This month, we had more views than we had space for on the London Bi Women’s Group’s challenge to decide who to accept as a woman (see Letters on pages 8 and 9). Our next issue will cover the general subject of gender. This appears to be an emotive subject; please write to us and help us keep our coverage of the issues broad and up-to-date.
You don’t have to be from London or be bisexual to attend the London Bisexual Women’s Group. So why the recent vote to establish exactly who can call themselves a woman?
LBWG’s new home has no TS policy. Some wanted to continue the previous policy but mentioned their concerns only to the group’s de facto leaders. Others were surprised the issue had arisen again, despite the atmosphere of the group changing, resembling a witch-hunt with people asking ‘is that a transsexual?’ of any tall or older woman. A vote seemed the only way to improve this.
The motion and background information, mainly worded by one person, was inevitably controversial. Those who ‘preferred’ an open-door policy were allowed no say in any proposed restrictions. Several people ideally wanting an open-door policy would have agreed to a ‘living full-time’ policy in the interest of group unity, but not to ‘post-operative only’.
The results show no majority opinion and have spectacularly failed in reuniting the group, due to two opposing and irreconcilable views on a women’s group’s function: either a positive collection of women, or a ‘safe space’ from male influence.
Most concern was not to do with any previous attendee (and no-one has disputed the right of post-op TS women to attend), but that any man could pretend to be transsexual to enjoy the company of ‘hot bi babes’. Some had other worries, such as the group ‘being in danger of turning into a TS support group’, despite LBWG not being a support group of any kind. Why should discussion not include transsexuality when relevant, just as someone else might bring up other personal subjects such as childbirth that also don’t apply to many in the group?
The small group format of much LBWG discussion enables subjects to be tackled in depth, but enhanced feelings, as sub-groups are assumed to be representative of the whole group. One woman felt uncomfortable talking about abuse by men in a group containing people she ‘perceived to be men’. Perception is in the eye of the beholder. I suspect she would not have felt any better if others considered the same people women. If someone brings up distressing topics themselves, is the group responsible for their comfort levels? Another ‘didn’t want to have to worry about someone’s history.’ Why is this only relevant to pre-op transsexuals? If referring to abuse, it assumes all women are nonabusive, which is patronising as well as inaccurate.
Will the new policy allay the group’s fears? It will have to be enforced by trust – if someone has female ID and claims to be a post-op transsexual, her word will have to be accepted, strip searches being presumably impractical. As pre-op transsexuals are no longer to be allowed the benefit of the doubt, one wonders if the group will be able to trust those who say they are post-op without such a measure. Should all members remember to bring suitable ID?
The LBWG was stagnating and recently discussed improvements, concluding unanimously that diversifying the membership would be good. Can this happen or will other minority groups be seen as ‘spoiling the group dynamic’? I find it sad that newcomers, often learning for the first time about transsexuals, are being taught caution of such people. I hope all transsexuals haven’t been judged by the person ‘believed to be transsexual’ who provoked the behaviour policy.
Until recently, I found LBWG a fun, friendly and supportive group of women. I hope it can revitalize and return to being a welcoming and thriving group, or the London bi community will be much poorer for it.
HT
