Will and Grace has dipped into bisexuality again, with an episode called “Bi-Plane”. The show has variously teased and frustrated us with its take on bisexuality since its return to the screen two years ago, so we approached this one with some trepidation.
Over in the USA the programme is a season ahead of the UK, so this one is in our future for most BCN readers – but as the programme works its way through its very last season, it has given us one last dalliance with bisexual representation.
With delicious irony it was a special episode after the programme skipped a week to make room for the triple-length series finale of The Good Place, which has had reams of bisexuality.
Spoilers ahead.
There is a thing TV programme scriptwriters do which I’ve heard called having an “a-plot” and a “b-plot”.  You tell two stories which may or may not meet at the end, allowing character development for a wider cast without them all having to be on the same adventure. It helps create a sense of time passing between scenes within each of the two tales. This one – season eleven, episode nine – has a second plot line set on a plane, but from the point of view of BCN we are all about the one on terra firma. It’s technically the a-plot, but it is a very “B” plot.
Grace’s twentysomething neice Fiona comes to visit, bringing with her a musical-loving male friend Trevor.  Will and Grace immediately read the pair as just like themselves at the same age – straight woman and gay best friend.
When Fiona and Trevor reveal they are in a relationship Trevor explains:
“You thought I was gay, everyone does. I’m not.  I mean, I do sleep with men. But I also sleep with women.”
And in a handy moment of out-loud subtitles for the hard of thinking at home Fiona chimes in, “he’s bi.”
In a moment Will is snarking behind their backs that “bisexuality isn’t even a thing, it’s like saying ‘I’m a cat person and a dog person. Come on, you know what you want licking your face’.” The four rapidly split into two pairs for private conversations about it all, man-to-man and woman-to-woman, as the grown-ups decide to prevent a wedding from happening.
Will explains to Trev, “There was a period of time I thought I was bisexual.”
“How tragic,” comes the reply. “I mean – you are so gay. You have a whole bookshelf of books about butts.” This is a comedy show remember folks, so you need to roll with the gender and sexuality stuff being in primary colours.
“The thing is, saying you are bi can feel like a safe half-step when you are scared to jump all the way in. But you know – deep down you’re either a cat person or a dog person.”
“I’m more of a bird person.”
In the next room, Grace is being similarly patronising to her niece.
“You know, Will and I dated way back.”
“I didn’t know Will was bisexual?”
“Oh no he was just gay and I was into guys who liked to clean and pick out my outfits.”
Grace explains how Will always avoided sex and how this has led to her having a host of hangups about her body, without any reflection on how this might have been a bad thing for her overall.
“Wow, you really couldn’t pick up on clues could you?”
“Is everything okay in the bedroom?” probes Grace, expecting the same sexless dimension to Fiona’s teenage life as she had experienced. Fiona complains that yes, it is terrible… as Trevor wants sex with her so much. Grace is rather nonplussed.
We shift to a four-way conversation as the show’s gay and straight leads try to take down this alien bisexuality thing one more time.
“There’s just a big thing missing,” explains Will, “and that is: Trevor, you’re not bisexual, you’re gay. And Fiona, you’re kidding yourself. We’ve been where you are.”
Grace tries to agree with both sides.
Fiona charges in: “How can you say he’s not bisexual? He’s dated more women than I have, and a lot of those women have dated a lot of the guys he has dated.”
“What the hell is going on out there!?” yelps Will. Ah, those crazy kids nowadays.
Grace tries to conciliate again explaining that Will is just saying that “if a man is attracted to men, he might be gay” and that you might marry a woman but you’ll still be attracted to men. Trevor declares any monogamous relationship to involve there being other people in the world you may be attracted to, and that you are making a choice to not be with many people regardless of your sexual orientation.
And that Will should respect that as, “the B is right in the middle of the LGBTQ!”
I knew there was a reason we’d moved to five letters.
“I refuse to acknowledge the B,” declaims Will. “The Bs and the Qs haven’t figured out if they are L or G yet.” Grace tries to sound more conciliatory but comes down on Will’s side before having their biphobia ripped into by their guests because her life experience was about someone being really gay.
I’ve seen this episode criticised online as being biphobic, but I really don’t think so. People alas still say and think these things, or have them as never-thought-through ideas they have picked up from society. If we never allow those bi-erasing ideas to be voiced on screen, we never get the chance to take them apart: by doing so this episode gave a bunch of bi and bi-ally viewers some rebuttals to memorise ready for when the biphobia hits the fan.
When the twentysomethings leave, Grace and Will sit down and reflect that they have been the bigots that used to drive them mad. The younger people really win this one.
It’s good to see a generational divide exposed like this. Will and Grace are both convinced there is ‘no such thing as bi’ because of their own story and the received wisdom from their youth, and from the platform of TV their story has helped reinforce the idea of “bi now, gay later”.
It’s notable the gay man / straight woman pairing have got the gaydar to spot Trevor’s queer man signals but are oblivious to Fiona’s bisexuality until it is spoken: the Will & Grace audience have been trained over the previous ten seasons in a set of gay signals that are all about gay men, so coding Fiona as queer for them would have taken a lot more work.
In a sidenote it’s interesting how the programme’s scriptwriters feel they can leave the B and Q challenged for legitimacy but to leave the T out.
This is tackling biphobia in an older generation of gay culture – and keeping on that message for about two thirds of the episode’s screen time.
Will & Grace is not the ratings monster it was in its early days, when it played a key role in normalising gay characters on TV with friends, sex lives and a hunkering for romance. With so many channels now, nothing is.
But in 2020 still has a big following and fond familiarity for an older generation, and presenting this thorough slap-down to biphobia and bi-erasure could be a helpful step in both American and gay culture. I don’t know about the backstory to this episode but I like to think that a few scriptwriters did some serious learning on how to improve on their past form. It feels to me like they did.
Sadly the show got canned at the end of season eleven, so we won’t get to see more of Fiona & Trevor. But they will forever be there on the end of the boxset of the show, signaling to a gay and gay-friendly America that the certainties of gay life when the show began in 1998 no longer hold.

 


This originally appeared in print in BCN issue 161, published in June 2020.

To get BCN magazine direct to your door six times a year subscribe.