The Australian government has U-turned twice on putting sexuality in the next census this week.

Labor party prime minister Anthony Albanese on Friday said the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) would proceed with testing a new question on sexual orientation for the country’s 2026 census. This after his deputy, Richard Marles, said that it was best not to ask to avoid a divisive debate.

This after a week where such a plan was on, then off, then back on again.

But there is push-back from LGBT+ groups over the apparent “compromise” decision to only ask about sexuality, not gender.

“We welcome the inclusion of a sexual orientation question but the national snapshot of our nation must include all of us, not just some of us,” said Equality Australia CEO Anna Brown. “Trans and gender diverse people and those with innate variations of sex characteristics deserve to be recognised as much as anyone else.”

The UK included some questions for the first time in the 2021 census, and similar steps have been taken in Canada and New Zealand.

The information gleaned can be a mixed blessing: the full census tends to be seen as a more robust data source than surveys, but depending on how a question is asked and who answers it the resulting figures for things like sexuality can vary. A single form filled in by a ‘head of household’ might not reflect the sexual orientation of family members whose sexuality is not known of, or approved of, by that individual – likely thus under-representing the number of LGB people in the country. Where the survey is conducted face-to-face some respondents may not feel safe answering the question to that person or in earshot of people they share their home with.

Having spent some time devising and testing its planned sexuality questions, the Bureau now has two years to work out how best to  get disgruntled LGBT people to fill it in at all.