The European Court of Justice today ruled against psychological testing being used to determine sexual orientation of asylum seekers applying for sanctuary in European countries, including the UK.
Their top-line ruling is that, “An asylum seeker may not be subjected to a psychological test in order to determine his sexual orientation,” the ruling states – legalese that applies regardless of gender. “The performance of such a test amounts to a disproportionate interference in the private life of the asylum seeker.”
The case came about because of the rejection of an asylum seeker from Nigeria who sought to live in Hungary because it was not safe to be a gay man in his home country.
For the individual this means his case will be re-assessed in Hungary, and for other asylum seekers it means no more ink-blot tests to work out whether you are bisexual, gay or straight. The court does not rule that these have no value – simply that they involve an unacceptable level of personal interference and in a situation where the challenging situation of fleeing and seeking asylum means the individual being assessed may not be able to fairly choose to give their informed consent.
Instead immigration services need to be able to assess people in person and to have staff able to understand bisexuality and homosexuality adequately, says the court:
“The Court also notes that the preparation of a psychologist’s expert report seeking to determine an
asylum seeker’s sexual orientation is not essential for the purpose of assessing the credibility of his
statements relating to his sexual orientation. In that regard, the Court states that, under the Directive, in a situation in which the asylum seeker’s sexual orientation is not substantiated by documentary evidence, the national authorities, which must have personnel with the appropriate skills, may rely, inter alia, on the consistency and plausibility of the statements of the person concerned. Moreover, the reliability of that report is, at best, only limited, with the result that its usefulness for the purpose of assessing the credibility of the statements of an asylum seeker may be questioned, in particular where, as is the case here, the statements of the asylum seeker are not contradictory.”
