The Queen’s Speech brought a double disappointment for bi people watching.
The vaunted “conversion therapy ban” will not be the legislation we have been expecting for more than 1,000 days, but a consultation on what the legislation should say. That kicks this initiative into the long grass yet again, delaying action and suggesting that the final bill will be far from comprehensive, using the consulation as an excuse to give dispensation to those who want to continue in their legalised bigotry and bullying.
Further the programme of legislation for the coming year announced the introduction of a requirement for photo ID in order to vote in UK elections. It is suggested that this will be issued free, though there is widespread assumption that the tight budgetary constraints post-pandemic will make it unlikely to be free in practice.
Identity documents like driving licences or passports will be required and it is being challenged as a tool of voter suppression for social groups less likely to vote for the Conservative Party, who are bringing the legislation forward.
People from poorer backgrounds are less likely to have these, and previous research has shown that the well known ‘gender pay gap’ has a mirror in pay rates according to sexuality. Bi men and bi women both earn less than their gay and straight peers, so we are less likely to be able to afford the documentation in question.
Bi people also report higher rates of disability in much research – with some disabilities debarring a person from having a driving licence, or meaning it can be summarily confiscated upon diagnosis. Even if special voter ID cards are free, someone who has just had their driving licence withdrawn and is having to adjust to changed life circumstances is unlikely to see getting one as a priority – thus squeezing out their voice from the electoral process.
Much reporting has noted a similar impact from the new law on people from some ethnic minorities in the UK. Trans people regardless of race or sexuality will also be disproportionately affected due to the personal and economic costs of sorting out replacement identity papers when changing your name and / or gender.
It seems likely that as the ID requirement will lead to some kind of ID card for those who have neither passport nor driving licence to be able to vote, we are likely to see the restoration of the ID card system introduced under the last Labour government and abolished in 2010. That charged both for the card itself at around £80 and then further charges for every update to the associated details, with fines of over £1000 if you failed to update information promptly or if the state didn’t process the changes accurately and so got its records wrong.
