A Spanish court has overturned a ruling from earlier this year in a case that threatened bi people and those who come to realise their bisexuality during an existing marriage.

A prior court hearing had ruled that a man had to pay his ex-wife 1,000 euros (£850) per year compensation for her having been married to a bisexual man without being aware of it after she sued him for misleading her about his sexual orientation.
Nearly a decade after their separation, she went to court claiming he had used her as a “refuge” to hide socially from the biphobia and homophobia that might have stigmatised his life and career otherwise. This despite their breakup in 2009 having been an amicable separation at the time.

The lower court’s decision, now overruled, has echoes of the equally unjust rulings in the UK where people who are trans have been prosecuted for not disclosing their gender history to a partner – despite those partners not having to actively come out as cis equivalently. In both situations the principle of being equal before the law has not applied – though only in Spain has it been overturned.

Thankfully Valencia’s Provincial Court overturned the fine, declaring it to have been discriminatory and also finding that defendants should not be required to declare their sexual orientation in court. Javier Vilalta had been obliged to disclose his sexual history including sex and relationships with women prior to his marriage.

Remarkably the ex-wife still cannot be named, while the ex-husband can, in a ruling which subtly endorses biphobia and stigmatises bisexuality.