Press reports this week have proclaimed a fall in the numbers of young people identifying as bi, trans and nonbinary in the US.
Once you scratch the surface though, the claims from the “Centre for Heterodox Social Science” ring as hollow as its contrarian name.
The report looks at figures from carefully chosen institutions and contrasts those figures with nationwide statistics from previous years and reputable sources.
While individual research projects will find different statistics due to variations like question wording and situation in which respondents answer, it’s an outlier compared to large sample research from reputable sources.
The social climate in the US at present is likely depressing the numbers reporting LGBT+ identities for fear of personal safety compared to just a short time ago, as it did for many years previously.
If you make respondents scared to honestly disclose, your work has dishonest findings – or in the old computing cliche: “garbage in, garbage out”.
Much like the “gay, straight or lying” claims made 20 years ago in the New York Times, it’s a case of a discredited author editing their results to fit a headline chosen before the research began.
