Yesterday, Friday 7th November, a private session of the United States Supreme Court considered whether to hear a case that seeks to overturn the US’ same-sex marriage laws.
The results remain secret for now but an announcement may be made as soon as tomorrow, Monday 10th November.
It might seem a bold move to repeal – around seven in ten Americans support same-sex marriage. It has been in place in the country for a decade and the sky has not fallen in despite the many warnings made by the anti- lobby at the time it became law.
The case is being brought under the pretence of defending religious freedom, by privileging one particular strand of a particular faith over all the others practiced in a country of 330 million people. Further, a country that still pretends to follow a constitution that codifies the separation of state and religion.
That freedom to follow other deities and interpretations of sacred texts (and to follow none) might be plainly secure with a different court, but the US Supreme Court is a deeply partisan construction.
The court is made up of nine Justices, who after a careful programme of packing the court by the Republicans over the past ten years is now widely seen as skewed 6 reactionary to 3 progressive.
In June 2022 it was that lineup of judges who struck down Roe v Wade, a 1973 ruling that had made access to abortion lawful across all 50 states. Empowered by that decision the three and a half years since have seen rollbacks of access to abortion and new laws criminalising both those seeking and those providing care. Some states were already primed to outlaw abortion the moment the ruling came out.
While a lower court has found against the case – as the staffer at the Rowan County Clerk’s office who was refusing to register any marriages now that same-sex couples were allowed to marry may have religious freedom in their private life but when acting as a government agent is employed to follow the law. The 6th circuit court declared that “The Bill of Rights would serve little purpose if it could be freely ignored whenever an official’s conscience so dictates.”
An open and shut case you might think. Next week might throw some clarity on that.
