Defending access to queer books

The American Library Association (ALA) has released its annual list of the Top 10 Most Challenged Books for 2023 and the State of America’s Libraries Report. This reports how library staff have acted to address community needs with innovative services, as well as the challenges brought on by censorship attempts.

The number of titles targeted for censorship rose 65 percent in 2023 compared to 2022, reaching the highest levels ever documented by ALA.

“In looking at the titles of the most challenged books from last year, it’s obvious that the pressure groups are targeting books about LGBTQIA+ people and people of colour,” said ALA President Emily Drabinski. “Shining a light on the harmful workings of these pressure groups is one of the actions we must take to protect our right to read.”

The censorship efforts led to Unite Against Book Bans creatoing their Book Résumé resource. These résumés support librarians, educators, parents, students, and other community advocates when they defend books from censorship. Created in collaboration with the publishing industry and library workers, each book résumé summarizes the book’s significance and educational value, including a synopsis, reviews from professional journals, awards, accolades and more. Where possible, the book résumés also include information about how a title has been successfully retained in school districts and libraries after a demand to censor the book.

“These are books that contain the ideas, the opinions, and the voices that censors want to silence – stories by and about LGBTQ+ persons and people of colour,” said ALA’s Office for Intellectual Freedom Director Deborah Caldwell-Stone. “Each challenge, each demand to censor these books is an attack on our freedom to read, our right to live the life we choose, and an attack on libraries as community institutions that reflect the rich diversity of our nation.”

10 Most Challenged Books 2023

1 Gender Queer by Maia Kobabe
LGBTQIA+ content, claimed to be sexually explicit

2 All Boys Aren’t Blue by George M. Johnson
LGBTQIA+ content, claimed to be sexually explicit

3 This Book is Gay by Juno Dawson
LGBTQIA+ content, sex education, claimed to be sexually explicit

4 The Perks of Being a Wallflower
by Stephen Chbosky
Claimed to be sexually explicit, LGBTQIA+ content, rape, drugs, profanity

5 Flamer by Mike Curato
LGBTQIA+ content, claimed to be sexually explicit

6 The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison
Rape, incest, claimed to be sexually explicit, EDI content

7 (TIE) Tricks by Ellen Hopkins
Claimed to be sexually explicit, drugs, rape, LGBTQIA+ content

7 (TIE) Me and Earl and the Dying Girl
by Jesse Andrews
Claimed to be sexually explicit, profanity

9 Let’s Talk About It by Erika Moen and
Matthew Nolan
Claimed to be sexually explicit, sex education, LGBTQIA+ content

10 Sold by Patricia McCormick
Claimed to be sexually explicit, rape

Delaware’s Pan Protection

The state of Delaware in the United States of America may amend its anti-discrimination laws to specifically include pansexual people. The move would also add asexuals to those identities formally recognised and given legal protection.

Unfortunately the move has involved transphobia and biphobia – and unusually, from those advocating for the change.

House Bill 275 updates the definition of “sexual orientation” throughout the Delaware Code by adding asexuality and pansexuality.

Representative Eric Morrison, who brought the legislation forward, explained pansexuality in committee through this example: “You may have someone who’s heterosexual, a heterosexual male, who of course is interested in women. However, they would not be or want to be with a trans woman. A pansexual individual is open to everyone. They would be willing to date … someone who is trans.”

That’s misleading: lots of people who are not pan would happily date a trans person. Many would also happily date a cis person, though not necessarily at the same time. Being trans-inclusive in dating is not unique to pansexual people, any more than dating short people is unique to heterosexuals or dating French people unique to gay men. To pretend otherwise is to both pretend that bisexuality is not and never trans inclusive, and that trans men and women are not men and women but somehow ‘other’.

That said, there may be value in having trans-inclusive experiences of attraction formally codified in state law, for when a cisgender person experiences harrassment or discrimination on the basis of their trans partner.

The bill would record in state law definitions: “Pansexuality refers to individuals who are attracted sexually or romantically, or both, to another individual regardless of that individual’s sex or gender identity,” and “Asexuality refers to individuals with little to no sexual attraction to other individuals, although asexual individuals may desire emotionally intimate relationships with other individuals.”

The bill moves back to the House for further debate.

Modernising Methodists

The United Methodist Church has taken a step into the modern age. The church’s General Conference in the USA has voted to allow bi people (and other LGBTs) to be ordained into the clergy, which had been banned at the church’s 1984 conference.

The measures were passed by a huge margin without any futher debate, after forty years of arguing. It was backed by attendees by 692 votes to 51.

A neutral stance was agreed on same-sex weddings: none shall be obliged to conduct them, and no one shall face penalty for conducting them. Further a section 28 style bar on use of church funds in ways deemed to “promote homosexuality” was revoked.

Pre-pandemic figures note 5 million people in the USA are members of the UMC, and around 10 million worldwide. Those numbers have fallen slightly as the reactionary wing realised they were losing control of the organisation and left.

Back and Forth abroad

Thailand looks set to join the list of countries that have same-sex marriage. By the end of this year the Thai government expects it to become law.

A bill to legalise it, and bring forward adoption rights for same-sex couples, has passed the lower house of parliament there by 400 votes to 15. This followed a set of debates in December.

That is a fairly unassailable majority, but the measure still needs to pass the Senate and be signed into law by King Rama X. It would join Nepal and Taiwan as the third country in Asia to legalise same-sex marriage. It could be the 38th country to recognise same-sex marriage nationwide, depending how quickly those remaining stages pass.

Meanwhile Iraq moved the other way criminalising same-sex activity and advocacy for LGBT people, along with outlawing less usual ‘sexual morality policing’ things like wife-swapping.

Grindring into court

Dating app Grindr is set to find itself in court over claims it leaked private data about users.
The best-known queer dating app, Grindr is mainly used by bi and gay men, with a focus on hookups over relationships.
The legal action is being brought by class action specialist law firm Austen Hays. They claim the app misused “private information of thousands of affected UK Grindr users, including highly sensitive information about their HIV status and latest tested date”.
Without users opting into that happening the case alleges this would be a breach of UK data protection laws for sharing sensitive data to third parties for commercial purposes.
The data sharing is supposed to have happened in and before 2020.
Last September Norwegian Data Protection Authority won a case that Grindr had broken GDPR rules in that country, and the year before the UK Information Commissioner’s Office ruled that Grindr had infringed GDPR laws – issuing a reprimand rather than a fine.
Some 670 people are taking part in the class action, with thousands more potentially affected.

Poll: Tell Kids

A new YouGov survey asked people about plans to ban relationship education for children under 12.
While campaigns against trans people’s civil rights have had some impact, the public are unimpressed with at least two people supporting inclusive education for every one against. 60% support age-appropriate education about the existence of trans and non-binary people while 30% are against.
On the existence of bi and gay people – that becomes some 78% for and 15% against, roughly a five to one margin.

Random Access

Our online archive of BCN back numbers is complete!
Over the past couple of years we have been filling in the gaps in the online collection of Bi Community News articles going right back to the start in 1995. Some of those have required OCRing or retyping from scratch as the original digital files have been lost.
Last to be added were issues 44 and 45, from the summer of the year 2000. Back then the news included an upcoming International Conference on Bisexuality (remember them?) in Manchester, while down south London’s main Pride festival was newly going by the name Mardi Gras.
They were the final two missing issues, though a few bits off issue 50 had also gone astray – now uploaded.
Thanks to our archive volunteers!

Sex Ed Cancelled?

Children in England under 10 may no longer get age-appropriate information about relationships in schools in a reversal of the curriculum introduced just before the pandemic.
The announcement came shortly before Rishi Sunak called a snap general election though – so quite what happens on that (as so many things) is more likely a matter of what happens on July 4th. In an echo of 1997, Labour are not pushing back on these things with a focus on winning power.
Due to devolution, relationship education in Scotland and Wales are not affected.