The government in Northern Ireland today debates ‘conversion therapy’.
+++ UPDATE: MOTION PASSED 59 VOTES TO 24 +++
A private members’ motion put forward by two MLAs from the Ulster Unionist Party has drawn support across most of the chamber in Stormont. It reads:
That this Assembly rejects the harmful practice widely referred to as conversion therapy; notes that the UK Government National LGBT Survey in 2018 reported that 2% of respondents had undergone conversion therapy with a further 5% having been offered it; acknowledges the damage this practice causes to the mental health of those who are subjected to it; further acknowledges that this practice has been widely rejected by medical professionals; declares that it is fundamentally wrong to view our LGBTQ community as requiring a fix or cure; and calls on the Minister for Communities to commit to bringing forward legislation before the end of the current Assembly mandate to ban conversion therapy in all its forms.
The peculiar punctuation style is down to the rules on such private bills, which must be a single sentence.
An amendment from the Democratic Unionist Party seeks to change it:
Leave out all after ‘professionals;’ and insert:
“recognises that legitimate religious activities such as preaching, prayer and pastoral support do not constitute conversion therapy, cannot be defined as such and must be protected; and calls on the Minister for Communities to consult widely on the way ahead, including relevant legislative options, to ban the practice of conversion therapy.”
Thus amending the motion to remove the section about how it is wrong to see LGBTQ people as needing to be “fixed” or “cured” as well as watering-down a call for legislation, replacing it with a woolly consultation.
Edited to add: some contributions to the debate.
Doug Beattie for the UUP opens with a comic take on the question in hand, and it’s early days but you suspect this will be the best bit of the debate. “I’m a straight man, I was born straight, there is no fix or cure for me,” he explains. He rejects the amendment calling on the DUP to withdraw it: “Nobody is tackling anybody’s faith, but if it is coercive, if it is controlling, then we have to stop it,” and offers thanks across party ranks to Alliance MLA Paula Bradshaw, who brought a public petition to the Assembly in March, calling for a ban.
SDLP member Mark Durkan: “It needs to be said empathically and categorically that sexual orientation is not a sin to be confessed.” His fellow SDLP member Cara Hunter adds that “Today’s debate is the symptom of a very sick part of our society that believes that our LGBT friends, family and colleagues need to be cured.”
Sinn Fein’s Sinéad Ennis refers to conversion therapy as “pseudo-malpractice” and that hundreds of constituents have called on her to support the ban. Write to your representatives, folks!
Presenting her wrecking amendment, Pam Cameron for the DUP concedes that no-one should be forced into having such therapy but that there is not a tightly worded definition of the practice means people who want to carry on doing it won’t know exactly how to weasel their way around the law – though of course she puts it differently. “Ambiguity, if translated into legislation, would criminalise legitimate activities or conversations,” she protests.
Alliance MLA Andrew Muir, who was the first out-gay Mayor in Northern Ireland before his election to Stormont, reflected on the amendment: “All this amendment does is harm, and the DUP need to recognise they’re on the wrong side of history in relation to this.” Muir, one of only two out LGBT MLAs, finishes that “This assembly mandate must end with a legislate ban on conversion therapy”. With elections due next May that could still see a ban here ahead of the mainland, where the Conservatives continue to drag their feet.
Inevitably one-man-band Jim Allister chipped in – what debate on which century Northern Ireland wants to be in would be complete without him – and explained that to him what was outrageous was that: “this bans conversion therapy in all its forms!” SDLP member Matthew O’Toole is caught by the TV cameras (and twitter) with his head in his hands listening to Jim.
As an issue, this splits the Unionist parties while the Nationalist and non-Sectarian parties are pretty much united in supporting a ban. Hence the UUP’s Mike Nesbitt spoke to address those watching who might be frustrated at the lack of unity among the Unionist parties on this issue. “Read the motion, read the amendment. Chalk and cheese, that’s why there isn’t and never can be unionist unity.”
Jim Wells who was elected for the DUP felt the need to tell the chamber that after 38 years of marriage he was still heterosexual. Honestly Jim, we didn’t doubt it. He went on to complain how unfair it was that campaigners for the bill gave the impression that the church might be hostile to gay people. This might be a little bit playground politics of us here but we’re not convinced it was the campaigners who started that impression going.
The tragedy that should be being addressed is how certain (and oh-so-certain) voices within faiths are so amplified that others feel they have to leave their religion because it will never accept who they are the way their god made them, but Jim doesn’t feel the need to talk about that.
After a break for lunch and financial questions, we had a few more contributions. With only 90 MLAs this was quite a significant proportion of Assembly members wanting to join in and many clearly did not get a chance.
Government minister and Sinn Fein MLA Deirdre Hargey responded formally to the motion, saying that her officials have started drafting legislation. If she can get it implemented in under 1,000 days from now she’ll be a faster mover on this than Boris Johnson and Theresa May – put a note in your diary for January 15, 2024.
For the DUP Robin Newton summated on his party’s wrecking amendment fairly incoherently: that he is against conversion therapy, but also against infringements on people’s freedom to advocate that bi, gay or trans people shouldn’t exist or should be barred from polite society. “There are some appalling stories of techniques that were used in conversion therapy and we don’t speak without compassion on the matter for those who suffered,” he says, yet given what else he has to say the words ring somewhat hollow. However his choice of language is an interesting sign of how far the centre ground of discussion on LGBT people’s human rights has shifted in Ireland in the past decade or so.
For the UUP John Stewart concluded the full debate rejected the amendment for its choice to excise the clause declaring it “fundamentally wrong to view our LGBTQ community as requiring a fix or cure”, and explained that “what we seek is a ban on harm being caused.” Jim Wells, who had spoken earlier, heckled and repeatedly tried to interrupt Stewart’s contribution and was politely but repeatedly rebuffed.
“Our LGBTQ people are not broken, are not sick, they don’t need a cure, they don’t need a fix. [those who have a problem with that] have a problem, it is not the LGBTQ people who have a problem.”
The amendment and then the motion were then put to a vote.
The DUP wrecking amendment was defeated with 28 votes for it and 59 against.
The motion thus not amended was passed with 59 in favour and 24 against. We don’t yet have a roll-call of who voted which way but that suggests 59 consistent votes and four who decided to sit on their hands after the amendment was defeated rather than express an opinion.
83 of the 90 MLAs voted. As a backbench bill it will not become law but the clear margin of support should help the government find legislative time to move the issue forward.
BCN says: The discredited quackery in question is neither theraputic nor results in any kind of conversion, yet continues to be promoted as an imaginary solution to the existence of people who are not straight and/or not cis for people who think that this somehow is a problem and one that needs to be solved. Because human sexuality can and does change independently over time there are occasional moments where someone who has undergone it becomes a happy heterosexual, in the same way that a stopped clock tells the right time now and again without being of practical use to anyone wanting to know the time later that day or having any functional mechanism underlying that moment of accuracy. Here’s hoping Stormont approves the motion.
