The latest Scottish Government Workforce Diversity and Inclusion report reveals how working in the Civil Service is different for bi, straight and gay people.
It has been misleadingly reported elsewhere to suggest that bisexual, lesbian and gay staff are being given preferential treatment in employment and promotion.
The report is an annual exploration of the diversity of Scottish Government permanent staff in core directorates, some agencies and some non-ministerial departments – what people generally refer to as civil servants.
They say that “Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual or any other sexual orientation not including straight/heterosexual staff make up 10.0% of the Scottish Government workforce, compared to 5.2% of the Scottish population aged 16 to 64.”
They also observe of this over-representation that it is marked “among staff working at lower pay bands. This high representation is likely to continue, due to the high representation of LGB+ staff among new staff joining the Scottish Government and the high representation of LGB+ applicants to work for the Scottish Government.”
New staff are more likely to be young where the proportion of the population identifying as gay or especially as bisexual is much higher than that 5.2% figure would suggest. This is also the likely reason why “LGB+ staff are more likely to have been promoted in the last year than heterosexual staff.” Sadly many of these findings do not separate out bi from gay / lesbian experience.
They also note that ” In 2023, gay and lesbian staff felt as engaged and included as heterosexual staff and experienced similar levels of bullying & harassment, while bisexual staff felt less included and experienced higher levels of discrimination and bullying & harassment than heterosexual staff.”
In the past other reports have suggested that bi people feel less able to be open about their sexual orientation safely in the workplace, and there is less of a beneficial effect from things like LGBT staff networks on bi staff than on gay and lesbian staff. This looks to reflect those findings once again.
Finally it’s worth noting the 10.0% of staff being LGB versus 5.2% of the population contrast may not be as accurate as you would think. People give different answers to questions about their sexual orientation dependent on how, when and where the question is asked.
