exposed, there is a lack of in-depth analysis or proposed solutions.

Despite this, the book is a very interesting and valuable exploration of body image issues in the LGBT communities, and is certainly relevant to many bisexuals as well.

Kevin Lano