The US’ Department of Defense faces a legal challenge over the stigma it put on discharged servicepeople through the wording of discharge notices.

Magistrate Judge Joseph Spero in an initial ruling dismissed a bid by the DOD to prevent the case being heard. This means a case will go to court for a proper hearing – where the practice of recording sexuality on the discharge papers of those expelled from the US forces will face overdue scrutiny.

Veterans affected argue it is unnecessary and acts as a barrier to employment in other walks of life. Further, it reveals private-life details of those discharged in every situation where they need to prove their military record of service.

The DOD tried to claim that there was no ‘discriminatory intent’ involved, even if it did impact the lives of thousands affected. Spero dismissed this.

The Department of Defense (US spelling) is being challenged over more than 35,000 military veterans who were dismissed from their jobs due to homophobia and biphobia on the part of the US armed forces and successive governments.

This tally includes people expelled for ‘homosexual’ conduct from 1980 to 1993 and others similarly discharged in the years until 2011 when President Clinton’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” messy compromise rule was in place.

If the case is won, the 35,081 veterans should face a less uphill battle to have their discharge papers amended – with sexuality remarks removed and, where appropriate, “dishonourable” replaced with “honourable”.

In a statement the plaintiffs observe:

“We are very pleased that the Court recognized the merits of this case by denying the Department of Defense’s motion to dismiss. This ruling allows us to move forward in rectifying the discriminatory effects of the Department of Defense’s policies, ensuring that LGBTQ+ veterans receive the honor they rightfully deserve, having served our country with dignity and integrity.

Over 35,000 service members were kicked out of the U.S. military based on sexual orientation and issued paperwork that explicitly called out their actual or perceived sexual orientation. Nearly 30,000 were denied honorable discharges, resulting in decades of discrimination—even after Don’t Ask Don’t Tell (DADT) was repealed in 2011. These veterans have been forced to carry official yet discriminatory paperwork from the U.S. government that unnecessarily indicates their sexual orientation anytime they try to prove their status as veterans.