Bi Media Watch

Batwoman came to E4 this spring. It is groundbreaking for a mainstream superhero show in making the lead a queer character: Ruby Rose stars as Kate Kane / Batwoman, giving network telly its first openly gay female lead of a superhero show.

It’s all set three years after Batman has mysteriously disappeared. Gotham is in despair, overrun by criminal gangs. If you liked all the peculiar villains and plot arcs of Gotham then this is going to be right up your (dark, foreboding, downtown) alley.

We get – perhaps – bi representation too in the form of love interest Sophie (Meagan Tandy) who finds her way back into Kate’s life, now married to a man but clearly carrying a torch.
In a surprise twist show lead Ruby Rose quit the show at the end of its first season. For the next season – whenever that can safely be made – bi actress Javicia Leslie will take over the role of Batwoman but as a different character, Ryan Wilder. A new woman in the bat costume so will there be a future in the story for Sophie?

Ruby Rose as Batwoman

Netflix drama The Politician returned for a second season. Our …hero?… Payton continues his journey to ever greater power, this time with the power bi move of realising fellow political hack Astrid might pose a threat to his rising star and inviting her – at girlfriend Alice’s suggestion – to join their relationship and turn it into a throuple.

Naturally all does not go well with this plan but it’s not the only three-way relationship in the programme, which might not be a new or creative way of presenting bisexuality on screen but gets the idea across in big neon letters for the viewers and throws some of the problems in keeping a poly relationship balanced into the mix.

Meanwhile Payton’s mother is developing political ambitions of her own: what do you do when your mom takes up your favourite hobby and proves rather better at it than you?

The series ends on a clear setup for a third season, and though the pandemic might delay the production I hope it gets made. Not least to find out if my pet theory that campaign aide McAfee will turn out to be the real power player of the story pans out.

Speaking of Netflix: Disclosure isn’t a bi documentary but it so nearly of could be: in giving the best part of two hours to how trans representation has evolved over decades.

“For years, the ways trans people have been represented on screen have suggested that we are not real, have suggested that we are mentally ill, have suggested that we do not exist,” opines Laverne Cox in this feature-film length documentary. You could so easily write that sentence about bis too. Further as the programme then talks about how when we are not out, perhaps not even to ourselves, our ears nonetheless perk up and we “lean in” to pay attention to the stories about people like us on television – even when all the representation that exists is a joke that reinforces the bullying or invisibility of the rest of our lives.

And there’s a shared message on the importance of people who are able to be, being out, as Alexandra Grey says: “you never know what those positive images do for other people”.

Also in factual TV was the BBC’s Storyville: Welcome to Chechnya – the Gay Purge. This is available on iPlayer til next year, and there can be few LGBT programmes more harrowing: watch with care.

THE BABY-SITTERS CLUB

For a happier mood, over to kids TV and The Baby-Sitters Club which dropped onto Netflix at the start of July, based on the 80s/90s books but mapped to life in… well, okay, not today’s pandemic world but life in 2019. It’s a simple enough story where a bunch of young women decide to organise their profitable baby-sitting work into a collective so they don’t compete over earnings and parents can always find a sitter.

There are small sprinkles of queer content in a consciously family-friendly show that is aimed mainly at a pre-teen/teen market. Same-sex attraction is casually dropped into a conversation without any raised eyebrows, while one episode does that all-too-rare thing of a trans character actually being played by a trans actor (somebody page Hollywood that this can actually be done). For my money it was an unusually well-done trans plotline, particularly in not going with the usual flow of showing active and hostile transphobia. There’s enough of that in the real world, people don’t need to be shown how to do it. Instead it’s a “how to be an ally” for young viewers and I may have had a little something in my eye towards the end.

Dead to Me

Dead To Me came back for a second run on Netflix, and Judy (Linda Cardellini) falls for a woman – Michelle, played by Natalie Morales who was last seen as the lead in the delightful but short-lived Abby’s.

Up ’til now we have only seen Judy dating men so it was another of those ‘whoop, whoop, we got another bi’ moments. Judy’s “I’m dating someone new, and it’s not of the gender you were expecting” conversation with the other lead character Jen is pleasingly calm and accepting.

Show director Liz Feldman gave an interview to refinery29 website that left me with mixed feelings though. “It was very intentional to never name it or label it or talk about it like it was a big deal,” she explained, adding that as a lesbian she has seen too many coming out stories and “for my own sense of freshness, I was like, let’s not label it”.

On the one hand a lot of folx don’t label things one way or another, but on the other it feels like something of a cop-out, not giving voice to often invisible and erased bisexuality and appealing to a gay audience who can read Judy as having switched from straight to gay. Creative directing or a queerbaiting ruse?

The third run of BiMediaWatch favourite The Good Place has reached E4 for viewers who don’t have Netflix. Since making the show Jameela Jamil (Tahani) has come out as bisexual, and the flirty interplay between her character and Eleanor (Kristen Bell) is one of many treats about the show. It also gives nonbinary people something of a screen hero in D’Arcy Carden’s Janet, who may date guys and be read as a woman but reminds us regularly they are Not A Girl. Will it ever be heard?

In other “shows you missed” opportunities, Chewing Gum has done the opposite trip from E4 to Netflix. The programme is a comedy centred on a 24 year old woman (Tracey, played by Michaela Coel) trying to break out of the mindset of her restrictive, deeply religious upbringing, becoming more worldly and especially having sex before marriage. Season 1 episode 4 dabbles in bi representation that may have you shouting at the telly for how many negative tropes you can fit into a scene.