The Equality and Human Rights Commission has come under fire from LGBT and ally campaigners today following the release of two publications that fly in the face of its name and notional mission.

Chair of long-running bi support group BiPhoria Jen Yockney MBE commented:

In a single day, EHRC have advocated privileging transphobia and watering-down legislation against conversion therapy to the point that any ban will be in name only.

Some cisgender bi and gay people might imagine that attacks on trans people’s human rights stand separate from their own. That being cis will act like a shield of steel against a rise in hatred of anyone perceived as different across society.

That would be mistaken, just as much as when Section 28 only mentioning homosexuality did not prevent it harming young bisexual people or young trans people.

In practice any attack on trans people’s equalities will impact everyone else who is perceived as not “performing” their gender as averagely as possible. We have already seen how premeditated endorsement or incitement of transphobia from both government and sections of the media has fed an uptick in cis women facing harassment in public places when perceived as “too masculine”.

In its early days the EHRC was too timid to challenge the then-Labour government over its shambolic progress on equalities.

In the same way the current EHRC leadership prioritise keeping close to the Conservative government over and above the role they should be pursuing as an independent champion of equality and liberation.

An EHRC worthy of the name would be taking very different positions than those which uplift those who want to attack trans people, bisexual, lesbian and gay people, and cis women as part of a broad mission to drag our country back to the 1950s.

LGBT campaign group Stonewall commented:

Today’s statements from the EHRC are an attack on trans equality and undermine EHRC’s core purpose of regulating, promoting and upholding human rights.

The two statements – in response to plans to legislate for a ban on conversion therapy in England and Wales, and Gender Recognition Act reform in Scotland – effectively seek to exclude trans people from improved rights and protections.

They disregard findings from the UK Government’s own research and the largest ever survey of LGBTQ+ people in the UK, as well as the expert opinion of the UN Independent Expert on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity on conversion therapy and gender recognition.

In these statements the EHRC is calling for further delays to legislation that our communities have been waiting on for many years. In both cases the UK Government and Scottish Government have given ample opportunity for consultation.

Meanwhile the UK’s biggest LGBT health charity, LGBT Foundation, published a statement:

It is with sadness and deep regret that LGBT Foundation is severing all ties with the EHRC.

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) released two statements today about two pieces of LGBTQ+ rights legislation in the UK; the proposed conversion therapy legislation in England and Wales, and the proposed GRA reform in Scotland.

These statements are extremely damaging and cannot be supported in any circumstances.

EHRC has ignored the experiences of trans and non-binary individuals who have undergone unnecessary trauma. They suggest that LGBTQ+ lives are up for debate and medical scrutiny. They disregard expert opinion and lived experience – a humiliating and dehumanising action against our community with real-world consequences.

EHRC should exist to regulate, promote, and uphold human rights, and we believe it is no longer fit for purpose. Our position from today is clear: EHRC can no longer call itself a true human rights organisation.

We will write an open letter to the Government Minister for Equalities Mike Freer MP to share our disappointment at today’s events. We join other organisations and colleagues in demanding a review of the EHRC’s accreditation as an A-status National Human Rights Institution. We will make this letter public.

We stand with our peers that are rightly horrified by today’s events and reassure the LGBTQ+ community that we will continue to fight for equality and justice in the UK.

And the Ban Conversion Therapy Coalition looked to the international stage:

It should be noted that this recommendation by the EHRC would place England and Wales as international outliers removed from the international consensus of states seeking to protect LGBTQ+ people from conversion practices. During the 4 years of delays, additional research periods and extended consultations that have occurred since the UK Government first promised to ban conversion practices, other countries and states such as France and Canada and Victoria State in Australia have moved ahead and outright banned conversion practices for sexual orientation and gender identity. No other comparable country, state, territory, region or city has passed a ban on conversion practices without including gender identity.