For the past three and a half years, and as part of completing my Doctorate in Counselling Psychology, I have been engaged in conducting research that aimed at exploring how women construct meanings of their bisexual experiences in the context of their relationships. The initial reasons leading to my interest in the area of bisexuality were personal and professional experience, while the specific research question was the result of reviewing the literature in this field and identifying a gap.
As a woman who has been in relationships with men and women, and although I do not use the term bisexual to identify my sexuality, I have experienced varied reactions from straight men and lesbian partners to my bisexual experiences. This naturally made me wonder about others’ experiences and the underlying assumptions about bisexuals. In addition, and while undertaking a placement over two years at a Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Trans (LGBT) charity organisation I never encountered a bisexual-identified client or clients with bisexual experiences, which led me to wonder about the possible reasons behind this.
Using a qualitative method of inquiry I interviewed nine participants who had all been in at least one intimate and sexual relationship with partners of multiple genders. The interview questions used in the research primarily included:
How do you identify your gender and sexuality, and what led to that identification? Or not?
Tell me about the different types of intimate and sexual relationships you have had?
What does it mean to you to have different types of intimate and sexual relationships?
How would you describe yourself (attitudes, behaviours…) when you are in a relationship with a woman? And when you are in a relationship with a man? Or individuals of other genders?
How do you experience the shift from a relationship with one partner to another?
Could you tell me about how your previous and/or current partners react to your bisexual experiences?
The aim of asking these questions was to generate a theory grounded in the data rather than test an existing hypothesis that could explicate how women make meanings of their bisexual experiences in different types of relationships. The data analysis resulted in the emergence of three main categories: category one, spatial negotiation of sexual self, category two, prism of experiences; refractions through an-other, and category three, techniques of the relationship. These three categories were integrated by examining the relations, intersections and interactions amongst them, leading to the identification of the basic social process, spatial negotiation, underpinning the participants’ experiences.
The categories represent the three primary themes that explain and account for the final emergent theory. Category one primarily reflects how participants have negotiated their sexual self in a process describing the change from heterosexual to non-heterosexual identifications. This category accounted for how the participants have discovered and explored their bisexual attractions through questioning heterosexuality and learning and understanding about other sexualities, which resulted in either rejecting the use of a sexual identity or embracing one. This incorporated properties involving their age and how they experienced maturing and self-acceptance in relation to their families, cultures, and previous as well as current intimate and sexual relationships. These properties further influenced how they understood, defined and lived their sexualities. In return the negotiation of sexual self was interrelated with their emotional and sexual experiences throughout their lives with partners of multiple sexualities and genders, the theme comprising category two.
Category two, prism of experiences; refractions through an-other, reflected how the participants made sense of and understood their sexual, physical and emotional experiences in relationships. Several properties were identified underlying this process such as how the participants understood their genders as well as their partners’ genders in relation to bodies, constructions of gender and gender roles, as well as dominant notions of femininity and masculinity in an overall heteronormative society. This pointed to a parallel process occurring between categories one and two, which shows the move from heterosexual to non-heterosexual identifications based on negotiations of sexual self in relation to the emotional and sexual experiences that were further negotiated through partners. These experiences have shaped the participants’ current preferences for bisexual partners due to experiencing more satisfying relationships as a result of sharing values, views and beliefs that allow them to experience sexual visibility, an intelligible and authentic identity in relation to their bisexual attractions, and an overall acceptance of who they are.
The ways in which the sexual, emotional and social experiences are negotiated in a relationship account for the techniques employed and form category three. Category three, techniques of the relationship, represents the process of partners’ preferences changing over the participants’ lives with current preferences being for bisexual partners. The process evolved based on previous unsatisfactory emotional experiences with lesbian and straight men partners embedded in the prevalent biphobic discourses, and leading to current relationships with bisexual partners being built on shared values. In addition, this included a move from being primarily involved in a heterosexual environment to homosexual and or/bisexual environment, and further resulted in more visibility and experiences of satisfying relationships.
Linking the three main categories and forming their foundation was the social process of spatial negotiation. The process of spatial negotiation reflects how the participants have been continuously constructing meanings of their bisexual experiences leading to their current relationships being the contemporary site for these negotiations. These dimensions incorporate properties from all categories illustrating how the participants are constructing their current relationships with their partners of preference based on the interrelations between how they experience their sexualities, how they experience their partners emotionally, physically and sexually, and how these are negotiated in their current relationships allowing them to achieve geater satisfaction. Hence, the process of spatial negotiation accounts for how actions, feelings and behaviours are constructed and organised in forming relationships.
The process of spatial negotiation was further divided into four dimensions each reflecting the specific properties involved in the three categories. However, all four dimensions are interrelated and interdependent upon each other. Self-with-self negotiation includes aspects relating to the internal negotiation that occurs at all times and changes throughout an individual’s life. Self-with-society negotiation accounts for how meanings are negotiated based on societal factors such as gender views, upbringing in the family and influences of heteronormative and non-heteronormative communities on the further constructions and negotiations of meanings. Self-with-partner relates to the specific experiences with partners throughout the individual’s life, which in their turn have been negotiated throughout. Finally, self-with-relationship is more specific to the contemporary relationships with bisexual partners based on continuous negotiations resulting in the achievement of the individual’s desired state of being. Hence, the final theory emerged as means of joining the three categories and the spatial negotiations together.
The final theory suggests that women’s bisexual experiences in contemporary relationships are constructed within a sphere of spatial negotiations geared towards facilitating the achievement of their desired sexual, emotional and social existence with bisexual partners. This desired state varies individually, yet appears to integrate aspects of visibility, authenticity and belonging based on shared values, beliefs and views with partners.
Joyce Chedid
