The High Court has kicked out a bid to prevent the introduction of the new Relationships and Sex Education (RSE) curriculum in Wales.
The curriculum equips children with age-appropriate awareness of language and concepts around gender, sexual orientation, consent and bodily autonomy. That gives them both understanding of forming and sustaining healthy relationships as adults, and how to explain experiences of abuse and control by adults in their lives either at school or later in life. It also normalises the variety of home life situations other pupils may have – for example different numbers or genders of parents and guardians. For some pupils at every school that as has always been the case but historically often stigmatised and led to bullying.
It was brought forward by the previous (Labour-Lib Dem) coalition at the Senedd, and following the election in 2021 the new (Labour-Plaid Cymru) government has continued with the planned rollout, starting this school term.
Not everyone is happy with the idea of children being protected from bullying, nor them able to identify harmful behaviour and explain what has happened to them. Worse still perhaps to grow up able to express their own preferences and desires.
The plaintiffs protested that ten-year-olds being aware of the very existence of gay people would “irreparably damage” their young minds.
However the court rejected the case, and a last-minute additional bid seeking to allow parents whose prejudices or behaviours toward children would mean they felt threatened by such education to exclude their kids from those classes.
Three children were cited as for some reason needing to be kept away from the lessons, but the judge responded that “There is nothing in the claimants’ evidence that any of the three children to whom RSE will be taught in the 2022/23 academic year will suffer any harm, yet alone any irreparable harm.”
The judge noted that the new curriculum and guidance are “a consequence of the legislative decisions of the Welsh Parliament [and not something that] the court should interfere with”.
