In an interview with today’s Guardian the former head of the Equality and Human Rights Commission has slated the Johnson government’s equality agenda.
In the autumn of 2019 most MPs who pushed for equality work in the 2015 and 2017 parliaments either announced they would not be standing in the upcoming general election, or defected away to sit and stand variously as Independent, Change or Liberal Democrat.
As such when the December election result was announced, we were unlikely to get an equality minister with an anti-discrimination agenda.
And indeed, we’ve been given Liz Truss instead.
Previous equalities leads each became known for some marginalised group. For Labour’s Harriet Harman it was probably victims of domestic violence. For Conservative Theresa May during her stint before becoming PM, it was women. For Lib Dem equality minister Lynne Featherstone, trans people’s rights.
Liz has instead decided to stand up for and champion white men – both as her policy focus and through appointing them to posts overwhelmingly more often than the proportion of the population they represent.
There are challenging inequalities facing a lot of white men in the UK; but compared to for example biphobia or transphobia they aren’t about being white or male, they’re about poverty and economic inequality and extend much more widely in society.
And so ex-EHRC head David Isaac has lambasted the shift in direction of the EHRC, observing of the new minister that “she says ‘I’ve appointed a new chair and these new commissioners’, and she doesn’t say ‘they’re going to do my bidding’, but it’s pretty implicit in what she’s saying that they are people who are supportive of her approach to equalities, which is a focus on white working-class people and the north of England and the ‘levelling up’ agenda.”
He challenges whether the EHRC will investigate Islamophobia in the Conservative Party in the same way it has challenged anti-Semitism in the Labour Party with a 130-page report released last October looking at the party across four years under Jeremy Corbyn.
The EHRC started badly in 2007, in part through trying to launch work on too many areas of equalities at once but also by being too closely tied to the Labour government and so only listening to a narrow range of voices and vested interests. In a sense the grab for control by the Conservatives now just repeats the mistakes made by Labour in what needs to be a firmly “arms-length” independent body.
