Same findings | Different perspective
New research from the USA suggests bi women die younger than lesbians, and lesbians die younger than heterosexual women.
It’s released by the JAMA research journal, in a paper entitled Disparities in Mortality by Sexual Orientation in a Large, Prospective Cohort of Female Nurses, authored by McKetta, Hoatson, Hughes et al.
The paper looks at women working in nursing – but it would seem likely the outcomes are similar for women across the wider population. The researchers found that bisexual and lesbian participants in the Nurses’ Health Study II died an estimated 37% and 20% sooner, respectively, than heterosexual participants.
Following some 90,833 women working in nursing in the USA, they find that there is an appreciable difference in the proportion of straight, bi and lesbian women who died in the monitoring period, and it is to some degree statistically significant.
Participants were female nurses born between 1945 and 1964, initially recruited in the US in 1989 for the Nurses’ Health Study II, and followed up from 1995 to 2022.
They find that “Of the 4,227 deaths reported, the majority were among heterosexual participants (n = 4146; cumulative mortality of 4.6%), followed by lesbian participants (n = 49; cumulative mortality of 7.0%) and bisexual participants (n = 32; cumulative mortality of 10.1%).”
Reflecting the generation from which the sample is taken, 89 821 (98.9%) identified as heterosexual, 694 (0.8%) identified as lesbian, and 318 (0.4%) identified as bisexual. An equivalent sample of nurses recruited today would likely have a far larger proportion identifying as bi.
This reflects other existing research from the US and elsewhere showing that bi and lesbian women are both more likely to do things like drinking and smoking more than their straight peers.
Where those findings suggest bi women have the health experiences that are likely to lead to shorter lives, such as more tobacco, drug and alcohol use. This new report shows the same problem from the other perspective – that the outcome you would expect from those things has been happening and bi women are indeed dying younger.
Depressing, but seemingly consistent.
Continental QUILTBAG
The European Union’s Fundamental Rights Agency has published the findings of a huge survey across the 27 member nations. This follows on from similar reports in 2013 and 2019.
‘LGBTIQ equality at a crossroads: progress and challenges’ explores the experiences, views and challenges LGBTIQ people face in Europe. It also highlights the changes since FRA’s previous surveys and lets you look at the results by country along the way, though sadly without the interactive visual tool they piloted in 2013.
The findings reveal signs of slow progress. While discrimination against LGBTIQ people remains high, it is gradually declining. Overall, schools deal with LGBTIQ issues more positively and proactively, and young people feel more supported by their teachers and peers. Nevertheless, bullying, harassment and violence have reached high levels.
See fra.europa.eu/en/publication/2024/lgbtiq-crossroads-progress-and-challenges
Mapping It
The 16th annual Rainbow Map, which ranks 49 European countries on legislative developments in the arena of LGBTI human rights, has been published by ILGA Europe.
It shows that while authoritarian leaders across Europe continue to use the scapegoating of LGBTI people to divide and mobilise their electorates, others are showing robust political will to honour commitments to advancing and protecting the human rights of LGBTI people.
At a time when some Italian regions are withdrawing parenthood rights from same-sex couples, when efforts are being made to rewrite guidelines to limit access to trans-specific healthcare in Slovakia, Croatia, France and the UK, and when we are witnessing Russia’s unprecedented move of criminalising the ‘international LGBTI movement’ as an ‘extremist organisation’, the findings of this year’s Rainbow Map make it more clear than ever that legal protections can be taken away as quickly as they are won.
From 2010 to 2015 the UK topped the table, but since then has slid slowly down the charts. Last year we placed 17th and the in 2022 we ranked 14th.
This year the UK ranks 16th – one place up from last year – but the UK’s score fell and it only improved its placing due to other countries also becoming more unsafe for LGBTI people. The country’s performance on hate crime and hate speech, as well as gender recognition and anti-discrimination drag our score down. The Westminster government has famously been promising a ban on conversion therapy since Theresa May was Prime Minister without any sign of it being delivered.
For the ninth year in a row, Malta takes the number one spot on the Rainbow Map, with a score of 88%. Iceland jumped to second place with a rise of three places as a result of the new legislation banning conversion practices and ensuring the trans-specific healthcare is based on depathologisation. Belgium also banned conversion practices and now takes third place.
