Today at the European Commission European Commission Vice-President Věra Jourová (Values and Transparency) and European Commissioner Helena Dalli (Equality) will present the EC’s first-ever LGBTI+ Equality Strategy. This had been announced by President von der Leyen in her 2020 State of the Union Address.
Here’s how it happened.
The Strategy is intended to fight discrimination based on sexual orientation, gender identity and sex characteristics, a daily reality for so many LGBTI people in Europe. It has four main pillars, focused on: tackling discrimination; ensuring safety; building inclusive societies; and leading the call for LGBTIQ equality around the world.
- Fighting discrimination: Legal protection against discrimination is key to advancing LGBTIQ equality. The Commission will undertake a stocktaking exercise, in particular in the area of employment. The report on the application of Employment Equality Directive will be published by 2022. Following up to the report the Commission will put forward any legislation, namely on strengthening the role of equality bodies. The Commission will also put forward a regulatory framework that will specifically address the risk of bias and discrimination inherent in artificial intelligence (AI) systems.
- Ensuring safety: LGBTIQ people disproportionately suffer from hate crime, hate speech and violence while the under-reporting of hate crimes remains a serious problem. To harmonise protection against anti-LGBTIQ hate crime and hate speech, the Commission will present an initiative in 2021 to extend the list of ‘EU crimes’ to include hate crime and hate speech, including when targeted at LGBTIQ people. In addition, the Commission will provide funding opportunities for initiatives that aim to combat hate crime, hate speech and violence against LGBTIQ people.
- Protecting rights of rainbow families: Due to differences in national legislations across Member States, family ties may not always be recognised when rainbow families cross the EU’s internal borders. The Commission will bring forward a legislative initiative on the mutual recognition of parenthood and explore possible measures to support the mutual recognition of same-gender partnership between Member States.
- LGBTIQ equality around the world: In various parts of the world, LGBTIQ people experience serious rights violations and abuses. The Commission will support actions for LGBTIQ equality under the neighbourhood, development and international cooperation instrument (NDICI), the Instrument for Pre-accession Assistance (IPA) and the Asylum and Migration Fund.

12.36 and we are still on the holding screen on the European Broadcast Service presentation. The daily news announcements session at 12.00 ran right up til the last minute which may have led to this slight delay.

12.38 the speakers are here! This is the first ever EU LGBTI equality strategy we are told by Věra Jourová, to tackle inequality faced across Europe.
There is progress in many states on issues such as in marriage, inheritance and so on. But also worrying trends: more than 50% of LGBTI people in the EU are almost never or never open about who they are because they are afraid of the social stigma from coming out, In 2019 nearly 1 in 2 felt discriminated against for being LGBTI. Attacks on pride marches and supposed “LGBTI ideology free zones” and that things may be worse due to Covid lockdown with young people locked into hostile environments at risk of violence or higher rates of depression.
12.40 We need to ensure all in Europe feel safe and can take an active part in society.
First existing laws must be fully applied and respected across all member states and the EC will act. Further there will be a extension of eurocrimes to include homophobic hate crime – including online. Member states must respect cross border family law recognition – when rainbow families cross EU internal borders they may find their child stops being their child and this is not acceptable – this will have to change.
It is not about ideology, or being men or women, it is about love. It is not against anyone, it does not put anyone on a pedestal – it is about safety and non discrimination. In 2020 hate and discrimination against minorities does not belong in Europe today.

12.45 Helena Dalli takes her turn, and explains this is about respecting humanity in all its diversity. This is biology, it is nature, not “ideology”.
We need an EU where all can reach their full potential, building from the base up. This Strategy is “an important milestone to acheiving a Union of equality, where diversity is celebrated as part of our collective richness” so all can be themselves without risk of violence.
We need to reflect on the most marginalised including those facing intersectional discrimination. These are the fourt key actions and objectives:
- discrimination against LGBTI
- ensuring safety
- building inclusive societies
- leading around the world
The strategy aims to combine efforts to improve legal protection against discrimination. For this the EC will ensure rigorous implementation of the employment equality directive
By 2022 the EC will put forward any new legislation needed.
The gender equality directive to be implemented correctly on for example gender reassignment.
Policy making and sharing of best practice will be key – for example with school bullying. The EC needs to address this.
Violence and ‘gay cure’ therapy (“fixing”) has no place in Europe. It needs to be wiped out.
Non-essential medical intervention against intersex people including genital mutilation must end.
11.50 There needs to be action on anti LGBTI hate crime.
But also there needs to be inclusion. For example via implementing the outcomes of case law on things like partnership recognition or parenting recognition: if you are a parent in one country you must be one in all.
We must improve recognition of trans and nonbinary identities. Sex and gender are not two fixed and immutable boxes.
Internationally LGBTI people face persecution, imprisonment or even murder simply for how they were born. The EU’s engagement on LGBTI issues in external relations will improve and LGBTI rights should be enjoyed fully everywhere and at all times. The EC will use all its powers on this: targeted actions and more mainstreaming as well.
LGBTI people’s demand for rights is as much an ideology as the demand for right for cisgender and heterosexual people’s. “LGBTI free zones” are humanity free zones.
Intersectionality will be throughout the strategy including religion, age, and so forth. All stakeholders need to work in tandem on this so the EC is calling for member states, institutions and agencies to work with civil groups and business to help promote this strategy.
All member states are invited to develop their own action plans on LGBTIQ equality – the EC will help review and develop those plans.
“Equal, safe and free to fully participate” is the aim of a union of equality.
11.54 we move to Q&A.
1. Hungarian constitutional changes proposed on family definition that excludes same-sex couples; the mutual recognition of couples within the EU is a ruling 2 years old and still talking not infringement procedures; and finally the idea of funding LGBTI initiatives – what about in states where that is actively opposed and seen as “western ideology”
- Věra Jourová stresses this is not ideology, not Western, it is EU citizens all having equal rights and freedom. Identity is not ideology. Point two needs to be a matter of European law and this is noted in the strategy. And point one in Hungary – EC is aware of this and constitutional changes need to be publicly debated over enough time to acheive consensus with necessary checks and balances. Family law is a member state issue but there are international human rights obligations and EU law. The EC is following developments in Hungary.
2. Two questions again over zoom – the EU list of crimes, this was also announced in September in the racism strategy under article 83 and there would be member state consultation – any responses yet? Secondly, LGBTI free zones – why are you not taking any action such as starting infringement proceedings against Poland? Is existing law inadequate.
- Věra notes the eurocrime process has not yet started as it is under Justice matters. The main aim is for it to be at a European level because some states are not addressing these hate crimes in national law. On the second point, Helena says with Poland there is condemnation of the zones and withdrawal of EU funding of projects in those areas, but there needs to be a clear legal basis for legal action.
3. Returning to Hungary, part of the proposal there is around the right of children to self determine gender as well as on a “Christian” values education. How to reconcile the EC actions in member states where LGBTI identities might not even be recognised for young people? Also in 2022 – so far such bodies has been a recommendation, will this be mandatory or less strong an institutional push? Thirdly, on the Polish zones the cutting of funding was hailed but no mention of the policy not to fund anti-LGBTI projects across the Union, would this have been a helpful signal and why is it not there.
- Helena says schools need to uphold equality for all students and the people there are the future adult society – a union of equality must look at and share best practices in education. Otherwise we will not have “a generation of adults to whom equality is a no-brainer”. See the EU FRA surveys on bullying in schools – even suicide attempts due to being othered as different. We can have a union of equality if we do not address the minority of schools which do not uphold values of equality and nondiscrimination. (It’s a passionate answer but does not seem to promise that there can really be action). On the equality bodies the EC will put forward any legislation required which may include equality bodies and she recognises that not all governments deliver on the legislation equality bodies consider needed.
- Věra- “I believe education is the only way to get rid of… hatred and discrimination”. We are not offering propaganda or promotion, we are about the basic understanding of human reality. Some languages are a challenge lacking different words for sex and gender. That linguistic issue raises problems with understanding. On equality bodies Věra would like legislation to set a clear basis for them including in funding security. This will be an important step forward beyond “soft law” and the detail is not yet clear. It’s untrue on the third point – respect for fundamental rights being the enabling condition for funding is set out in the document. No infringement procedure because they are just local declarations and this is a legalistic issue with how the infringement procedure works. More evidence is needed before the EC can act.
12.15 Another set of questions
4. First on mutual recognition of parenthood – how will this be delivered? New law or better enforcement of what we have? Second – the funding and the LGBTI free zones: the EC decided to withdraw some small grants but in that case these areas should not be eligible for more general funding such as cohesion funding?
- Věra takes part two there. It will be a matter of analysis if the non-compliance can be grounds to freeze funding, it is more in the field of law, justice and fighting crime. It needs to be clear where we have legal power to take action. But for concrete projects where the area is noncompliant – there is some nuance here. It will be case by case. On mutual recognition it will be international private and family law, which needs unanimity under the treaty, failing that there is enhanced co-operation as a less welcome approach. 21 states recognise some kind of same-sex partnership but not all recognise adopted children. That is not a credible thing across Europe.
- Helena reiterates that it is not sensible that crossing a border can change whether you are a parent. Similarly – the EU funding projects that go against EU values seems a simple question.
- Věra adds a practical point from 20 years working on EU funding. Where the EU requires a tickbox on equal opportunities, it was just ticking a box and everyone did and it was accepted. That time has gone. We did not see trends such as in Poland then, so now the audit bodies and such need to check beyond a tickbox to whether there are really those kind of principles in place.
12.20 A short set more questions:
5. One question – if you could tell us which countries do not yet have national plans for LGBTIQ?
- Helena says: we are not here to name and shame member states. We want to encourage them to be inclusive. To help and naming at this point will not help.
6. A question on antisemitism – held back to be the last question at the request of the questioner.
7. If discrimination should be wiped out and that also means in the religious field – given recent proposals to have training for Imams to end hate speech. Will there be similar things for other religious denominations? Or should the EU only act in the secular sphere?
- Helena is not aware of the proposal but to build an inclusive society we need to respect religious ideas of others and other such difference – except where they come to promoting violence and so forth. Diversity is a strength of the EU. Věra adds that in six years in the Commission working on human rights, she encountered three areas where religion came up. Freedom, which is enshrined in legislation. Second seeking a good dialogue with the churches as key leaders in public discourse to understand key parts of our society. And thirdly, closer to the question, we funded for example projects to de-radicalise for young Islamists to tackle terror issues. We noted radicalisation was moving online but also into places like prisons. We called for national security bodies to identify such places and act against those Imams who were working to radicalise young people to turn them into killers. We have seen more recent attacks and must not close our eyes to it.
- Helena adds that “there is no place for violence and this is what it boils down to”.
6. Back to the question about how the same people who incite antisemitic hate and anti-LGBTI hate tend to be the same bigots. When things are not going the right way in courts or national authorities do not act. There are some hard line antisemitic front pages in Greece this week. It is shameful to see and surely violates state and European laws on hate speech. Why is there not action over so many years? These are the same papers as incite distrust of Covid vaccines by trying to link them to their antisemitic propaganda. Things are left to go despite the laws.
- Věra says this is indeed an alarming question again. The Jews and LGBTI people share a place – being in the same basket of citizens who are traditional targets of attacks from some sources. Far left and far right. What should we do when there is no action? For the – still – democractic states, the main task is to protect their citizens be that LGBTI or Jewish or other targeted groups. Where they fail the EC can have dialogue but cannot make national police or prosecutors to take action or control national courts. On anti-Semitism the EC does what it can to press states and has increased budgets to work on these issues. She cannot comment on cases she does not already know details of but where are the rest of the local media that could speak up and not be passive? European history shows activity by some and passivity by others led to the Holocaust.
They wrap up and mask back up. We are done.
