A bisexual man who was convicted of rape cannot be deported to his country of origin, a UK court has ruled.
The man who had non-consensual sex with a sleeping woman is originally from Jamaica, and would normally face deportation having completed his sentence.
However as he is bi, and given the high risks for openly LGBT people in Jamaica, the Upper Tribunal Immigration & Asylum Chamber ruled he could not be sent home.
The man, who in legal reporting is simply known as “AA”, was imprisoned for seven years from 2018 for forcing himself sexually on a woman who was asleep at the time. In his defence at the time he pleaded that he was acting under the effects of alcohol and cannabis, which the court rightly did not consider an acceptable excuse.
He came to the UK in 2001, fleeing his homeland after getting into a relationship with an older man when he was 13 years old, which was discovered leading to a series of assaults where he was attacked variously using a machete, a metal bar and a dog. His case for remaining on the UK in part depended on this history and what would be likely to happen to him if he returned.
The Home Office, presenting the case for him to be deported, argue he is a danger to the community if he remains in the UK. The court ruled that despite this he could not be sent to a country that would be a danger to him. Ironically the reason he cannot be sent back to his homeland from the UK lies in its past as a UK colony – Jamaica’s homophobic laws and culture date to 1864 and the Offences Against the Persons Act passed there by their British rulers.
It is a hard outcome to feel good about. However if as a country we believe in a system of crime and punishment and rehabilitation, at some point most prisoners need to be freed. And having served a sentence a court felt appropriate for his actions, it would be immoral to now knowingly send him to a country where he is likely to face violence if not death. Doubly so given that, were he heterosexual, going there would pose no such danger.
