A corner of Twitter this week has been full of fans of a bi-bashing, trans-bashing lobby group promoting the idea that lesbians are “becoming extinct”.
Now although many of our team have dated them over the years, let’s be fair and say that lesbians are not our specialist subject at BCN. But we were pretty sure there are a lot of lesbians out there, as we’ve met tons over the past quarter of a century. If they were becoming extinct that could be worrying, though far more weird than worrying given they have existed for as long as humans. If.
The underlying fictional worry is that lots of people who would otherwise have identified as lesbians are now identifying as trans guys, which takes lesbians away from their tally, but all the people who would have identified as straight guys who have come out as women and as lesbian don’t count for the maths. And thus what was once a huge lesbian community is now down to perhaps a few dozen people nationwide.
Nope, us neither.
It’s a claim coming from people who think – or at least pretend to think – that it’s terrible that cis lesbians might feel socially pressured to pretend they are straight because heterosexuality was the assumption made about them at birth, but that at the same time it’s great to have a bunch of men socially pressured into identifying as women because “female” was the assumption made about them at birth.
Again: nope, we don’t get how you hold both those ideas in your head at once either.
It’s almost as if the people making these arguments started with a chosen conclusion and are trying to work their way backwards to find reasons why they should think that.
There definitely used to be fewer people identifying with some labels like pansexual or genderqueer. Before those words were invented pretty much no-one did. Even now as identities they can be hard to find and feel you have the right to own. Yet if you thought of yourself as straight when growing up, then found the word lesbian and it felt more fitting, then found another even better fitting word such as polysexual for who you had been all along, you weren’t really “lost” to being straight or gay – you never were.
Maybe that’s the problem: as people have more freedom to use labels that fit better, they aren’t being squeezed into the uncomfortablly limited lives and labels of old?
So we went to the experts. The Office for National Statistics collates information every year about the number of bi, gay and lesbian people in the UK. We report on that regularly in our Different For Bis column where we normally focus on the “B” column, naturally. But we went back to their reports and had a look at how the numbers have been shifting.
Taking the last four years for which they have figures:
2015: 1.6% of the population Gay; 0.7% Lesbian; 0.5% Bi Men and 0.8% Bi Women
2016: 1.7% of the population Gay; 0.7% Lesbian; 0.6% Bi Men and 0.9% Bi Women
2017: 1.7% of the population Gay; 0.9% Lesbian; 0.6% Bi Men and 0.9% Bi Women
2018: 1.9% of the population Gay; 0.9% Lesbian; 0.6% Bi Men and 1.1% Bi Women
So the number of women who feel safe to identify as bi is definitely up. Brilliant! And so is the number who feel they can own the word lesbian: 0.7% of people in this country five years ago but 0.9% now. Up by roughly a third. And in a country with a slowly growing population so in raw numbers that will be up a bit more than a third.
But if we consider the UK population to be around 66 million people – that’s something like 600,000 lesbians now, up from 460,000 five years ago.
As Mr Spock’s calmly analytical mind would explain things: “It’s extinction Jim, but not as we know it.”
