Ireland to overturn historic crimes too?
A few years ago the UK legislated to overturn the criminal records of people – overwhelmingly men – who were convicted of crimes that would have not been deemed crimes were they heterosexual and doing something equivalent. It has extended to the return of medals taken away from servicepeople who were discovered to be bi or gay prior to the repeal of the ban on queer people serving in the armed forces.
Now it looks like Ireland is going to follow suit.
The Irish Independent newspaper reports that justice minister Helen McEntee has received an outline report on overturning similar crimes prosecuted in the Republic when discriminatory laws were in place.
It suggested that as well as a formal erasure of the criminal record and apology from the state, there should be financial compensation in cases where the conviction led to someone losing their job unjustly. As in the UK, individuals – or people acting on their behalf where the convicted person has since died – would need to apply for their conviction to be struck from the record, rather than a broad ranging purge of all criminal records trying to find the ones where a homophobic law might have applied.
Singapore: Change of Heart
Singapore looks set to end its criminalisation of sex between men.
The law in question is not actively enforced, but six months ago a court case argued that it breached the country’s constitution.
The law states that, “377A. Any male person who, in public or private, commits, or abets the commission of, or procures or attempts to procure the commission by any male person of, any act of gross indecency with another male person, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to 2 years.”
The court ruling refused to repeal the clause, but argued this was a task for primary legislation rather than the courts: “Politics seems the more obvious choice than litigation for debating and resolving highly contentious societal issues.”
Now Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong has announced a plan to repeal 377A. There is not yet a timetable but government backing at the highest level for repeal seems likely to be able to drive change.
While similar homophobic laws have been in retreat across the Americas and Europe – albeit with that tide turning recently in the UK and US, countries across Asia have seen less movement from historic criminalisation.
American Bi Loophole
A court case in the USA looks set to exploit a loophole in equality law that we reported on in BCN past.
Where the UK legislated employment equality in the US it was won in the courts. In 2020 the Supreme Court ruled that workplace discrimination on the grounds that someone is gay or trans was illegal, on account of the employer would not treat them in the same way if they had been assigned another gender at birth. Thus men fired for being gay would have kept their jobs if they were born female and were in or seeking relationships with men – so it’s sex discrimination.
A test case in Austin, Texas argues that the same sex discrimination cannot apply when an employee is bisexual. For example if they were born female rather than male, then an employer that wanted not to employ bisexuals would still have the same issue with their sexual orientation.
The case, brought on behalf of an employer and the Bear Creek Bible Church will move to the Federal Appeals Court without a date having yet been set.
Footie Biphobia Lands a Fine
A Tower Hamlets FC football player has wound up in court for biphobic hate. Sheppey United player Jahmal Howlett-Mundle came out last summer, to solid support from his team-mates.
However on the pitch Tower Hamlets’ Ayokunie Odedoyin tackled Jahmal while letting rip a torrent of queerphobic abuse – perhaps frustrated at how much better a team with an openly bi player were doing than his own squad. Hamlets were hammered four-one.
That wound up in court in June. Odedoyin found himself in court for sentencing and down £1120 and 120 hours community work. Jahmal commented to the BBC, “With short sentences like this how are people supposed to understand that there’s a lot of pain and suffering that does happen to people like myself and other active LGBTQ+ football players.” Tower Hamlets’s social media sadly was silent.
Glas’d To Be Bi
Glasgow’s LGBT pride event, Mardi Gla, set a new first for a pride in the UK by focusing its parade on the message “Bi is Beautiful”.
Many prides give their parades themes each year, from political issues like trans inclusion or asylum rights to less obvious things like schooldays.
Kicking things off, bi speakers included Scottish government minister Patrick Harvie.
It’s not the first bi focused march – at the least there have been some for Bi Visibility Days over the years, but this is the first time a broad LGBT Pride event has prioritised the B.
Canadian Blood
Canada is switching to a risk-based rather than orientation-based set of rules on blood donation.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced, “When we were elected, we promised to end the blood ban across the country for men who have sex with men. And in the year since, we funded research projects to back that decision up with science.
“This past spring, Health Canada authorized Canadian Blood Services to lift the ban – and instead screen donors based on sexual behaviour, regardless of gender identity or sexual orientation. Yesterday, Health Canada also approved Héma-Québec’s request to eliminate the current three-month deferral period for donors in Quebec. They’ll adopt the same approach to screening as Canadian Blood Services.
“This is another step in the right direction. And the fact that all Canadians will soon be able to donate blood safely, without discrimination, is good news for everyone.”
The move mirrors changes in the UK since the ending of the total ban on blood donation by men who have sex with men (and their female partners) here ten years ago.
Monkeypox “slowing” in the UK
The spread of monkeypox is slowing down in the UK according to health officials.
Nonetheless our advice from earlier in 2022 about monkeypox risk minimisation still applies.
As at 27 September 2022, there are 3,485 confirmed and 150 highly probable monkeypox cases in the UK: 3,635 in total. Of these, 3,461 are in England.
This means while it is still spreading and a serious health hazard, the rate of spread is dropping. This may be due to the immunisation programme taking place.
Between 2018 and 2021, there had been just 7 cases in the UK. Some 98.8% of new infections are in men.
Civil Partnerships Resurgent
Mixed-sex civil partnerships have proven surprisingly popular now they are open to more couples.
In 2020, there were 7,566 opposite-sex civil partnerships formed in England and Wales, of which 7,208 were registered in England and 358 in Wales. This is the first year that civil partnerships between opposite-sex couples have been an option, following a long legal battle, with a few formed on 31 December 2019 on the first day they were permitted..
There were 745 civil partnerships formed between same-sex couples in England in 2020, the lowest number recorded for England since the introduction of civil partnerships in 2005. Wales had just 40.
There were 994 same-sex civil partnerships formed in England and Wales in 2019 in comparison; this number is declining year on year.
First Timers
Three-quarters (73%) of same-sex civil partnerships formed in England and Wales in 2020 were to couples where both partners had never been in a marriage or civil partnership before. For mixed-sex partnerships, this was just over half (52%) – but then marriage has been an option for mixed-sex couples for very much longer, as well as those relationships having greater social acceptance and mathematical chance of happening.
With so many taken up by people previously not in a recognised partnership it seems likely civil partnerships are proving popular with people who always avoided marriage because of some of the values that it has traditionally held, either religious connotations or the notion of a wife being owned by her husband. Some may be being taken up by people who have found love after the death of a married partner and who do not want to detract from the importance of that marriage in their life.
The median age at civil partnership for opposite-sex couples was 58.9 years for men and 56.3 years for women; for same-sex couples, the average ages at civil partnership were lower (49.8 years and 50.1 years respectively).
Will America make equal marriage law?
The US government is wrestling with the question of whether to legislate for same-sex marriage – and if so when. For a country where same-sex marriages have been taking place nationwide for seven years that sounds strange.
Same-sex marriage was legalised through the courts, finding the basic constitutional requirement to treat people equally regardless of sex meant you could not bar someone from marrying this man or that woman simply because they were male or female. The court case Obergefell v. Hodges concluded in June 2015 with that ruling, and at a stroke same-sex marriage was legal across all fifty member states.
Since the Republicans packed the Supreme Court thus unpicking the “Roe v Wade” abortion law, there is a threat to apply the same broken logic to same-sex marriage and even laws permitting sex between women or between men.
New federal legislation could help block efforts to overturn the legality of same-sex marriage. A “Respect for Marriage Act” needs at least ten Republican senators to give it their support to become law – as the Senate is tied 50-50.
The question is whether a vote is more likely to pass before or after November’s nationwide mid-term elections. We can but watch as the current Senate leadership gamble on millions of bi and gay people’s futures.
