A government minister floundered at the dispatch box this afternoon defending a legal change that will make many bi people – cis and trans alike – and their straight, gay and ace friends less safe in public. 

Yet despite her having to fall back repeatedly passing the buck to the discredited Equality & Human Rights Commission, due to Labour’s huge majority in the Commons the law looks set to be enacted in a few weeks’ time.

Seema Malhotra, currently a junior Minister for Equalities in the beleaguered Starmer government, had been pressed to make a statement on the latest draft Equality Act 2010 “code of practice for services, public functions and associations” from the EHRC. This intentionally misinterprets the “For Women Scotland Ltd v. The Scottish Ministers” judgement handed down just over a year ago on 16 April 2025, and breaks many other UK laws in the process.

It will become law unless a vote is forced in the Commons and the House rejects it. This is the same process that let Labour government’s 1999 measure to roll back trans equality in the workplace following a more positive court ruling pass into law without a vote.

Spoiler alert: this article will once more not involve the government allowing a vote.

The Supreme Court ruling made clear that it should only be considered as relevant to a minor part of Scottish governance regarding the makeup of committees, but has been steamrollered into wider application with a pretence that it applied to all interpretations of the Equality Act 2010. Thus flows an at-best dubious argument that trans women and trans men must no longer be allowed to use whichsoever public toilets and changing rooms as are safest physically and mentally for all involved, but instead be forced to use those related to the sex they were arbitrarily assigned at birth.

This only works in an imaginary world where there are two discrete sexes and every human falls into precisely one or the other, but Labour and the Conservatives are now both overwhelmingly wedded to that pretence.

From that flow a series of other decisions which had to have been made long before the EHRC received the court judgement. As we noted last year their response came far too quickly to have been thought through after its publication.

The proposals seek to expunge trans and other gender non-conforming people including many bi cis people from work, community groups and wider society.

After the minister had briefly spoken to open the debate her opposite number Mims Davies (Conservative) offered a selection of her own delusions about the world, after which Seema laughably responded that “We are focused on the practical—treating everyone with compassion, dignity and respect—and we should never fan the flames or seek to grab headlines.”

We are absolutely convinced of the veracity of all of that, as a career politician and MP she has never sought to grab headlines.

Soon Rebecca Paul (Conservative) angrily declared that the business of MPs and the House of Commons was to respect the law as handed down from the courts. We’re not sure that’s what being an MP is supposed to be about, it sounds more like the role of a police constable than that of a highly paid legislator.

Nadia Whittome (Labour) pointed out that among the absurdities of the current proposals was that “a charity that wants to put on a women’s coffee morning that is open to the public cannot, according to the guidance, be trans inclusive without being open to the whole public.”

Tom Gordon (Lib Dem) reflected how far the Conservatives had sunk since 2010s leader Theresa May had said: “when it comes to rights and protections for trans people, there is still a long way to go.”

More strikingly he highlighted the corrupt nature of the EHRC that produced the proposals: “As a member of the Joint Committee on Human Rights, I attended the evidence session when we interviewed the new chair of the EHRC, and for the Minister to say that that was an independent process when the Government rammed it through despite cross-party consensus that the new chair was not fit for the role is, quite frankly, surprising.” Seema told him that, “It is important to note that access to a toilet should be very clear, and to recognise the Supreme Court ruling in relation to toilets,” which seems to be misleading the House given the Supreme Court ruling quite specifically didn’t involve toilets. In 88 pages the word does not appear a single time.

Christine Jardine (Lib Dem) challenged the minister that while she had claimed the government was here to uphold and protect, not weaken, the 2010 Equality Act, “She will look very hard before she finds a member of the LGBTQ community in this country who believes that.”

Charlie Dewhirst (Con) whined that the NHS was still treating patients, often with respect and dignity, and made it plain that he found that distressing,

Cat Eccles (Lab) noted that “A number of LGBTQ+ charities and equality organisations have warned that the guidance risks legitimising exclusion and increasing harassment of both trans people and gender non-conforming cis people. A number of my constituents across Stourbridge have contacted me because they are deeply concerned by the proposed changes. Will the Minister confirm whether this House will have the opportunity to debate and to vote on the final code of practice before anything comes into force?” Seema noted there was a debate happening here while dodging the question of having prevented a vote taking place.

Pan MP Layla Moran (Lib Dem) asked “My question to the Minister is simple: what if she is wrong? What if her assurance that this decision will protect trans and non-binary rights does not come to pass and the situation gets worse? Is she open to working with others across this House to fix this issue, or is this a done deal?”  Seema sighed that “I am sure that the honourable Lady will continue to raise those concerns.” Which really isn’t an answer, but by this stage it was plain to all that Seema isn’t capable of answers.

Alex Sobel (Lab) noted that “When read together, paragraphs 2.5 and 2.92 of the code imply that a transgender person and a cisgender person who are in a relationship can no longer enjoy the rights that they have enjoyed since the introduction of the Act—for instance, in terms of their relationship being respected, registered and recognised by the law.” Seema said he’d have to ask the EHRC as she was not intellectually able to handle questions about the tearing-up of longstanding marriage and civil partnership law her government is intent upon to placate Big Social Media and the theist-fundamentalist lobby.

Josh Barbarinde (Lib Dem) had a snappy line: “this code of practice, which is unworkable for all, immoral for all and undermines equality for all” he noted. He then asked, given the government was claiming the measure would enhance the privacy, dignity and safety of cis women, how that was reconcilable with the same government’s equality impact assessment observation that “Women who are considered masculine may face greater scrutiny about their sex as a result of the changes. This will likely have a negative impact on this group.”

The discussion ran on, with various Labour, Conservative and TUV members supporting the measure, more Lib Dem and a few more Labour members opposing it, Plaid fence-sitting and Reform and the Greens silent.

Until, without a vote because the government is scared of one, the debate ended.