A study from Michigan State University and Ohio State University compared the mental and physical health of bi and gay Americans to their straight counterparts.
Hui Liu, lead author, says that “Because younger lesbian, gay and bisexual generations have grown up in a more progressive era, we expected that they may experience lower levels of lifetime discrimination and thus have lower levels of health disadvantage than older LGB generations. However, our results showed the opposite to be true.”
Published in the Demography journal they look at psychological distress, depression, anxiety, self-rated physical health and activity limitation – breaking down figures by media generations of Baby Boomer, Generation X, Millennials and pre-Boomers. The data is taken from existing research: data from the US’s 2013–2018 National Health and Interview Surveys.
As with a lot of other recent research, the figures for bi people were worse.
For the Boomer generation, gay and lesbian people are 150% more likely to experience anxiety and depression than straight people their age. For bis it’s the same 150% on anxiety but 250% of the rate of depression.
For lesbian and gay Millennials, the anxiety mark-up is 200% and depression 250%. But for their bi peers those figures are 300% and 380%.
A fascinating result. Was growing up without expectation of things being OK, or of it “getting better”, somehow an insulating factor for older queers? Is it an impact of cyberbullying combined with the shiny (mis)representation of your life that social media encourages? Are older people just more pleasantly surprised to be living in a world that has the limited progress and liberation that has been achieved – or have they had more time to develop their own coping strategies for dealing with the world, and if so why are gay people doing better at that?
As the authors
note, “Sexual minority cohorts who came of age in the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s experienced lifelong discriminatory sociocultural events relative to those coming of age today, with likely strong implications for health.
They add, “Similarly, those who experienced the Stonewall riots of 1969, the HIV/AIDS crisis of the 1980s, and the subsequent gay liberation movement were likely affected by this social upheaval (and outright discrimination) in profound ways.”
There’s no reason to think that being bi or gay has become more common in recent generations, yet other US research shows much higher rates of bi and gay identification by generation. We might also wonder if the figures reflect that many older people are still too reticent to tick the bi or gay box on a survey, and that is skewing the results.
Note:
The adult generation groupings used in research like this are based on year of birth:
Generation Z (1997-2004)
Millennials (1980-1996)
Generation X (1965-1979)
Baby boomers (1946-1964)
